PDA

View Full Version : Respect For The Birds We Photograph


Booswalia
16th of February 2007 (Fri), 09:44
The Birds We Love

As photographers with a special interest in birds and wildlife we need to pay special attention to how our behavior may effect our favorite subjects. The opportunity to get that great shot can sometimes have devastating effects on our feathered friends without our even knowing it. I’ve learned a lot about birds in the past year and even more in just that last few weeks after volunteering to become an Eagle Guardian. A project where volunteers observe eagle behavior from a respectable distance and report back to an authority to keep records in our province.

My eyes were opened when I discovered that some of my own behaviors may have had some detrimental effects on birds. Even my own thinking, such as, “oh it’s just an ol’ tern or an ol' gull” . It may be just an ol’ tern or gull to me, but the tern population is declining here and I had no idea. My ignorance is no excuse.

So, with this in mind I thought it might be helpful for the POTN birding group to perhaps read the following and see if they can find ways to improve their interaction with wildlife. I would never want to discourage people from photographing birds but I would like people to examine their own experiences to see if there's room for improvement.

Colonial Nesting Birds
Birds that nest in colonies such as gulls, terns, herons and cormorants are concentrated in small areas for just a few weeks of the year when they nest and at this time are threatened by human disturbance as well as extreme weather, pollutants, toxic chemicals, and predators.

Did you know... you are disturbing a nesting colony if:
• the birds take flight. This exposes the eggs or young to extreme temperatures and predators reducing nest success
• the birds dive at you. This takes time and energy away from more important activities such as feeding and preening. Not to mention that is stresses the adults.

If you encounter these behaviors, leave the area.

Human Disturbance of Bald Eagles

Drawn by curiosity and driven by good intentions, people want to see a bald eagle nest, up close. Pedestrian traffic to the base of a nesting tree or within 100 m (300 feet) of the nest can cause nest abandonment. Repeated and frequent stresses to nesting birds of almost any kind, cause them to leave eggs and small chicks exposed to the elements and to predators and froces adults to use limited energy supplies in their own bodies to flush from the nest, circle the area and call and try to defend the nest. These energies are better used to hunt for food, feed young, incubate eggs or brood young. When adults flush from the nest they attract potential predators and mobbing by crows and ravens. Even black birds are often seen chasing eagles.

Human disturbances to eagle nests can be reduced but are difficult to eliminate. However, through public awareness it is possible to improve conditions for bald eagles and work to reduce nest abandonment, and chick and adult mortality rates.

Disturbances such as wood cutting, building construction, loud and repeated noises, vehicles use and burning should be reported to a conservation officer so they can take action to minimiz or at least delay such activities until a less threatening time.


A Year in the Life of a Bald Eagle

Jan. An established pair will return to the nesting site, go through courtship, add material to the nest and create a strong pair bond. Disturbances can send them out of the area and force them to re-build else-where.

Feb. Males gather branches and bring them to the female to ensure the nest is built just right. Soft bedding is added.

March Eggs are laid, usually 2 eggs 2 to 5 days apart. Incubation is shared between male and female, with the female doing most of the incubation. They take turns finding food and incubating for the 35 to 38 days until the chicks are hatched. If disturbance occurs now they may expose the eggs to very cold temperatures and cause mortality of the embryo.

April Chicks hatch. The adults have the strongest ties to the eggs just before hatching and just after they emerge. For the first few days the female continues to brood the young as they are very small, have no feathers, and are weak. This is when it is extremely important not to disturb them. Leaving the nest exposes the chicks to cold and often wet weather at this time of year.

May The adults brood the young on cool and cold days and nights for most of this month. If the weather is warm one adult may be seen on a branch overlooking the nest, but not in the nest. Only one parent is bringing food to the nest, while the other stands watch, broods and/or feeds the chicks.

June Chicks continue to rely on the parents to bring food but have grown very large. By the end of June they may weight as much as their parents and can feed themselves. Their flight and body feathers continue to grow until they fly. They may be seen flapping their wings to build strength for flight.

