View Full Version : A is for ...
contact
15th of May 2004 (Sat), 16:07
http://mwb.smugmug.com/photos/4247124-L.jpg
Any suggesting in making this more creative?
vvizard
15th of May 2004 (Sat), 16:35
Apples and Avocadoes :) Great colors on this one. I almost got a lust for fruit now.. And that's not often =D
karusel
15th of May 2004 (Sat), 18:48
You should photograph perfect fruit or at least make it look perfect in PS... the left apple has a brown mark that draws unwanted attention... pretty much the same applies to the avocado right to that apple...
stopbath
17th of May 2004 (Mon), 14:15
I don't know, but I would not catagorically strive remove all blemishes from fruit. I think they can add interest to a photo.
I don't think the photo benefits from the blemish, but still, the photo is a good one. (I'm not keen on the grout line though, there are no others to balance it out.)
Sendide
22nd of May 2004 (Sat), 02:15
nice shot,
could you please post the setting for this picture?
thanks
regards
Cem
22nd of May 2004 (Sat), 20:23
Nice color and sharpness and composition...I think it can be more atractively with some light and shadows.
contact
25th of May 2004 (Tue), 23:06
Canon 10D
f/22.0
ISO 100
50 mm
John_T
26th of May 2004 (Wed), 08:57
Perhaps I am wrong, but are the apples wet and the avocados dry?
Malok
26th of May 2004 (Wed), 12:36
I like the shot generally, but find the white background, particularly on the top left side rather distracting. My eye goes to the background rather than the fruit. Perhaps a background which isn't quite as light would help too.
Malok
contact
26th of May 2004 (Wed), 22:01
Yes, the apples are wet and avocados are dry.
Thanks for all the comments!
gazettalux
27th of May 2004 (Thu), 11:48
add anchovies
John_T
27th of May 2004 (Thu), 12:19
Replace the apples with tomatoes and make some tacos.
Mark Kemp
27th of May 2004 (Thu), 12:57
A is for
A still life? or A bunch of fruit? :lol:
Seriously though I am not convinced about the composition. It seems a bit tight on all 4 sides. There isn't one whole fruit shown, but on the other hand they are still easily recognisable so that it is not very abstract either.
There is nothing really wrong with the shot, it is certainly technically fine, well exposed, good colours etc. But for me its just that, it doesn't really make me want to eat the fruit. Nor do I wonder for a while what it is. There is no particular commonality of tone or form to the elements.
Still life is always very difficult to compose, especially for something like fruit that has been done so many times already. This why I don't do much still life I think, shortage of original ideas or compositional skill. But I am impressed with those who can do it. I would practice some more and try moving the elements around and see what please you. Maybe even add or remove some elements or change something. You could perhaps cut one apple and one avocado in half and show then next to some whole ones. Maybe even leave the knife in shot? -- See those are the best ideas I can come up with -- told you I can't do still life :roll: , maybe I should practice and learn as well. If I get round to it I will post something here.
vBulletin® v3.6.7, Copyright ©2000-2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.