PDA

View Full Version : question re: 70-200 choices


NoviDave
15th of October 2006 (Sun), 20:47
Another newbie question that has probably been beat to death but I need real world experience.

Brother gave me his old original rebel (300d?) with a very nice lense. Kinda like a drug dealer. The first taste is free. Now I have the bug to spend some money on upgrades. I was planning on picking up the canon 70-200 f/4 L series. Sounds great. Then I read all the posts here (damn you! damn you all!) and everyone seems to be in love with the 2.8's. Since I plan to shoot A LOT in hockey rinks, I'm sure the 2.8 is the better choice, but as I am a NEWBIE, that's a LOT more money than I want to spend right now.

So, do you think I will love the L series f/4 or should I spend a little more and get the Sigma f/2.8 (about $300 more).

Obvously I'm hoping you will all say "you'll love the f/4" but I guess I need real world advise.

Thanks everyone. Great site. Been here only a couple days and I'm a couple of grand in the hole (did I mention the 30D?)

QF-347
15th of October 2006 (Sun), 21:00
if your shooting in low light alot. you would be better gettting the Sigma 70-200 f2.8
its a lil more expensive than the canon f4 but you wont regret it im sure :)

Cam

JVL
15th of October 2006 (Sun), 21:05
I'm holding out for the Canon 70-200mm f/2.8 IS, also a newbie, I've looked at things like the 70-300mm f/4 IS and the Sigma's, something is irresistably drawing me to the canon f/2.8. It could be the near perfect reviews I always read on it. I know that, once I buy it, it's a lens that I won't mind having (and if I do the re-sale is always high). Anyway, that's my few months worth of thinking about this same issue.

codex0
15th of October 2006 (Sun), 21:07
I'd say go for the Sigma 2.8. It's my favorite lens that I've held/used. Period.

Some images I've shot with it (not embedding for those that don't want to scroll through pictures):
http://www.codex0.info/photo/albums/upload/Susquehanna/Day%206/IMG_2911.jpg
http://www.codex0.info/photo/albums/upload/music%20man%20sat/IMG_1114.jpg
http://www.codex0.info/photo/albums/userpics/10001/IMG_6461.jpg
http://www.codex0.info/photo/albums/upload/a%20cappella%20sampler/Shades%20of%20Blue/_MG_0422.jpg
http://www.codex0.info/photo/albums/upload/music%20man%20sat/IMG_0318.jpg
http://www.codex0.info/photo/albums/userpics/10001/IMG_5377.jpg