PDA

View Full Version : Tele adapters for Canon S3


Changeling
1st of November 2006 (Wed), 18:01
I am in the process of buying the things I want for a Canon S3 IS. I have purchased a LensMatic 58mm adapter to connect these adapters

On other web sites they talk about the Sony VCL- DH 1758 (plastic housing), and the VCL-HGD 1758 ( older, aluminum housing).
I "think" the two Teles have the same lenses but am not sure at all.

The Canon TC-DC58 B is what some of people use because it's canon, without any other considerations. I have heard it is a "real bear" to work with.

There was a tremendious article written by a professional photographer called "Katz" I think. He extolled on the virtues of the Sony VCL-DH 1758 on a sony camera called the Sony R1, I think.

On the other hand a very few individuals using the Canon S3/Sony VCL-DH 1758 say it is awesome and gives them the maximum magnification without problems.

I'm confused, I am definately a newbe, but see no reason to make mistakes when there's a few real experts willing to help!

Doe's anyone have expertise in the field/are I am talking about? If so, what/why do you recommend? If ther is a tele that you have personal experience with don't hesitate to suggest!
In fact, all suggestions from experiencd indiviuals are very welcome.
Sincerely, Lola.

PS. I can't help making a science out of everything I do, it's just part of the way I am.

RossW
1st of November 2006 (Wed), 19:48
Welcome, Lola.

This sort of question comes up frequently here; very recently there have been two inquiries that should help you, even though the posters were asking about teleconverters for the S2 model. One of the threads is here (http://photography-on-the.net/forum/showthread.php?t=233875); the other is here (http://photography-on-the.net/forum/showthread.php?t=233754).

If I recall correctly, at least one of them (or an internal linked thread) mentions the Sony TC. I don't know exactly what was meant about the Canon TC being a "bear" to use, but I've had success with mine... as have others. The links I provided have sample photos in them.

Changeling
2nd of November 2006 (Thu), 13:28
Ross thanks very much for the welcome and links.
Changeling