Canon EF-S 17-55mm F/2.8 IS USM

[Ronald S. Jr.]

Ronald, I am not so sure that there is much drop in contrast and colour. Definitely not a HUGE difference between my 70-200 2.8 IS and my 17-55. Bokeh is definitely not AMAZING on the 17-55 but its decent. See a few of my shots above for examples :D

I think the color rendition difference is noticeable enough that I could probably pick which came from which, and the bokeh with specular highlights isn't very nice compared to the brick.

As far as the contrast, it does have some, but I remember not having to add contrast most of the time with the brick, whereas now it's a standard part of processing. Not a big deal, but it's one more step, you know?

[ErikM]

Ya I know where you are coming from. I prefer my images to be quite contrasty so I always end up adding some here and there :D

[2gDSM]

http://farm1.static.flickr.com/190/517469205_c1ffbeb588_o.jpg

RAW conversion only--I think it's got enough contrast and colors for me :)

[ekie]

http://ekkizsikk.info/photography/d/15665-1/_MG_3923.jpg

turbooooooo :D

[Dorman]

I just went through all 21 pages of this thread, some spectacular images in here (special mention to Erik!)... I'm convinced and I'll be ordering this lens in the near future. I'll be hanging on to my 17-40 for awhile until I'm 100% convinced the 17-55 can do everything just as well. Thanks alot fellas, my wallet hates you!

[ErikM]

Thanks Dorman, much appreciated!! I am quite sure you're gonna love this lens :) Post some shots when you get it!

[ErikM]

Here is a recent image of a friend... just messing around :D

f2.8

http://www.netengine.ca/photos/June8_07/pino2.jpg

[ErikM]

http://www.netengine.ca/photos/June8_07/soobsJune8_07.jpg

[syntrix]

bugeyes FTW! fap fap, you on nabisco erik?

[ErikM]

Ya I am a member but I rarely visit these days...

I do love bug eyes but I own the red RS, no bugs eyes! ;)

[Marydoright]

Roundhouse! My boys thought it was life size Thomas the Tank Engine! :)

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v340/marydoright/Fun%20Digi%20Cam%20Pics/Henry%20Ford%20Museum%20June%202007/HenryFordMuseumJune2007012copy.jpg

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v340/marydoright/Fun%20Digi%20Cam%20Pics/Henry%20Ford%20Museum%20June%202007/HenryFordMuseumJune2007015copy.jpg

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v340/marydoright/Fun%20Digi%20Cam%20Pics/Henry%20Ford%20Museum%20June%202007/HenryFordMuseumJune2007018copy.jpg

[magik306]

Here is my contribution to this thread.

40mm @ F4

[/URL][URL="http://imageshack.us"]http://img452.imageshack.us/img452/535/cleangavinsmallir3.jpg (http://photography-on-the.net/forum/%5BURL=http://imageshack.us%5D%5BIMG%5Dhttp://img452.imageshack.us/img452/535/cleangavinsmallir3.jpg%5B/IMG%5D%5B/URL%5D)

[AustinWolf]

I love this lens... one of my first shots out of this lens...

http://farm1.static.flickr.com/135/320771833_20fdf7d569.jpg

Just flipping throught the photos, wasting my time in this place as usual. Had to say, this is a WONDERFUL shot.

[Dorman]

Erik, no problem, credit is given where credit is due! I certainly will post up some images, I've got a deal in the works to get my hands on one and I hope it will go through.

[divinemethod]

I've been having sexy time with this lens ;)

http://divinemethod.zenfolio.com/img/v0/p1040184620-4.jpg
http://divinemethod.zenfolio.com/img/v0/p930045283-4.jpg

[syntrix]

Black car theme!!! 54mm f/2.8

http://deviantspeed.com/gallery/d/7996-2/IMG_3268.jpg

[metalsaber]

Here are a couple from the Wings Over Pittsburgh Air Show that I took on Saturday.

http://www.metalsaber.com/images/wings_over_pittsburgh/wings_over_pittsburgh16.jpg

http://www.metalsaber.com/images/wings_over_pittsburgh/wings_over_pittsburgh15.jpg

http://www.metalsaber.com/images/wings_over_pittsburgh/wings_over_pittsburgh12.jpg

[forno]

Trying out my new battery grip last night

http://www.forno.smugmug.com/photos/164127096-L.jpg

[ZekaG]

A few from me:
(Oh how I love this lens)

http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1402/557430632_ab93803d02.jpg

http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1184/552943991_25c90c166b.jpg

http://farm1.static.flickr.com/214/465813204_1bac0de964.jpg

[suyenfung]

37mm, f5.6, no sharpening

http://www.jarredwagner.com/photos/cdpf/07.06.23_12.44.37.jpg
http://www.jarredwagner.com/photos/cdpf/07.06.23_12.44.37.100.jpg

[forno]

^^^cracker shot:cool: :cool:

My little guy 52mm f/2.8

http://www.forno.smugmug.com/photos/165723150-L.jpg

[joonlee]

Some pics from Marineland, Ontario, Canada....

http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1154/677639423_c42f46ebec_o.jpg

http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1023/677630401_530c78d2be_o.jpg

http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1033/677630297_42f20d4d5e_o.jpg

[starmage]

Hi All, I'm planning to get a 17-55 2.8 is LENS in days,
One thing make me confused, do I need a B+W CPL or not?

