Which Pic?

[cA70]

I'm gonna blow up one of my images for some people i know of there home town, but i can't decide which one.

http://images.fotopic.net/?id=1024521&outx=600&oq=0
OR (with there niece in top right)
http://images.fotopic.net/?id=1024523&outx=600&oq=0

My plan is to go to 8x10inc and frame it.
I do have the origional LrgSupFne pic on computer, but makes quicker viewing on the net.

Any advice on which would look better blown up or not?

And i believe that photography is about what you like, so what i like others might not, so i figure i should ask some people in the know and get a general opinion.

If these collections dont work they can be found at http://a70.fotopic.net/show_collection.php?id=44600

And if that link doesn't work, the main page is in my sign, and its in the locations collection. Deciding between Morning Mist and Sunrise with waves.

[speedy_gonzales]

I like the second one better. Both good pics though

[cA70]

Thats my fav, but i didn't know if the contrast between the yellow shy and the to under exposed rocks was to much.

thanks

[John_T]

I say both. Both are excellent and opposite.

You choose, because it is something of you that you want to share with others.

Only one thing in the first one. Remove the white dot (window reflection?) in the right middle. It grabs your eye and you lose the mood of the scene.

[A_Candid_Goodbye]

first off, both photos are great but b/c the gold sky is so bright and the water and rock of the scenery below is harder to make out. if you choose to take the pic to digi darkroom and darken, and soften the sky i think it would be a super photo. but b/c of the richness of the golden sky i will have to go with the first. Please remember this is just an opinion. i think both are great. keep it up!