PDA

View Full Version : should i crop?


RoB_m
13th of July 2004 (Tue), 18:43
i've posted this before but i'm about to make a huge print of this image and it's costing me about $14 to make, so i want to get it right. i want to know if you guys think i should keep the large cloud formation at the right edge of the image or should i crop them out?

http://rexthewonderhorse.com/rob/utahrocks.jpg

Shakey
13th of July 2004 (Tue), 18:58
I think it adds depth. Keep it

ChrisN
13th of July 2004 (Tue), 20:34
This may sound silly to some, but I think that if you crop it out, it will make the mountain look lopsided.

the angles in the ridges and the way the horizon slopes will make it feel as though the camera was not straight when the shot was taken.

I think you should leave it in. its only 14 dollars and you shot it yourself, which makes it that much more of a conversation piece

Zqy
14th of July 2004 (Wed), 01:30
Keep it as is, I agree that without it the mountain by itself would not appear staight on the horizon, it also provides good depth.

Nice image.

Zerah

stopbath
14th of July 2004 (Wed), 10:24
Leave the clouds. They echo the slop of the rock formation. Nice shot!

RoB_m
14th of July 2004 (Wed), 10:49
well, it's unanimous. i kept the clouds and got a nice 8"x44" print on epson premium lustre. LOVE this paper. thanks, people.

paulj48
15th of July 2004 (Thu), 03:46
well, it's unanimous. i kept the clouds and got a nice 8"x44" print on epson premium lustre. LOVE this paper. thanks, people.

What resolution did you get this print from? Was it 2185x413 if so what was the print quality like at only 50dpi?

RoB_m
15th of July 2004 (Thu), 12:22
well, it's unanimous. i kept the clouds and got a nice 8"x44" print on epson premium lustre. LOVE this paper. thanks, people.

What resolution did you get this print from? Was it 2185x413 if so what was the print quality like at only 50dpi?

that's just my web version for display on forums.

it's a 5 image panorama. i was able to print it 30" wide at 300dpi and 41" wide at a little over 200dpi 8)