[jaymrobinson]

You do not necessarily need a filter on any lens. Although a polarizing filter can be useful in many situations and any kind of filter can protect the lens front element.

[starmage]

You do not necessarily need a filter on any lens. Although a polarizing filter can be useful in many situations and any kind of filter can protect the lens front element.


OK, Thanks.:)

[metalsaber]

Hi All, I'm planning to get a 17-55 2.8 is LENS in days,
One thing make me confused, do I need a B+W CPL or not?

I use one on mine all the time except indoors. Plus it can also help protect the lens.

[hjohnson]

Back to birds (Herons make the perfect subjects.. they're large and hold very still while they're hunting for food):

[hjohnson]

Hi All, I'm planning to get a 17-55 2.8 is LENS in days,
One thing make me confused, do I need a B+W CPL or not?

The Circular Polarizer (CPL) filter can be very handy, as it will blue up the sky, as well as help you eliminate glare/reflections off of non-metalic surfaces. It's not something you would leave on there day-to-day.

However, I am a believer in keeping a UV filter on the lens at all times. My 17-55 runs around with a B+W MRC UV filter and a hood. This is probably overkill, but it's a kilobuck lens so I'm not taking any chances. :)

[august23]

http://i115.photobucket.com/albums/n316/yandoli/IMG_07988.jpg

http://i115.photobucket.com/albums/n316/yandoli/IMG_08644.jpg

http://i115.photobucket.com/albums/n316/yandoli/IMG_08722.jpg


All pictures are original, wide open @ 2.8, and have no PP done to them.

Wish I had more use for it, I'm selling it!

[isogood]

http://www.pbase.com/isogood/image/79385206.jpg

Canon EOS 20D (http://www.pbase.com/cameras/canon/eos_20d) (above)

1/500s f/9.0 at 55.0mm iso200

[isogood]

1/1000s f/4.0 at 17.0mm iso200


http://www.pbase.com/isogood/image/77561117.jpg




1/500s f/8.0 at 55.0mm


http://www.pbase.com/isogood/image/68018383.jpg

[jaymrobinson]

isogood - c'est bon!! tres bien!

[sanil]

Trying out my new battery grip last night

http://www.forno.smugmug.com/photos/164127096-L.jpg

Beautiful shot forno. I would have loved bicycle to be ahead of the car. it would have a been a great pic.:cool:

[starmage]

The Circular Polarizer (CPL) filter can be very handy, as it will blue up the sky, as well as help you eliminate glare/reflections off of non-metalic surfaces. It's not something you would leave on there day-to-day.

However, I am a believer in keeping a UV filter on the lens at all times. My 17-55 runs around with a B+W MRC UV filter and a hood. This is probably overkill, but it's a kilobuck lens so I'm not taking any chances. :)

Thanks all for your information, I'll get a UV first for protecting the lens.

[forno]

Beautiful shot forno. I would have loved bicycle to be ahead of the car. it would have a been a great pic.:cool:


Cheers, I liked some of the urban shots I have seen posted here and thought I would get amongst it:cool:

[tiredoffilm]

Just got mine, this is Jessy

[vmarcus]

Hi, everyone -- New to the forums. Some fantastic photos here! After hours of research, I finally decided to order the 30D body and the 17-55 lens. Should be here this Thursday!

I do quite a bit of travelling and noticed many suggestions for "walk-around" lenses, etc. I like to go as light as possible for mobility and security reasons.

The other lens I am considering purchasing is the 70-200 F2.8L IS. Of course, the 17-55 will be my flag-ship for now. The 70-200 will probably stay at home most of the time.

I know that these are trivial questions, but do you recommend any other lenses for travelling and landscape/urban photography? What are some issues I should expect with the 17-55? Any other input is appreciated.

Vic

[ErikM]

My only two lenses are the 17-55 and the 70-200 2.8 IS. I can basically shoot anything! These two lenses are a great combo, you won't regret it!

If you are travelling lots you may want to consider the 70-200 f4 IS instead, its a little lighter!

[terriyaki]

If you are travelling lots you may want to consider the 70-200 f4 IS instead, its a little lighter!

I wouldn't say that it's just a "little lighter". The 4L IS is half the weight of the 2.8L IS!

[dave_bass5]

Hi, everyone -- New to the forums. Some fantastic photos here! After hours of research, I finally decided to order the 30D body and the 17-55 lens. Should be here this Thursday!

I do quite a bit of travelling and noticed many suggestions for "walk-around" lenses, etc. I like to go as light as possible for mobility and security reasons.

The other lens I am considering purchasing is the 70-200 F2.8L IS. Of course, the 17-55 will be my flag-ship for now. The 70-200 will probably stay at home most of the time.

I know that these are trivial questions, but do you recommend any other lenses for travelling and landscape/urban photography? What are some issues I should expect with the 17-55? Any other input is appreciated.

Vic

Thats a good set up. I also have the 17-55IS and dont find it too large now im used to it. Might i suggest the Tamron 17-50 f/2.8 as a smaller alternative. I find i use mine if im out all day and know i wont be needing the IS.

Also maybe the 70-200 f/4 IS rather than the f/2.8 if size is important.

