Sunset Mountain

[MidKnight]

First off, thanks for looking and making comments.

What i need is any comments you wish to make, and i also need to know which is your favourite, or the best of the 3, and why?

thanks

http://www.midknight.com.au/temp/

[Cobra351]

First off you've captured some incredible looking sunsets, nice job!
I really like all the pictures, they all show great moments in nature, but I especially like the last two. I like these because of the sizes of the land and clouds in each, they both look roughly equal with a small amount of sky in between. It's probably just me, but I think this symmetry looks good.
Nice pictures again.

[GPR1]

I, on the other hand, like the first one best, because there is still a bit of detail in the shadowy foreground. In all three the composition lacks impact. I would have preferred less foreground and more clouds. That's my two cents worth.

Greg

[Warman]

You captured a nice sky there, the clouds realy look like they have volume. I just think that you should lose half of the picture, i mean, its just black space and adds nothing to the composition.
The first photo with only a strip of black and the elevation against the sunset would make it a realy good composition. Try a few crops and show us what you come up with.

[MidKnight]

ok i croped them, and agree looks much better. (c = cropped) my fav is #2 (3314c)

but then again, i love the sky in #3317c

[KO_300D]

great pics! The croppings are better. I particularly like 17c, but it's caught between a full size pic and a wide, landscaped shot. I'd consider cropping a small amount of the sky off the top (as it's not as detailed as the rest of the clouds) and then you've got yourself a landscaped sunset picture. Hope my 2 cents worth is worth it's value!