Beach Panorama

[Boucher]

Technically this isnt my photo. It's my friend's photo but I had a go at editing it.

I'd like to know what u think.

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2403/2186702043_86e002f725_b.jpg

[scorpio_e]

I would clone out a few things. Piece of grass in lower right corner and the dust speck (right side near clouds). Other than that great shot.

[PETERSYMES]

It is quite a nice shot, but along with Scorpio_e crop comments a i find the brightness range left to right a little too much.

[WhiBal]

I'm with scorpio_e. And I like the brightness range. It gives this shot a nice bit of drama and a very strong feel. Not everybody's taste I'm sure, but it works well for me.

What did you do to your friends pic and why did you post it as it's not yours? Just curious to hear if you think it's a good shot or well just well edited?

[Boucher]

Well at the time He couldnt be bothered to edit it, and I was bored so decided to get this photo off him.

I was just looking for an all round C&C for him and me.

As to the shot, the exposure was a bit off, see the underexposed foreground. but I think its a good shot. To tell you the truth its probably the most extensive editing I've done on any image so far.

[Canon30Dguy]

I really like it... love the range in the sky. But it seems a bit crooked to me... like it needs to be rotated CCW a few degrees...no? The only thing I would do extra is perhaps boost the vibrance in the middle-left area of the photo... under the set of clouds where you have that bit of muted teal. Bring out the color in that and it may help. Maybe not though.

[Boucher]

Thanks for you comments. :)

Yeah I don't think I rotated it enough.