[vmarcus]

Thanks for your suggestions... I am leaning towards the 70-200 2.8 because of potential low light conditions I may encounter. Can't wait to post some shots from the 17-55 upcoming week!

[narlus]

I think the color rendition difference is noticeable enough that I could probably pick which came from which, and the bokeh with specular highlights isn't very nice compared to the brick.

has anyone who owns both lenses taken you up on this challenge yet?

As far as the contrast, it does have some, but I remember not having to add contrast most of the time with the brick, whereas now it's a standard part of processing. Not a big deal, but it's one more step, you know?

if you shoot RAW, adding contrast in PP is mandatory no matter what lens you are using, ime. so, no big deal.

edit - here's my contribution to this thread:
http://narlus.zenfolio.com/img/v0/p118251358-4.jpg

[ekie]

heres a few recent one from my trip to DC .. gotta love the use of IS inside museums .. i believe it was all taken @ f2.8 and iso800

PP using lightroom. lighting was tough to get proper white balance on some of them so i just convert to b/w with color tone to them.

http://ekinphotography.com/gallery/d/17027-2/_MG_4592.jpg

http://ekinphotography.com/gallery/d/17201-2/_MG_4797.jpg

http://ekinphotography.com/gallery/d/17203-2/_MG_4798.jpg

http://ekinphotography.com/gallery/d/17213-2/_MG_4803.jpg

http://ekinphotography.com/gallery/d/16925-2/_MG_4830.jpg

[ayman86]

love the 3rd and 5th one, ekk_xt. great job

[rustyjaw]

Hey all,

This is my first post here. I'm a recent convert from P&S (Canon PowerShot S80) to DSLR (XTi). I went for broke and bought the 17-55 f2.8 with the new camera. This past weekend was my inauguration to DSLRs and the new lens. Here are some shots from my outing, I had a fantastic time:

http://www.rustyjaw.com/pics/dome_800.jpg

http://www.rustyjaw.com/pics/lamps_800.jpg

http://www.rustyjaw.com/pics/undervalve_800.jpg

http://www.rustyjaw.com/pics/weepers_800.jpg

http://www.rustyjaw.com/pics/into-the-fray_800.jpg

[nicksan]

I would say you are doing just fine!
Nice captures!!!

Hey all,

This is my first post here. I'm a recent convert from P&S (Canon PowerShot S80) to DSLR (XTi). I went for broke and bought the 17-55 f2.8 with the new camera. This past weekend was my inauguration to DSLRs and the new lens. Here are some shots from my outing, I had a fantastic time:

http://www.rustyjaw.com/pics/dome_800.jpg

http://www.rustyjaw.com/pics/lamps_800.jpg

http://www.rustyjaw.com/pics/undervalve_800.jpg

http://www.rustyjaw.com/pics/weepers_800.jpg

http://www.rustyjaw.com/pics/into-the-fray_800.jpg

[rustyjaw]

Thanks a lot! Looking forward to getting as comfortable with the XTi as I was with my S80. So far it's quite a joy to use.

[vmarcus]

Went out for day hike yesterday in the Columbia River Gorge. Took the 30D with the 17-55 out with me. Just got the camera/lens and new to RAW photography in general. I did some minor adjustments to these in PS, let me know what you think...

1. Mini rapids

http://www.whereisvic.com/potn/cr01.jpg

2. I couldn't hear cars anymore

http://www.whereisvic.com/potn/cr02.jpg

3. Wild Mushroom

http://www.whereisvic.com/potn/cr03.jpg

4. Some kind of a white berry?

http://www.whereisvic.com/potn/cr04.jpg

5. Railway

http://www.whereisvic.com/potn/cr05.jpg

6. The car

http://www.whereisvic.com/potn/cr06.jpg

Thanks,

Vic

[DerekI]

Hi, everyone -- New to the forums. Some fantastic photos here! After hours of research, I finally decided to order the 30D body and the 17-55 lens. Should be here this Thursday!

I do quite a bit of travelling and noticed many suggestions for "walk-around" lenses, etc. I like to go as light as possible for mobility and security reasons.

The other lens I am considering purchasing is the 70-200 F2.8L IS. Of course, the 17-55 will be my flag-ship for now. The 70-200 will probably stay at home most of the time.

I know that these are trivial questions, but do you recommend any other lenses for travelling and landscape/urban photography? What are some issues I should expect with the 17-55? Any other input is appreciated.

Vic


What about an EF100f2.8 USM or as Erik says the EF70-200f4L IS if you dont mind being so conspicuous.

[ErikM]

Vic, nice pics and nice IMPREZA! I drive an Impreza myself :)

http://www.netengine.ca/photos/april24_07/scooby2HDR.jpg

[vmarcus]

Thanks, Erik. Your Impreza looks deceiving. Spoiler in the back would yield a WRX, but then I see no hood scoop!

This was my first shot at post-processing. I shot in JPEG/RAW mode just for comparison and can definitely see a big difference between the JPEG and the post-processed RAW file. I wish the railway photo was a bit more centered, but I had no tripod and basically just snapped away. Any other particular advice you can give?