July Young eagles will take their first flight. They may soar to a nearby tree or to the ground. They do not hunt at this time but beg from the parents, following them as they fly in the area. If they cannot fly and left the nest early they are vulnerable to ground predation. This is the start of a year long period when the most mortalities take place - simply due to inexperience.

Aug to Oct. The young will leave the nest area and learn to hunt with their parents.

Nov to Jan. The family group may leave the area and head for slightly warmer climate or better hunting ground. The juveniles and adults separate during the winter months when the adults begin to return (if they left) to the nest again.

Spring is coming and the excitement of capturing that wonderful nesting behavior is tempting, but lets not go overboard and repeatedly disturb the creatures we love.

Your thoughts are welcome....

dancinec
16th of February 2007 (Fri), 09:49
I agree, thanks for sharing your thoughts.

JimLittle
16th of February 2007 (Fri), 09:53
Good and helpful info to keep in mind during the year---thanks!

bromm
16th of February 2007 (Fri), 10:08
Great info you posted here Shirley, Some of this may be things that would seem harmless but pointing out the consequences sure brings things into perspective, Thanks for sharing this info with us. :D

hTr
16th of February 2007 (Fri), 10:16
That is very good information, Bald Eagles are protected species and you can be fined or arrested for harrasing a nest. 330 feet for Casual periods and 660 for observation. Most photo taking should be away from the nest in roosting areas or feeding areas.

eccles
16th of February 2007 (Fri), 10:37
Surprising as it may seem to some here, ;) not everyone lives in North America, but the comments are equally valid elsewhere. In the UK, peregrine falcons and several other raptors have similar status to bald eagles, and require equal caution. Regular nesting sites are usually monitored by RSPB officials, and you risk a fine here too if you disturb them.

ngannet
16th of February 2007 (Fri), 10:51
I agree completely, especially in light of some recent posts. I think birders and photographers are sometimes separate entities. I think many birders regard photographers in a bad light. Most birders are very content to view birds through a spotting scope without ever getting near the bird. Whereas photographers want to get closer. I am both, but a birder first and foremost. This is not to say there are not irresponsible birders as well. I would much rather get a far away shot than disturb the bird and am very careful about that. No photograph is worth endangering any animal, bird or not. And if you go birding often enough, you will get photographs of nearly every bird you are looking for. Eccles, I'm always interested to hear more about the world's birds and I only wish there were more posts of birds from abroad!

canonloader
16th of February 2007 (Fri), 12:01
Great information. I knew most of it, but I'm glad I had the chance to refresh.

not everyone lives in North America
No, but every North American lives in North America. ;)

dphillips81
16th of February 2007 (Fri), 12:46
Thank you for the great information! We have several nests around town here, and it is good to have this info to share with others so that we don't disturb them.

Booswalia
16th of February 2007 (Fri), 17:16
I'm glad that people share my concern. I hope the word gets out to more photographers.
Sorry Eccles, I didn't mean to sound like I was only concerned about North American birds. I think everyone can benefit from knowing what constitutes "disturbing" wildlife.

eccles
16th of February 2007 (Fri), 18:18
S'okay, Booswalia. I was only kidding. :D
I usually shoot butterflies and dragonflies, and although I do quite well with those insects, I am nowhere near to the standards of you guys when shooting birds, but the same cautions are valid with butterflies too. If you crash through undergrowth, trampling plants to get a butterfly shot, you may be inadvertedly crushing next years eggs or caterpillars. Tread lightly!

johnstoy
16th of February 2007 (Fri), 18:30
Very good "heads up" perspective...should be considered for a Sticky:

Booswalia
17th of February 2007 (Sat), 07:03
Thanks John, Perhaps you could suggest that to the moderator.

johnstoy
17th of February 2007 (Sat), 07:17
Thanks John, Perhaps you could suggest that to the moderator.

