PDA

View Full Version : Shooting in NYC (Legal)


RobNYC
7th of October 2008 (Tue), 16:37
Here is something that could affect anyone who shoots in New York City.

A new law went into effect on August 13, 2008 under Title 43, Chapter 9, Rules of the City of New York. It seems we are lucky, but if you shoot video or use lights... maybe another story. I am not going to copy in the whole law, just what photographer's need to know.

MOFTB = Mayor's Office of Film, Theatre, and Broadcasting

a MOFTB permit is required for:

filming and taking of motion pictures
taking of photographs
(others I won't list)AND the person doing it is:

using vehciles or equipment OR
the activity obstructs 1 or more lanes of a street or walkway or bridge OR
the activity obstructs more than 1/2 of the sidewalk or other pedestrian passageway, or if the sidewalk is less than 16 feet, the activity obstructs more than 8 feet of passagewayEquipment is defined, and the definition does NOT include handheld devices. Handheld devices includes film cameras and tripods! So with a SLR and tripod you are OK. In fact, the release says "Therefore, a camera mounted on a tripod is a handhled device and no permit is required."

This new rule carries NO penalty, but other laws can be enforced, such as Disorderly Conduct for blocking the sidewalk. The new rule is also different if you have a NYC press pass issued by NYPD.

For those who like to shoot bridges, tunnels, trains, etc.
Bridges and tunnels under the jurisdiction of the Port Authority and the Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority have their own rules. They post signs that say photography is prohibited. They can arrest you or write you a summons for disobeying the signs. You are allowed to take photos in the NYC Subway without any permit as long as you don't use any ancillary equipment (so no tripod and no lighting equipment).

I am not your attorney, so feel free to get an attorney's opinion if you think you need it. I just thought some of you might find this useful since alot of people shoot in NY regularly or come in for vacation. :)

nicksan
8th of October 2008 (Wed), 11:00
So are you saying when I shot some pics while ON the Brooklyn Bridge, I was committing a crime?


Kewl!:lol:

RobNYC
8th of October 2008 (Wed), 11:13
LOL

tsw910
8th of October 2008 (Wed), 17:10
So are you saying when I shot some pics while ON the Brooklyn Bridge, I was committing a crime?


Kewl!:lol:

yeah LOL .. when i took some pictures of the verrazano bridge a few year back ... NY's finest HomeLand Security division came knocking on my door ... just to ask a few questions ..


but then i shouldn't have been there at 2am LOL

RobNYC
8th of October 2008 (Wed), 17:13
See but that follows the law anyway... the Verrazano is a TBTA bridge and they have a rule of no photography. The Brooklyn Bridge is not a TBTA bridge and we can photo it all we want!

tsw910
8th of October 2008 (Wed), 17:16
NICE ! .. i still have to make a point to get out there to snap some off

Road_Rebel
9th of October 2008 (Thu), 10:18
So are you saying when I shot some pics while ON the Brooklyn Bridge, I was committing a crime?


Kewl!:lol:

lol, joker

nicksan
9th of October 2008 (Thu), 15:07
Damn...and I thought I was being bad arse mofo.:lol:

Good info...didn't know that.
I was under the impression that using a tripod in NYC was a no-no regardless, but I guess that isn't the case.

Rob, at least your education is being put to good use...like educating POTN members...eh? ;-)

See but that follows the law anyway... the Verrazano is a TBTA bridge and they have a rule of no photography. The Brooklyn Bridge is not a TBTA bridge and we can photo it all we want!

RobNYC
9th of October 2008 (Thu), 15:57
I like to lend a hand if I can :)
As far as a tripod goes in the city, if you tried to set up in a place like Times Square (or anywhere really) and you did block pedestrian traffic or cause a nuisance... a cop can always come along and tell you to move. If you refuse you can get arrested for disorderly conduct... this was always the case... but there is no tripod ban.

JCH77Yanks
14th of October 2008 (Tue), 21:52
yeah LOL .. when i took some pictures of the verrazano bridge a few year back ... NY's finest HomeLand Security division came knocking on my door ... just to ask a few questions ..


but then i shouldn't have been there at 2am LOL

Seriously? Where were you shooting from? I never had a problem shooting from the Dyker Beach/Bay Ridge walkway.

mleone
20th of November 2008 (Thu), 08:30
I bet its a new law to keep us safe from those terrorist! Sort of like taking off your shoes at airports or only having 3oz in a zip lock bag. Totally useless but looks like you are doing something!

seanzky
20th of November 2008 (Thu), 08:47
Good to know. I would have definitely done bridges without ever knowing it wasn't allowed on some.

toyguru
20th of November 2008 (Thu), 11:11
Equipment is defined, and the definition does NOT include handheld devices. Handheld devices includes film cameras and tripods! So with a SLR and tripod you are OK. In fact, the release says "Therefore, a camera mounted on a tripod is a handhled device and no permit is required."



So the size of the tripod is also not indicated? That would mean you could put one of those mini tripods you get "free" and shoot just about anywhere then! right?:grin:

AndOJones
7th of December 2008 (Sun), 19:35
first off thanks for the heads up.
But if the bridge says cameras are prohibited and you do it, your A more-on
Taking off your shoes at the airport is the least bit of things tooooo worry about homeboy, you should worry about your recycing instead son.

If you choose to be a bad-mon at the airport your azz should get arrested for non-compliant behavior just like if it says no cameras on the bridge and you get caught, no doubt in my mind, why the POLICE shouldn't get OT cuz of your dddddddumbazzzz

simplified24
13th of December 2008 (Sat), 00:05
first off thanks for the heads up.
But if the bridge says cameras are prohibited and you do it, your A more-on
Taking off your shoes at the airport is the least bit of things tooooo worry about homeboy, you should worry about your recycing instead son.

If you choose to be a bad-mon at the airport your azz should get arrested for non-compliant behavior just like if it says no cameras on the bridge and you get caught, no doubt in my mind, why the POLICE shouldn't get OT cuz of your dddddddumbazzzz

I hear you but.. its a tourist attraction.. people are taking pics every day!! My NYU photog course started off with the bridge as our first few assignments lol!!

RobNYC
13th of December 2008 (Sat), 08:59
What bridge are you referring to Simplified? All the lower Manhattan bridges are ok for pictures it is allowed.

philmar
19th of February 2009 (Thu), 17:39
now what if you're taking a photo of an American swimmer smoking a bong on a NYC bridge?