Broad Street Bridge

[Jamie Holladay]

I had some time to shoot today, YAH!
We have a wonderful bridge here in town that I like to shoot. I took a different approach on it today. Here is one shot with four versions. The first one is not cropped, the second one is the same but B&W. The third and fourth shots are cropped and B&W. Tell me which one you like best, and some C&C is very appreciated (even if you hate it tell me but tell me why please).

1.
http://www.24zero.com/Urban/BroadStreetBridge/02042007/BS_Bridge_02042007_001_pst.jpg

2.
http://www.24zero.com/Urban/BroadStreetBridge/02042007/BS_Bridge_02042007_001bw_pst.jpg

3.
http://www.24zero.com/Urban/BroadStreetBridge/02042007/BS_Bridge_02042007_001c_pst.jpg

4.
http://www.24zero.com/Urban/BroadStreetBridge/02042007/BS_Bridge_02042007_001cbw_pst.jpg

[WorkingClassHero]

I like no 2. The trees on either side add a nice frame and sense of depth and I like the B&W. After the crop it doesn't do anything for me.

[Jamie Holladay]

Thanks for the comments.

[GilesGuthrie]

I too prefer the uncropped B/W.

[Jamie Holladay]

Thanks Giles