Do you think flags go up when we use the word "Moderator" in our posts? They do have that stealthy ability to magically appear and do wonderful things with this forum...Let see what happens in the next day or so...thereafter, I'll PM one promptly...

foxbat
17th of February 2007 (Sat), 07:30
Good information. The codes that I follow are set out here:

http://www.rspb.org.uk/Images/BIRDPHOT_tcm5-43180.pdf
http://www.americanbirding.org/abaethics.htm

qhorses
17th of February 2007 (Sat), 09:10
Great info here. Thanks for posting.

nitefrogger
17th of February 2007 (Sat), 10:29
Very worthwhile reminders. These principles actually apply to ALL wildlife.

StarDog
17th of February 2007 (Sat), 10:53
Shirley, Thanks for the post. I know in the heat of the hunt guidelines may not be on top. We wildlife folk see much more disturbance from the general public that may seem way over what we might do but even small disruptions in the life of critters can cause great harm. - Bob

sam walker
29th of March 2007 (Thu), 21:57
A good post Booswalia et al. i have a bald eagle nest that I regularly monitor. An unusual location that is behind the parking lot of a bar above a volleyball court. I was shocked to see that they would pick such a busy human site. I did take it slow when I first found it not wanting to be the one who caused an abandonment. This particular pair is very calm although wary of humans below and always watching. I did send photos from last year's visit to another birding site in the UK and was strongly critisized for posting a nest that I was likely disturbing. Happy to see that similar pics posted here have not been struck out. Every case is different and any nesting bird should be approached with care. My most terrifying instance came with a redwing blackbird. Not a imposing bird like a raptor. I walked too close to a nest.The cock, unhappy at my nearness flew down and got in my face beating his wings and yelling. Very effective in getting me to change my course quickly.Take it slow with all of them.We are all 20+ times their size. You'd freak too if your spouse were in the yard with your child and an elephant came lumbering in.
Sam

Accentor
30th of March 2007 (Fri), 06:09
As eccles says, these guidlines are (or should be) applicable everywhere. In N America, the UK and other parts of N Europe we do have a natural sympathy for the protection and preservation of wildlife and habitat. Sadly, in S Europe this is not the case and most people in Mediteranean countries would laugh their socks off if you presented them with guidelines as to how not to disturb wild birds and animals. Their only concern is whether or not these things are edible and, if they are, how can they capture and kill them.

Having said that, there is in the UK a certain amount of friction and conflict between birders/birdwatchers and hard-core photographers; a certain faction of the latter seem willing to go to any lengths to "get the shot" and the wellfare of the birds is often a low priority.

calicokat
30th of March 2007 (Fri), 06:10
Great post and great info

mike85
7th of October 2007 (Sun), 15:16
WOW Great information.

aarathi
7th of November 2007 (Wed), 01:46
This was the good information about birds. This was very helpful and useful to study about birds. This makes love towards birds.

medic583
13th of February 2008 (Wed), 19:45
Booswalia, thanks for the great note and reminder of the impact we can have on wildlife. Even though I am lucky enough to have many species of wildlife visit my home each and every day... I have to remember it me who is residing in their habitat... and that my actions do affect their life as well.

Thank you soo much for the reminder to this rookie :)

The_Caper
15th of February 2008 (Fri), 18:54
A very good post Shirley and so very important. Thank you so much for taking the time to post this info.

I also agree with nitefrogger that this info can or should be applied to all wildlife.

Cheers.

Paul.

dazzlebea
23rd of February 2008 (Sat), 18:07
Great post and only too relevant due to the fact that more and more people own DSLRs with long lenses. It seems like it is very easy to focus on getting the shot and forgetting about the important issue: the welfare of the subject.

Approximately 1 year ago I took 2 friends of mine down to San Diego County where a pair of Bald Eagles was nesting (http://UBSeng.zenfolio.com/p798472007/). When we arrived we were disappointed that there were fences and signs keeping us at quite a distance. One of my friends decided to ignore the fence and sings and got better shots than my other friend and I did. Ah well... so what?!?

