PDA

View Full Version : Color or Black & White (Pix)


streetsilence
4th of April 2008 (Fri), 16:23
Wanted to get some feedback from these 2 images. Let me know what you think...color or black and white, If any. Thanks in advance for the feedback.

Title: Number 24
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3090/2385886447_9abdb9eaf0.jpg

Title: Number 24 B&W
http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2401/2386717492_94dd8f9a33.jpg
Both taken with Canon 400D, 18-55mm Kit Lens and processed in Photomatix.

BottomBracket
4th of April 2008 (Fri), 17:54
I like the BW photo. The colored one is good too though I would like the saturation to be a bit more subdued.

streetsilence
4th of April 2008 (Fri), 18:18
I like the BW photo. The colored one is good too though I would like the saturation to be a bit more subdued.

Thanks for the feedback... I definitely understand with you mean by the saturation. I'll be more aware of that next time for sure. Thanks again. Peace!

Gary Lindquist
4th of April 2008 (Fri), 18:21
I prefer the color image but do think that if you want to title it "Number 24" you should recrop so that the '24' is not so close to the edge. Not much, just enough to get it off the edge.

streetsilence
4th of April 2008 (Fri), 18:35
I prefer the color image but do think that if you want to title it "Number 24" you should recrop so that the '24' is not so close to the edge. Not much, just enough to get it off the edge.

Good advice... It was just a little subtle thing that I thought was kind of cool. I;m not really stuck on the name, but that isthe least of my worries... Really just trying to improve. I'm still a newbie (5 months in). Thanks for the feedback as well. Highly appreciated.

Gary Lindquist
4th of April 2008 (Fri), 18:40
streetsilence, I love the title--it really works. I would, however, recrop (if possible) to get it off the edge. Not possible?

streetsilence
5th of April 2008 (Sat), 12:12
streetsilence, I love the title--it really works. I would, however, recrop (if possible) to get it off the edge. Not possible?

Thanks Gary. Really appreciate the feedback. I'll definitely try re-cropping. Glad you like the title. Peace!

Darsk47
5th of April 2008 (Sat), 19:56
I vote for the B&W.

Shimpu
6th of April 2008 (Sun), 10:35
I like the color one. Reminded me the Matrix movie. :)

streetsilence
6th of April 2008 (Sun), 13:14
Thanks for the feedback, highly appreciate it. Matrix...Really! What a compliment. I love the Matrix. Peace and Keep Creating everyone!