English Church

[rhommel]

HDR - English church

http://www.flickr.com/photo_zoom.gne?id=512808346&size=l
http://farm1.static.flickr.com/193/512808346_c8d23b88c1.jpg

[sando]

Looks like it was drawn with crayons, frankly.

[Paul Tinworth]

Looks like it was drawn with crayons, frankly.

With respect, I entirely disagree.

I think you've done an excellent job, rhommel! :)

[kenyc]

Unfortunately this is over-done. It looks like a comic-book drawing. :)

KAC

[PeppermintP]

Unfortunately this is over-done. It looks like a comic-book drawing. :)

KAC

yeh, but is that always a bad thing? I guess it kinda depends what you are looking for in an image. Personally I kinda like the look, but I feel it is too tightly cropped at the bottom - I want to see the floor.

[rhommel]

Unfortunately this is over-done. It looks like a comic-book drawing. :)

KAC

I wanted it to look like a comic-book drawing :)

let me ask you, why is it unfortunate?

[kato1]

I love the effect of these HDRs.
Well done

[KGB]

I like it ...what PP did you do to get the effect ??

[mrmkt]

I like the artistic look. Well done

Mark

[Glenn NK]

Yes it's nice - but if I didn't know it was a photo, I would assume the artist used pencil crayons (coloured pencils).

The only clue that it's a photo is that the exterior walls and columns are not vertical.

[curiousgeorge]

Well done for the effort, but I hope this isn't the future of photography.

[BigBlueDodge]

I agree. It's too over the top. Nothing natural looking about it at all

[jdizzle]

I've seen great HDRs that look very natural and this one isn't. I like it but, it's too overdone in saturation and colors. I understand the look you are going for but, if you tone down the saturation a bit you'll be fine. I can't say I'm a pro but, when I first started PPing, I overdid everything. I occasionally over do it every now and than but, I'm still learning too. Try another attempt and make sure your monitor is calibrated. I know alot of people who work on there photos and they don't have there monitor calibrated. Thanks for sharing.

[rhommel]

Yes it's nice - but if I didn't know it was a photo, I would assume the artist used pencil crayons (coloured pencils).

The only clue that it's a photo is that the exterior walls and columns are not vertical.

I agree. It's too over the top. Nothing natural looking about it at all

I've seen great HDRs that look very natural and this one isn't. I like it but, it's too overdone in saturation and colors. I understand the look you are going for but, if you tone down the saturation a bit you'll be fine. I can't say I'm a pro but, when I first started PPing, I overdid everything. I occasionally over do it every now and than but, I'm still learning too. Try another attempt and make sure your monitor is calibrated. I know alot of people who work on there photos and they don't have there monitor calibrated. Thanks for sharing.

Thank you for all your comments... Your comments made my image a SUCCESS because that is EXACTLY what I was going for, to make my photo look like it's not a photo :)

[steveathome]

You can see the image more clearly on your link, I think its great

[eenorton]

I'm a big fan of HDR stuff. I like the shots that have a natural look to them.... and I like the shots that are over the top. I think it's great!