Vic

[ErikM]

Vic, mine is a 2005 Impreza 2.5 RS. I installed the wrx spoiler and side skirts myself :)

As for processing advice.... just keep on experimenting. The best way to learn photoshop is to keep practicing and don't be afraid to try something different!

[vmarcus]

Mine is a '06 RS :D

Nice job with the spoiler/side skirts. I decided to keep mine the way it is.. or I might as well get the new non-rally looking STI.

[juejaimon]

Hi all,

I just got this lens and want to post a picture.... we're only allowed 100k?... hrm..my file is almost 3 megs in size... how are you guys putting such hi rez pictures up?

[sh0ebox]

Hi all,

I just got this lens and want to post a picture.... we're only allowed 100k?... hrm..my file is almost 3 megs in size... how are you guys putting such hi rez pictures up?

use www.imageshack.us or something --- but even that only allows 1.5mb photos, so resize it in photoshop or something first

or just let imageshack resize it for you i think that would work

[Linkzi]

Hi all,

I just got this lens and want to post a picture.... we're only allowed 100k?... hrm..my file is almost 3 megs in size... how are you guys putting such hi rez pictures up?

I use Photobucket...It's free and you can just upload it to an 800x800 limit. Here is a link on how to post here:

http://photography-on-the.net/forum/showthread.php?t=290249

[juejaimon]

Thanks for the help :)

here's one of my first pics with this lens.

http://i186.photobucket.com/albums/x293/juejaimon/IMG_4686-800-2.jpg

[Linkzi]

Thanks for the help :)

here's one of my first pics with this lens.

Lovely shot! Shots like those of our children are the main reasons for most of us buying expensive gear!

[Tom_D]

I love this lens. I lets me get natural light pictures of our grandson that I would have missed in the past or used a flash on. Of course, how can I miss with such a great subject (I'm not biased at all.)

[anomie]

Here's two from a recent trip to Mystic Seaport, Mystic, CT:

http://ddemelo.zenfolio.com/img/v1/p13706330-4.jpg

http://ddemelo.zenfolio.com/img/v1/p342396327-4.jpg

[Calbeee]

i really like my lens, fits perfectly on a 1.6x
i used it on a XT, 20D and 30D... it's just a jewel
since ever i got it, i rarely use photoshop at all...
dpp straight from raw is just too great

http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1228/865513426_4f9aef6a9a_o.jpg

http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1354/864567339_675b20eee9_b.jpg

http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1020/867620417_07fb6bdcaf_o.jpg

http://rcxotic.com/yesterday/d/33502-1/IMG_1328.jpg

http://rcxotic.com/yesterday/d/34839-1/stjamespano.jpg

[Pentaxis]

One of the best portrait shots I have seen in a LONG LONG time. This is absolutely amazing. The contrast between the dark forest and the angelic and innocent like qualities of the child is amazing. The off center framing and choice of DOF is PERFECT too. Is this all natural light, or did you use a reflector?

Stunning.

37mm, f5.6, no sharpening

http://www.jarredwagner.com/photos/cdpf/07.06.23_12.44.37.jpg
http://www.jarredwagner.com/photos/cdpf/07.06.23_12.44.37.100.jpg

[mizouse]

after much contemplation i want this lens over the 24-70 because i don't think i could give up the wide angles i would be able to get with 17mm

[ZekaG]

after much contemplation i want this lens over the 24-70 because i don't think i could give up the wide angles i would be able to get with 17mm


You are right on the money. 17mm is much better than 24mm on a 1.6x body. I love mine...

[Linkzi]

http://i171.photobucket.com/albums/u291/Linkzi/Family/_MG_2454.jpg

[mizouse]

http://i171.photobucket.com/albums/u291/Linkzi/Family/_MG_2454.jpg


OMG what a cute dog :)

[Linkzi]

Thanks...How could you not leave her at the pet store. :lol:

[mikeivan]

I have only had my 17-55 a couple of months and I love it. This archive shows some great examples. I used mine in England in cathedrals and museums (no flash) and for landscapes.

195677
This is early morning at Stonehenge, with a CP, 17mm @ f/8


195678
It also makes a great close up lens, this is 38mm @ f/8, 1/20 sec and handheld. Gotta love that IS.


I am very pleased with this lens, I have never used anything close to 17mm before and it is a whole new world. I am taking it to Yellowstone NP next week, and I can't wait.

[vmarcus]

I like the shot of the Stonehenge.. great dimensions on the clouds!

Vic

[Lord_Malone]

Hooray!, I just got my 17-55 back from Canon. If anyone followed, I sent a complaint about my lens dust issue. A little while later, I sent in my lens demanding a free clean. Which they did. And now, it has come back, and it's like new. Maybe even better than new. Seems like they tidied up the zoom ring, and my images seem contrast, sharper. I have reason to believe the dust is coming from the front, so now I have a Heliopan filter slapped on.

some test shots:

efs17-55IS, 55mm, f2.8, 1/30s, iso100

http://img208.imageshack.us/img208/5024/img3517da3.jpg
efs17-55IS, 17mm, f2.8, 1/13s, iso100

That's not the original toy Optimus Prime is it?

[laxx]

No, that's the 20th Anniversary Masterpiece Optimus Prime. =T You can easily tell by how much detail was put into designing the toy. The easiest give away are the individual fingers.

