PDA

View Full Version : My experiences with Smartdisk Photobank 40GB


darkvibe
15th of June 2006 (Thu), 19:36
3 weeks ago I needed some extra storage. I bought the 40GB smartdisk image bank because I found it locally. I got it home and tried using it. I could not get it to connect to the computer 9 out of 10 times. It kept shutting off. Once I did get it to randomly connect my computer told me that I had a USB 2.0 device plugged into a USB 1.1 hub. Funny since I have a Lexar media reader in the same port running at 2.0 speeds. Updated drivers, no change. I don't think it's my computer causing the problem if another device works fine with the same port and cord. I called tech support and spoke with someone who did not seem to have a clue what the problems were being caused by. We determined that I should return it and try another unit.

Got the new unit home and it connected fine. No shutting off issues this time but it still would not read/write at USB 2 speeds. Took it to a friend's house and it worked fine there. I'm upgrading my computer soon so I can live with it for now and hope it works on the new computer.

I used it for about 2 weeks, x-fering about 20GB of data at USB 1.1 speeds, taking about 3 hours to dump a day of shooting onto my desktop. Today I deleted everything from it and emptied the recycle bin. The unit still reads 20GB free. I called tech support (I might add they are very friendly and helpful) and describe the problem. Apparently it is a bug and they are aware of it and working on a fix. A firmware update may be available but she did not sound certain. She gave me two options. Format it on a Mac (which i do not have access to) or format the drive with a format utility. Windows will not allow a 40GB drive to be formatted in FAT32 and the unit will not work if you format in NTFS. After looking for a free format utility I gave up and packed it back in the box. It's going back for a refund.

Sorry for the long post. I just thought I would share my experience with the product. I'm disappointed that they would ship a product that I feel was not tested throughly enough. Although their tech support was helpful every time I called, I paid $180 for this so i expect it to work. Time to start searching for a different brand.

I urge everyone to avoid this thing at least until they get the bugs worked out.

Chris Johnson 00 T/A
15th of June 2006 (Thu), 19:45
http://hyperdrive.com/ ;)

kevbailey
12th of July 2006 (Wed), 05:05
I purchased the photobank last week and mine works perfect. I'm glad I had it. I ended up shooting just over 2900 shots in 4 days.

Kevin

psykoko
12th of July 2006 (Wed), 08:03
i have the fotochute smartdisk 20Go.
I never have any problem...
Do you try to format it?

darkvibe
20th of July 2006 (Thu), 20:48
Do you try to format it?

I couldn't, that was the whole problem. A fresh format in FAT32 would clear the unit but windows XP can not format a drive that large (over 32GB?) unless you use NTFS, which is useless. A mac would have worked, or a 3rd party utility which I could not find after a few mins of searching. I figured I paid for a product, I want it to work right, not some workaround that I need to do every time I delete photos from it. They still haven't released a firmware update to correct it and it's been over a month since i called and they told me that they knew about the bug and were working on it.

While I was using it to dump flash cards to and xfer to the computer I loved it. It worked perfectly. It's just the glitch that would not clear the memory reading when I deleted photos from it. This would have given me the disk full error when i got to 37GB.

I'm now the proud owner of a 40GB hyperdrive and couldn't be happier.

lostdoggy
20th of July 2006 (Thu), 21:39
I might be wrong but I formated my 120GB EXT HDD w/ window XP. I believe 160GB is the Limit for FAT32, then again I might be wrong.

There are free utility that you can download one is Maxtor and its usually shipped w/ HDD.

psykoko
21st of July 2006 (Fri), 08:31
yep !
use maxtor or an other soft !
I'm sure you can save your disk

amaphiyarden
13th of March 2009 (Fri), 11:42
If your looking to Re Format the PhotoBank here is the Software. After SmartDisk was sold to Virbatim a year ago Its been impossible to find this software. I found it on my PC recently and decided to share it on the net... Good Luck http://yardenreport.blogspot.com/