Double Arch

[AV Mode]

Hi folks, I'd like to know which verson works best, toned or b/w soft look?
Comments always welcome.:)

http://www.pbase.com/image/70802339.jpg

http://www.pbase.com/image/70802644.jpg

[amonline]

I like the second.

[Ianfp]

I think I prefer the slightly warmer tone of #1, but then #2 looks good too!

[AV Mode]

Thank you both for comments.

Cheers :)

[tlc]

first one.

[ohsnap]

The first one is best. You lost a lot of detail in the very white/very black areas with the second.

[roman_t]

first one has more details of bricks and leaves. i love this place. i like second too.

[Canonada]

First one.

Joe

[Athena]

hmmm - I thought I had commented on this. Must have only been in my mind.

I prefer the second one specifically because of the detail lost in the blacks. The scene is overwhelmingly full of detail and that little bit less allows me to focus more on what I am actually seeing. But I do love the tone in the first. :)

[BillsBayou]

I like the first one better.

[gardengirl13]

Another vote for the first one

[Anthony McAvoy]

First one for me, some of the bricks look a little blown out on # 2.

[AV Mode]

I prefer the second one specifically because of the detail lost in the blacks. The scene is overwhelmingly full of detail and that little bit less allows me to focus more on what I am actually seeing. But I do love the tone in the first. :)

My thoughts exactly exept I couldn't find the right words to explain it. ;)
I tried to make the light and shade the principal elements in the second one.

Thank you for that. :)

[barP]

My thoughts exactly exept I couldn't find the right words to explain it. ;)
I tried to make the light and shade the principal elements in the second one.

Thank you for that. :)

athena sees it like it is.

wp.