[freakeystyley34]

i NEED this lens, i may have to sell my soul.

[juejaimon]

been itching to try this lens on my car... just after a wash...:D

http://i186.photobucket.com/albums/x293/juejaimon/wash.jpg

100% crop

http://i186.photobucket.com/albums/x293/juejaimon/crop.jpg

[Linkzi]

Beautiful Ride! What year is it? Do they still make them?

[juejaimon]

Beautiful Ride! What year is it? Do they still make them?

Thanks... it's a 1991...the first year of issue. :)... they stopped making them in 2005

I think a polarizer will make the picture pop more.... hrm...

[sanil]

:)nice lens

[mizouse]

been itching to try this lens on my car... just after a wash...:D

http://i186.photobucket.com/albums/x293/juejaimon/wash.jpg

100% crop

http://i186.photobucket.com/albums/x293/juejaimon/crop.jpg

hmm... you're from the bay area huh? that looks like alameda.

anyways nice NSX, one of these i'll get one of them.

[juejaimon]

hmm... you're from the bay area huh? that looks like alameda.

anyways nice NSX, one of these i'll get one of them.


Yes, that's Alameda.... across the estuary from the Port of Oakland terminals. Thanks for the compliment, it's a joy to own and always fun to drive. ;)

[Robf]

nice thing i like about this lens is it pushes snaps closer to being shots...

if i'm walking around doing nothing specific then i'll have this on the 400d first

http://www.rfarn.ukfsn.org/pics/_MG_4591.jpg

http://www.rfarn.ukfsn.org/pics/_MG_4646.jpg

http://www.rfarn.ukfsn.org/pics/_MG_4972.jpg

http://www.rfarn.ukfsn.org/pics/_MG_4999.jpg

http://www.rfarn.ukfsn.org/pics/_MG_5059.jpg

http://www.rfarn.ukfsn.org/pics/_MG_5071.jpg

http://www.rfarn.ukfsn.org/pics/_MG_5090.jpg

[jaymrobinson]

Robf, weren't you scared with that dog coming at you?

Great pics by the way.

[anomie]

Lovely photos, Rob!

[Robf]

thanks for the nice comments :)

the dog is a softy...i've known her since she was a pup...and i've spent ages with her trying to get a full frame shot in focus of her running...she knows the routine by now :D

the fireworks was shot from a small boat...i think it shows off the IS quite well...1/20th iso 1600

[mellowd]

http://i171.photobucket.com/albums/u291/Linkzi/Family/_MG_2454.jpg

This dog is uber cute.

[unferth]

A few from Destin FL

[Linkzi]

Thanks! She still is a cutie.

[Aray_Of_Art]

i really like my lens, fits perfectly on a 1.6x
i used it on a XT, 20D and 30D... it's just a jewel
since ever i got it, i rarely use photoshop at all...
dpp straight from raw is just too great

http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1228/865513426_4f9aef6a9a_o.jpg

http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1354/864567339_675b20eee9_b.jpg

http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1020/867620417_07fb6bdcaf_o.jpg

http://rcxotic.com/yesterday/d/33502-1/IMG_1328.jpg

http://rcxotic.com/yesterday/d/34839-1/stjamespano.jpg

WOW! :shock: Great shots! And VERY helpful!!!!!

[juejaimon]

yes..i agree...is that a miniture beagal?...

This dog is uber cute.

[Linkzi]

yes..i agree...is that a miniture beagal?...

Shes a 15in Beagle at 7 weeks. Thanks.

[Dorman]

Still needing this lens. I picked up the tamron 17-50 to get me by until I had more mad money kicking around. I'll definitely be upgrading before wedding season next year!

[DerekI]

this is a great lens and all talked about issues like flares , CA and dust are not true.

I have had it for a long time , no dust .

I have had it for a long time , no flare in my photos.

No CA either , the Tamorn had the CA issue, though my Canon 17-55IS is pretty good .

The only one issue of the lens is scare people a way when I it at them.

Also , the hood of the lens is hard to find in Asia ,next time , I will go back to So-cal get it there , but I wont go there till Next year.

Oh well , shooting real life people is hard but at least with the 17-55IS , I can make it easier.

Note: the 17-55Is works better with my 40D than with the 400D because of the new 40DAF system .

[DerekI]

Still needing this lens. I picked up the tamron 17-50 to get me by until I had more mad money kicking around. I'll definitely be upgrading before wedding season next year!


The Tamron is as sharp but the IS makes it different , especially for weddings and events .

The Tamorn is a great lens but just not as practical or useful in real life .

With that said, if you are shooting static or slow moving subject in day light , the Tamorn is maybe a better choice since it is so small and cheap.

But my subjects are always moving and need ultimate AF speed , I use my Canon more often, other wise, I would love my Tamorn for its size and close-up feature.

The Tamorn is sharper in macro range or close-up , but the Canon beats the Tamron in infinity range , especially wide open at borders.

The tamorn has a bit more saturated color with warmer cast and I prefer that of my Canon because I like cooler color tone.

The Canon has better CA characteristic and more resistant to flare than the Tamorn.

The Canon has less distortion at its 17mm mark than the Tamorn ...........but the tamorn is definitely wider at its 17mm end than the Canon at its 17mm mark.

