PDA

View Full Version : From a related thread: Best UV filter brand?


fwhitesides
25th of January 2004 (Sun), 19:49
I actually never gave much thought to the brand for UV filters. I usually use whatever brand the store I buy from has displayed most pominently. Usually, this is Hoya.

What are your favorite filter brands?

CoolToolGuy
25th of January 2004 (Sun), 19:53
I like B+W, but Hoya (especially the Multi-Coated) is probably very close.

The latest thing (that I have noticed) is the 'slim' filter designed to prevent vignetting. If you are entirely digital, this is not worth chasing, since the crop factor reduces the Angle Of View. Nice idea for film, though (and perhaps the EF-S lens).

Have Fun
Rick 8)

defordphoto
25th of January 2004 (Sun), 20:00
I use Canon (go figure).

dennykyser
25th of January 2004 (Sun), 20:42
my 100 2.0 has a canon and so does my 28-90 4.5 go figure, probaly the filter on that lens is worth more than the lens. Got that with my Elan 7e and found out how poor it is when I put it on my 10D.

Is Canon a good quality filter? (UV)

perror
25th of January 2004 (Sun), 21:04
I'm using B+W on my 28-135 and the rest are using Hoya. I like the B+W mainly because of the MRC coat which makes it really easy to clean..:)

ilya
25th of January 2004 (Sun), 21:28
I have a
B+W for 28-135IS
Canon Haze UV-1 Glass Filter (L-39 Sharp Cut) for the 70-200 2.8 IS
Sunpak UV for the 17-40L
Sunpak UV for the 75-300IS

Yes, you can say I got it wrong, I have expensive stuff for the 28-135 (inexpensive) lense, and cheap filter for the 17-40L. That's true. I don't really notice the diff; and if its a critical shot, I"ll take off the filter in any case. I am planning to get something better for the 17-40 though.

zerolight
26th of January 2004 (Mon), 10:49
I'm using a B+W MCR. I didn't like the canon. It affected my auto-focus.

Vegas Poboy
26th of January 2004 (Mon), 13:23
B+W is my first choice & then Hoya all of my filters is multicoated.

CyberDyneSystems
26th of January 2004 (Mon), 13:31
I have not decided!

My Canon filters are becoming scratched just by looking at them..

The Hoya caused my Sigma 70-200mm to go all "backfocus" on me... so I think I need to try a B&W.

neil_r
26th of January 2004 (Mon), 14:03
I use Hoya Super HMC PRO, they cost a little more but worth it (possibly)

Check out this thread if any of you missed it:-

http://photography-on-the.net/forum/showthread.php?t=17316&highlight=

Neil

Yarin
26th of January 2004 (Mon), 14:25
Any comments on Tiffen?

c_canade
8th of May 2006 (Mon), 20:06
I realize this is an old post but it warrented a reply
Tiffen are not coated and more prone to lens flare - (use lens hood)
As far as Bob Atkins UV tests (http://bobatkins.com/photography/technical/filters.html) :
http://bobatkins.com/photography/technical/filters/rmafilter06a.gif
"This last plot makes the order of UV absorbing effectiveness quite clear

* The Tiffen Haze-1 is best. It's a neutral filter so color balance is unaffected.
* Next is the Tiffen 812. Good UV blocking if you also want a warming filter
* The Hoya 81B warming filter is quite similar to the Tiffen 812.
* The Hoya UV filter comes next, neutral, but with 2 stops of UV blocking.
* The B+W KR1.5 gives about 1.5 stops of UV blocking with slight warming.
* The Tiffen polarizer gives less than a stop of UV blocking - but that's not why you use a polarizer!
* The B+W UV and Hoya 1B aren't very effective UV blockers. The 1B is slightly warming
* The three "generics" and the Tiffen UV protector are pretty useless for blocking UV, though they may make fine, neutral, lens protectors."

the later was taken from the above Bob Atkins link and was Last Modified 05/13/2005 18:30:19 so it should be still a usfull and fairly upto date test resource for UV Filters.

Personally, I'd like to see several other commercial grade as well as some other pro filters added to this UV filter test to make it more complete - but that is was all i found with a quick browse.

chase

XMX
9th of May 2006 (Tue), 21:59
B+W are very very nice filters. However Hoya filters are nice replacements.

malla1962
10th of May 2006 (Wed), 08:47
All my lenses are fitted with hoya pro1's with no effect on IQ.:D