RPCrowe
3rd of May 2008 (Sat), 16:34
Moose Anderson, the great wildlife photographer says (and I totally agree):

"There is no image worth harming the subject to obtain"

IMO, disturbing nesting birds is a harmful action as is to intrude on an animal's (bird, reptile or mamal) feeding/mating area...

ladytiger
12th of May 2008 (Mon), 16:29
Thanks for the information.And so very true

csquared63
11th of June 2008 (Wed), 21:56
This is a very good post.

I'd like to add a link to a wikihow article for getting into birdwatching. I found one thing particularly interesting. They warn that it is not prudent to make "pish" sounds during migration periods. They claim that it further stresses already stressed birds and may contribute to their death. I've been birdwatching for over 30 years and this is the first time I ever heard this, but it seems to makes sense.

http://www.wikihow.com/Bird-Watch (http://www.wikihow.com/Bird-Watch)

Abagail
27th of September 2008 (Sat), 12:53
Thank you for the great information! I agree completely, in my opinon that will assist to some one. see these pet portraits (http://www.paintyourlife.com) that really nice.

STP 40D
28th of September 2008 (Sun), 12:38
I prefer to shoot from far away. I think it gives the best opportunity to shoot an animal in its' natural habitat, unfettered by any concern caused by people getting to close.

As an aside, I find it rather interesting that photographers will go out of their way to not upset wildlife when they shoot pictures, but will often dismiss the concerns of people when shooting pictures. Not passing a verdict, just making an observation...

LV Moose
31st of January 2009 (Sat), 12:00
The Birds We Love.....



The Birds I Hate.....


Freaking pigeons!



Okay, I'm done now.

canonloader
31st of January 2009 (Sat), 12:05
Hey Moose, I take it you have never eaten one?

Delicious. Skin it and fry in a pan with butter. You will love them after that. ;)

LV Moose
31st of January 2009 (Sat), 12:44
Hey Moose, I take it you have never eaten one?

Delicious. Skin it and fry in a pan with butter. You will love them after that. ;)


Hmmm...

That's kind of the only way I like cats, too.

But I think we're getting off topic ;).

In all cerealness... good topic, and thread. But most of my wildlife photography takes place in my back yard, and those damn hummingbirds give me a lot more consternation than I give them!

digital_photog
12th of February 2009 (Thu), 19:07
Great to see that some have an interest in protecting our fine feathered friends!! I happen to see a few photographers chasing a Snowy Owl recently and the bird flew away with one photographer tramping through the snow following the Owl. This was so unnecessary considering the person had a long lens (perhaps a 600mm). The owl outsmarted that person and landed far away. We need to respect their habitat and not interfer with their survival.
JMHO Fred

Loopy
14th of February 2009 (Sat), 18:21
I have volunteered with a few bird organizations over the past few years. As a new member here, it was very good to see this thread!
I've seen photgs climbing into trees to get closer, people chasing them and worse. So many birds are declining in population that we need to be very aware of what we're doing.
Now it's time to get back to taking pics!

Here and There
15th of February 2009 (Sun), 15:58
We need to respect their habitat and not interfer with their survival.
JMHO Fred

+1 million! Around here some of the best birding sites are in and around sensitive wetland areas. There are signs that encourage you to stay on the designated paths/trails to avoid excessive wear and tear on the wetlands and though it's not mentioned in the signs, this also helps to keep a respectful distance from birds that live in these wetlands. I find it incredibly annoying and ignorant when birders, photographers, joggers, cyclists, people with dogs, etc., ignore these postings and roam wherever they please.

LordBrian
16th of March 2009 (Mon), 18:44
I would like to know peoples views on using flash's on wildlife. I personally don't like doing it as I don't think they would like it.

artyman
16th of March 2009 (Mon), 19:07
They probably think it's lightning, but I expect I would avoid it personally.

canonloader
16th of March 2009 (Mon), 19:10
I don't use flash on birds cause it's a pain in the butt to use. When I have used it, most of the birds ignored it, some flinched, some took off. I have since learned to use exposure compensation and won't flash the poor critters any more. I hate it myself, I suppose they do to. :)

lauraandski
21st of April 2009 (Tue), 21:30
Thanks for posting. We just found our first bald eagle nest, and are excited about watching the babies grow.