I compared the 16-35L of my dad's to my Tmaorn and I found the 16mm of the 16-35L is about the same as my Tamorn at its 17mm.

For landscapes , I like my Tamorn better because of the more saturated Tamorn color and its wider 17mm end, but for people or in door , I definitely use my Canon....

So you may better keep both , I actually have the 17-85IS and 24-105L too .

But I prefer my 17-55IS to all others if I have to sell all others , but with knowing that if I sell them , I will lose some money , I will seep them all .


The Tamron is a great lens for many applications but not for action or street photography since the AF is capricious, or at least I can say it is slow.

I think main questions you need to ask yourself before spending a grand on the Canon are :

1 do you shoot wide open a lot?

2 do you need super fast AF?

3 do you carry a tripod ?

4 do you have time shooting RAw or just have to shoot Jepeg?

If you use RAW only , all color issues of the Tamorn are no problem at all.
And the the distortion of the Tamorn is easily correted when needed it.

But the wide open sharpness is something you can never make up for by shooting RAW .

Actually, to me getting the CanonEF-S17-55IS saved money in the long run because I could sell all my primes in the range : the 50f1.8 and f1.4 , the 28f1.8 , the 35f2 , the 24 f2.8, the 85f1.8 and Sigma 30EX.

Good luck to you and either way , you won't lose any since both are great lenses IMHO.

Take care.

[TMR Design]

Hi Derek,

Can I ask why you have the 17-55 IS and the 17-85 IS? Obviously the 17-85 has a bit more reach but at 85mm you can only open up to f/5.6 and the 17-55m is f/2.8 throughout the focal length range.

[DerekI]

http://www.wlcastleman.com/equip/reviews/17-85compare/index.htm

[DerekI]

http://www.wlcastleman.com/equip/reviews/17-85compare/index.htm

Forgot this any one on the fence between them should read the MR. Castleman review.

As he says , the Canon is more resistant to flares than other F2.8 crop-only kind of lenses.

[DerekI]

His reviews are always more detailed than all other reviews on line out there, and he is not biased like others.

So check it out , also read his 40D review.

I think all rebel users should get the 40D,there is a day-and-night difference in AF speed.

[AiGTs]

I love this lens, it's been on my camera since the day I got it. :)

http://members.cox.net/aigts/s2k_farm.jpg

[keithk42]

I love this lens, it's been on my camera since the day I got it. :)

http://members.cox.net/aigts/s2k_farm.jpg


Nice shot. Did you use a polarizer to get the sky so blue? I've been thinking about getting one for my 17-55.

Keith

[AiGTs]

Nice shot. Did you use a polarizer to get the sky so blue? I've been thinking about getting one for my 17-55.

Keith

I don't have a polarizer, but I try to bring out the colors in post production. ;)

[slavik13]

A few samples... this is a perfect lens on a crop body like Xti or 20/30/40d. I do have some major dust issues with mine, but it isn't affecting the image quality at all.

http://stevek.net/photos/sfo2007/slides/IMG_7187.jpg

http://stevek.net/photos/sfo2007/slides/IMG_7183.jpg

[ZekaG]

I like this lens so much, that I have to post again...
http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1231/1466866640_0af726299c_o.jpg

http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1411/1466014973_db0a852672_o.jpg

[Familiaphoto]

Here is my one of favorites. This is simple the best lens I've used.

http://familiaphoto.zenfolio.com/img/v2/p638257948-4.jpg

[forno]

Here is my one of favorites. This is simple the best lens I've used.

http://familiaphoto.zenfolio.com/img/v2/p638257948-4.jpg

Nice use of the bean:cool::cool:

[mikeivan]

Well, I bought this lens about six months ago and I find it amazing to use, I am not experienced with landscape or "wide angle" (I know it isn't really wide on my 20D). However, this lens is just one more reason I will never leave the "1.6 sensor" world (another being "reach" for my birds).
210568
These two shots are from my recent trip to Alberta, the "Three Sisters (f/14, 1/30, ISO 200)" and
Lake Louise (f/11, 1/60, ISO 200).
210569
They are shot using a CP, which I find difficult to master but very useful, especially at high altitude. Any comments are welcome, I am a real rookie at these sort of shots. I also used this lens at a family wedding, good candids and no flash! To me, it is the plastic L.

[unferth]

I love Chicago :)

[Familiaphoto]

I love Chicago :)

I know what you guys mean. This city offers so much to shoot. I've spent hours by the bean alone, there is so much opportunity.

[71sbeetle]

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2317/1510971377_85046acb32.jpg
http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2317/1510971377_d1cfe84ef4_o.jpg

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2321/1511829246_ab2fb474ea.jpg
http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2321/1511829246_364e71292d_o.jpg

[fz_za]

71sbeetle, fantastic shots of absolutely amazing cars (I drive an Audi myself)!!! I'd take either of those any day (that S5 looks gorgeous - is it already available in the US?)

[71sbeetle]

71sbeetle, fantastic shots of absolutely amazing cars (I drive an Audi myself)!!! I'd take either of those any day (that S5 looks gorgeous - is it already available in the US?)

thank you :)
Yes it's been available here for 3 days now, I had a chance to drive it yesterday and it's a blast !!!

