Opinions needed, Please!

[Milner]

OK I have been trying out different workflows/pp to streamline big jobs.
I have posted 3 versions of 2 photos in a gallery that I would GREATLY appreciate your opinions one. Ignore composition ect, I took the first two as a representative sample of conditions for the show. Just looking for opinions on which you like best from a PP stand point. I know there is a lot that can be improved, but I am trying to cut back my time and still have satifactory results.
http://www.milspecphoto.com/gallery/3142165#172391281

THANKS
Marc

PS captions of the phots indicate the workflow.

Edit: added 2 more options

[symes]

I'll be the first to say that the images are far too small for me to give any sort of opinion on the subtleties of what your asking...

Cheers,

[Milner]

I'll be the first to say that the images are far too small for me to give any sort of opinion on the subtleties of what your asking...

Cheers,

Larges and originalsedits are availble if you toggle over the photo....

[narlus]

i vote #2 (Breeze Browser raw to jpg to i2e plug in)

[12stones]

i vote #2 (Breeze Browser raw to jpg to i2e plug in)

I agree.