PDA

View Full Version : what lens to what camera and why?


MrsOpie
25th of September 2007 (Tue), 22:01
i just purchased a Canon 20D (the baby) to go with my Canon 5D (the big mother). I also have a 24-70/2.8 and a 70-200/2.8. What lens should I put on what body and why? I plan on using both cameras during the ceremony and then just using 1 camera for formals/reception. I've never shot with a 2 camera combo so I would like some advice. :)

Livinthalife
25th of September 2007 (Tue), 22:03
24-70 on the 5D for wide shots, and the tele on the 20D for the crop factor.

That's what I would do. congrats on the "new" camera!

notapro
25th of September 2007 (Tue), 22:06
I'm interested in hearing responses to this too. don't mind me while I subscribe...

tim
25th of September 2007 (Tue), 22:14
24-70 on the 5D for wide shots, and the tele on the 20D for the crop factor.

I agree, for those reasons.

cccp145
25th of September 2007 (Tue), 22:20
24-70 on the 5D for wide shots, and the tele on the 20D for the crop factor.
same

MrsOpie
25th of September 2007 (Tue), 22:22
the 70-200 is a heavy lens can the 20D handle the weight of the lens?

JaertX
25th of September 2007 (Tue), 22:26
the 70-200 is a heavy lens can the 20D handle the weight of the lens?

yes...that's the combo I used for quite a while.

tim
25th of September 2007 (Tue), 22:39
the 70-200 is a heavy lens can the 20D handle the weight of the lens?

Yes, no problem. With big lenses you always support the lens and let the camera hang off the back.

MrsOpie
25th of September 2007 (Tue), 23:09
I plan on having both cameras around my neck so one of them will be just hanging there pointing at the ground while I'm shooting with the other.

tim
25th of September 2007 (Tue), 23:11
I find that gets uncomfortable, I leave the camera i'm not using on the ground. The 20D will probably be fine with the 70-200 F2.8 hanging off it, but I wouldn't do it regularly to my own camera/lens.

MrsOpie
25th of September 2007 (Tue), 23:20
I find that gets uncomfortable, I leave the camera i'm not using on the ground. The 20D will probably be fine with the 70-200 F2.8 hanging off it, but I wouldn't do it regularly to my own camera/lens.

So tim what your saying is have the 5D and 24-70 combo on my neck and the 20D and 70-200 combo on the ground and then pick it up every so often to take a close up shot? I tend to move around a lot to get different shots during the ceremony. I'm open to ideas. How do you do it?

tim
25th of September 2007 (Tue), 23:33
So tim what your saying is have the 5D and 24-70 combo on my neck and the 20D and 70-200 combo on the ground and then pick it up every so often to take a close up shot? I tend to move around a lot to get different shots during the ceremony. I'm open to ideas. How do you do it?

My 70-200 gets left in the aisle during the ceremony, and carried if I want it to come with me.

Tish
26th of September 2007 (Wed), 00:05
So tim what your saying is have the 5D and 24-70 combo on my neck and the 20D and 70-200 combo on the ground and then pick it up every so often to take a close up shot? I tend to move around a lot to get different shots during the ceremony. I'm open to ideas. How do you do it?

This is typically what I do--both 20Ds are on me, but the 17-55 is around my neck & the 70-200 on the ground/floor if I'm stuck in one place for any length of time. If I'm truly on the run the whole ceremony, I have them both physically on me, with the 70-200 on my right shoulder. The strap is long enough that I can pull into position to use, then drop it back out of my way to use the shorter strapped one around my neck.

The 70-200 and the 20D do just fine. I do prefer to use a grip & handstrap with that combo though, it's a LOT more comfortable if you're doing any significant shooting.

cdifoto
26th of September 2007 (Wed), 00:12
Yep make your long lens longer and your wide lens wider. No-brainer to me. Same reason I go with the 24-70 on the 1D and 70-200 on the 10D. I also hang the 10D/70-200 combo around my neck all the time and let it hang. No biggy, no concerns.

jessiper
26th of September 2007 (Wed), 00:19
24-70 on the 5D for wide shots, and the tele on the 20D for the crop factor.

That's what I would do. congrats on the "new" camera!

That's exactly why I put the 24-105 on my 5D and the 70-200 on my 30D. 24mm isn't wide enough on the 30D.

Congrats, as well!

jessiper
26th of September 2007 (Wed), 00:21
So tim what your saying is have the 5D and 24-70 combo on my neck and the 20D and 70-200 combo on the ground and then pick it up every so often to take a close up shot? I tend to move around a lot to get different shots during the ceremony. I'm open to ideas. How do you do it?

I put my 5D w/wide angle around my neck, and the 30D w/70-200 on my shoulder throughout the entire event. I may set one of them done for just a few seconds, though.

Nan08
26th of September 2007 (Wed), 00:25
Isn't it fun? I have my first wedding this sat and I've already planned to do this combo. 70-200 on 30d and 24-70 on 5d for the ceremony. And before that, I'll probably have my Nifty on my 5d and 24-70 on my 30d when Bride is getting ready in the room.

So you already decided Opie?

picturecrazy
26th of September 2007 (Wed), 01:36
Wow, I never really put the second body down. Especially after seeing how blatant some of the thieves have been lately. dressing up as a guest, grabbing gear sitting about 3 ft from you... yikes.

anyhow, I would configure the cameras just as everyone above says and buy a couple Op/tech Pro Loop straps! Whoa they make such a difference in carrying that weight for an all day shoot.

jessiper
26th of September 2007 (Wed), 01:43
anyhow, I would configure the cameras just as everyone above says and buy a couple Op/tech Pro Loop straps! Whoa they make such a difference in carrying that weight for an all day shoot.

Do you have to have the battery grip for those? I thought I had read that somewhere, but I'd love to get a wrist strap.

cdifoto
26th of September 2007 (Wed), 01:45
Do you have to have the battery grip for those? I thought I had read that somewhere, but I'd love to get a wrist strap.

The Pro-Loop is just like any other shoulder strap. No grip required. It's the E-1 wrist strap that requires a grip.

picturecrazy
26th of September 2007 (Wed), 02:06
Do you have to have the battery grip for those? I thought I had read that somewhere, but I'd love to get a wrist strap.

The e1 strap is a wonderful thing too. I have the pro loop AND e1 strap on my Mark III and wouldn't have it any other way.

And yes, the e1 strap fits beautifully on a 20/30/40/5D with grip. As far as I can see, the e1 strap is the ONLY reason I would put a grip on a body. Otherwise I find it the most useless piece of gear I own and am thinking of selling it.

RobKirkwood
26th of September 2007 (Wed), 02:50
I also shoot primarily with 24-70 f2.8 on 5D and 70-200 f2.8 IS on 20D, and both cameras have Canon grips fitted. Only problem I've found with the combinations is there's a gap between the 70mm on 5D and the 70mm on 20D (effective equivalent 112mm) and once or twice indoors with limited space I've found 70/5D too short and 70/20D too long and been unable to move without causing distraction.

I also put the 70-200/20D on the ground next to me when I'm using it (lives in a Peli case when not), but there are two of us about.

Rob