[ItsMike]

Here is a shot I posted in the Experimental section.. But.. It does include a %100 Crop.. And it was hand held.

http://i221.photobucket.com/albums/dd71/mpimage/Misc/TheKing.jpg

Here is another shot..

http://i221.photobucket.com/albums/dd71/mpimage/Misc/IMG_2253copy-1.jpg

one more for the road....

http://i221.photobucket.com/albums/dd71/mpimage/Misc/IMG_2245.jpg

[DallasPhoto]

Just got mine about 4 days ago. LOVE IT.... my contribution, my nephew!
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y110/n_d_mand13/blakesleep1web.jpg

[Joetaco]

damn it! i just went through all 28 pages of this damn thread. now i am back to torturing myself about which lens to get.

[kevindar]

http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1081/915844283_f52aae5ce7_o.jpg

[svpworld]

Love my news lens, shame we haven't had a glimmer of sun since I've had it though! At least I can open it up to f/2.8 indoors!

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2213/1570260421_7394bc8974_b.jpg

[masterkraft]

hi there, i joined this site a few days ago and have spent most of the weekend reading many of the threads. I had decided to buy the 40d but wasn't sure what lense to get, having gone through the last 30 odd pages it's got to be the 17-55 great pictures all of you, great site looking forward to getting the camera!!

[flareak]

I got mine TODAY!!! WEEEEE

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2033/1737990905_828698ac52_b.jpg

[agent.media]

Got mine a couple of days ago!

Both photos taken at ISO3200

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2363/1772925970_4d7f1c410c_b.jpg

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2285/1772071249_a11ab5e4f0_b.jpg

I love being able to do SO much more at low light.

[khnordeen]

i need this lens so bad. someone sell me theirs or trade for my 17-40L...

[supertop99]

http://www.bloggang.com/data/thekoptop/picture/1193654163.jpg

I love it!

[Linkzi]

This lens is my most used, eliminates the use for me to use primes...It's just way to versatile and sharp.

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2217/1806245139_6638728bc7_o.jpg

[Aldwyn]

I just picked up this lens this week... havnt had much time to play with it yet, but set up the Bees for a few shots yesterday in between trick or treaters:

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v466/aldwynn/Guitars/vrcontest2-2.jpg

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v466/aldwynn/Guitars/vrcontest1-2.jpg

[agent.media]

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2160/1942163554_c65d712fea_b.jpg
http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2141/1942176638_930afb1c38_b.jpg

[BrantG]

http://www.brantgajda.com/images/forums/landscape1.jpg
http://www.brantgajda.com/images/forums/landscape2.jpg

[Player9]

I just picked up this lens this week... havnt had much time to play with it yet, but set up the Bees for a few shots yesterday in between trick or treaters:

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v466/aldwynn/Guitars/vrcontest2-2.jpg

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v466/aldwynn/Guitars/vrcontest1-2.jpg

Forget about the camera; how's that sweet Tele working out? I own a regular American Series (black with maple) but I was severely tempted to spring for this one with the belly carve. I don't recognize the amp, is it a custom low watt similar to a Fender Champ or Deluxe.

[fz_za]

Spectacular images, BrantG. Where is that?

Did you use a Circular Polarizer? Are those images HDR'd at all?

[BrantG]

Spectacular images, BrantG. Where is that?

Did you use a Circular Polarizer? Are those images HDR'd at all?

It's in Western, Pennsylvania on a State Game lands. I was on a narrow strip between 2 lakes.

A circular polarizer was used. I did add some saturation, but not much.

[khnordeen]

I am so glad I can finally post in this thread, lol.

http://i18.photobucket.com/albums/b130/gimmekickz17/Moffett13copy.jpg

[71sbeetle]

EF-S 17-55mm @ 55mm, f/2.8, 1/10, ISO 1600 on a 30D

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2400/2008160934_1ce9279eff.jpg
http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2400/2008160934_0f4c4112b3_o.jpg

[bob_r]

Here are a couple of mine taken with a 30D.

These were taken on trip to St. Louis last month.
1/2000s f/7.1 at 23.0mm iso200
http://www.pbase.com/bob_r/image/86898081.jpg

1/800s f/7.1 at 20.0mm iso200
http://www.pbase.com/bob_r/image/86956612.jpg

1/4000s f/2.8 at 24.0mm iso200
http://www.pbase.com/bob_r/image/86864343.jpg

and a few others

1/200s f/4.0 at 42.0mm iso400
http://www.pbase.com/bob_r/image/75770710.jpg

1/4s f/2.8 at 55.0mm iso200
http://www.pbase.com/bob_r/image/74247062.jpg

Bob R

[airbutchie]

I am so glad I can finally post in this thread, lol.

http://i18.photobucket.com/albums/b130/gimmekickz17/Moffett13copy.jpg

Hey Gimme... Hhehehehhe... Nice to see you posting here on POTN... I knew I saw this picture before!!! Hhehehheehe... Keep'em coming bro...

- airbutchie :D

[vmarcus]

Love that St. Louis shot!

Vic

[bob_r]

Thanks, Vic.

[mitchster26]

http://i36.photobucket.com/albums/e11/mitchster26/Unknown-1.jpg

[mrcoons]

http://MusicMan5.smugmug.com/photos/224550279-L.jpg


http://MusicMan5.smugmug.com/photos/175719241-L.jpg

[g_intasopa]

here are my contribution from the 17-55, im a newb so any critique would be great ^^

love this lens (1st and 3rd handheld), no PP other than HDR on the first pic
http://lh4.google.com/gintasopa/R1TP0He3eWI/AAAAAAAAA2Y/Onb9xHyLgqA/s800/DPP_bg0003_1_2_tonemapped.jpg

http://lh6.google.com/gintasopa/R1TP7ne3edI/AAAAAAAAA3U/wo85zjWzGKE/s800/_MG_2654cathe.jpg

http://lh5.google.com/gintasopa/R1TQlXe3egI/AAAAAAAAA3s/YqyPUUmckKE/s800/_MG_2980.jpg

[Scunner]

As much as I've been tempted by the 5D, I'm loathe to be parted from my 17-55. It's on my 40D almost exclusively and yields very satisfactory results.

The pictures below were taken at the funeral of a close friend's father. I was hesitant at first, feeling like I was intruding on a very private and solemn event, but friends are friends, and I was glad to be there for him. His dad loved classic cars so it was fitting that they came along for the ride.

http://www.smugmug.com/photos/224922899-L.jpg

http://www.smugmug.com/photos/224932855-XL.jpg

[suyenfung]

this is probably my favorite lens right now, just fantastic.

http://www.jarredwagner.com/images/uploads/shared_archive/cdpf/1755/07.05.07_19.51.12.jpg

http://www.jarredwagner.com/images/uploads/shared_archive/cdpf/1755/07.05.09_14.05.43.jpg

http://www.jarredwagner.com/images/uploads/shared_archive/cdpf/1755/07.06.26_18.40.43.jpg

http://www.jarredwagner.com/images/uploads/shared_archive/cdpf/1755/07.06.27_20.04.24.jpg

http://www.jarredwagner.com/images/uploads/shared_archive/cdpf/1755/07.10.12_14.44.35.jpg

http://www.jarredwagner.com/images/uploads/shared_archive/cdpf/1755/07.10.16_17.19.22.jpg

http://www.jarredwagner.com/images/uploads/shared_archive/cdpf/1755/07.10.16_19.30.38.jpg

http://www.jarredwagner.com/images/uploads/shared_archive/cdpf/1755/07.11.22_15.25.12.jpg

[71sbeetle]

this is probably my favorite lens right now, just fantastic.

http://www.jarredwagner.com/images/uploads/shared_archive/cdpf/1755/07.10.12_14.44.35.jpg




Beechcraft 1900D! Where was this taken ?

[mizouse]

man this thread makes me want to sell a kidney just so i can get one :(

[nairud]

f4, 1/20, ISO1000.. all handheld
Shot during Bandai Action Kit Universal Cup 2007
http://i129.photobucket.com/albums/p202/nairud7418/BAKUC%202007/IMG_1285.jpg

http://i129.photobucket.com/albums/p202/nairud7418/BAKUC%202007/IMG_1260.jpg

http://i129.photobucket.com/albums/p202/nairud7418/BAKUC%202007/IMG_1264.jpg

http://i129.photobucket.com/albums/p202/nairud7418/BAKUC%202007/IMG_1254.jpg

[verty]

i just got this lens! wooohoooo
im shooting my first reception this saturday with it.. ive been shooting with a Tamron 28-75 but find its not wide enough for indoor shots and i also want the IS that the canon offers!
cant wait to test it out :D

[Linkzi]

i just got this lens! wooohoooo
im shooting my first reception this saturday with it.. ive been shooting with a Tamron 28-75 but find its not wide enough for indoor shots and i also want the IS that the canon offers!
cant wait to test it out :D

Congrats on getting one of the finest lens Canon has to offer and welcome to the club!

[suyenfung]

Beechcraft 1900D! Where was this taken ?

is that the plane?

that was taken over salt lake city as we departed toward vernal, utah. i was traveling to meet my friend, the guy by the river.

[71sbeetle]

is that the plane?

that was taken over salt lake city as we departed toward vernal, utah. i was traveling to meet my friend, the guy by the river.


Cool yes this is the airplane, I figured it was one of Great Lakes' Beech 1900D :)

http://www.airliners.net/open.file/1131461/L

[agent.media]

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2044/2048296064_19ef69be33.jpg

Taken at ISO 200 and f/2.8

[thespeakerbox]

Man, im torn between this lens and the tamron 17-50.... price makes it tough to decide.

[S-S]

bridesmaids

[tonylong]

This lens will make your 30D behave like...a...30D should! It is a beg, borrow, or, well, sell a kidney type of lens!

[ALaS]

I was torn between this and the 24-70mm 2.8 L. I finally came to my senses :]

[ALaS]

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2044/2048296064_19ef69be33.jpg

Taken at ISO 200 and f/2.8

awesome shot!:!:

[Pasukun]

30D + 17-55 is + 430ex @ f/2.8

Used slight USM. (200/0.2)

I freakin love this lens. :)


http://i209.photobucket.com/albums/bb246/Pasukun2/01.jpg



http://i209.photobucket.com/albums/bb246/Pasukun2/02.jpg



http://i209.photobucket.com/albums/bb246/Pasukun2/03.jpg