2 questions

[infeeneetee]

picture #1 (p/s: the clouds are not fake)

[infeeneetee]

#2

[gramps]

and the questions are?????????

[infeeneetee]

Question 1:

which better?..
#1 without lensflare
or
#2 with lensflare

Question 2:

My pictures become oversaturated after edited & saved in photoshop..

my work flow:-
1) open with sRGB color setting
2) make some editing
3) save as web (the preview has already shown the unwanted saturate color)

any idea?

sorry for my english...
and thanks in advance

[kb244]

I'm having a hard time figuring out what he's asking.... maybe soemthing like which is better.... ?

[gramps]

I don't see the lens flare...........

[dewmuw]

The lens flare runs in #2 from central to about 1 o'clock.


Without is better.

[gramps]

The lens flare runs in #2 from central to about 1 o'clock.


Without is better.


see what happens when you get old?

[dewmuw]

see what happens when you get old?

Your collection of camera gear gets too big? :)

[gramps]

Back to the topic...........I think #1 is better. As far as over saturation, are you changing the size of the picture before yousave for the web? Is the original shot as a jpg?

[chris.bailey]

#1) I like it without the lens flare. I dont see the benefit of introducing something that is normally avoided.

#2) Have you got sRGB colour space set in the camera or aRGB? Are you doing a colour space conversion when you load them for editing? Is your monitor calibrated even with Adobe Gamma or the like? If jpg, what setting have you got in camera? What do you mean by oversaturated?

[infeeneetee]

Back to the topic...........I think #1 is better. As far as over saturation, are you changing the size of the picture before yousave for the web? Is the original shot as a jpg?

thanks for the comments..

yes, i resized it before i save for the web ('save for web' in PS function).. and yes the original shot was in jpg..
any idea?

[infeeneetee]

#1) I like it without the lens flare. I dont see the benefit of introducing something that is normally avoided.

#2) Have you got sRGB colour space set in the camera or aRGB? Are you doing a colour space conversion when you load them for editing? Is your monitor calibrated even with Adobe Gamma or the like? If jpg, what setting have you got in camera?

i think g6 uses sRGB.. no color conversion was made since my PS is set to sRGB working space..

jpg setting:
Large/Superfine

What do you mean by oversaturated?

sorry, i think i've used a wrong term.. what i mean is, the color become more saturated when i save for web in PS..

[infeeneetee]

I'm having a hard time figuring out what he's asking.... maybe soemthing like which is better.... ?

sorry, not clear .. yeah, Question 1: which picture is better? picture #1 or picture #2

[Feihung08]

sorry, not clear .. yeah, Question 1: which picture is better? picture #1 or picture #2
Well considering I had such a hard time seeing the lens flare myself (getting old too) I would choose #1. I'm a big fan of 'scenic' shots being more natural, so the less 'editing' the beter IMHO.

[infeeneetee]

Well considering I had such a hard time seeing the lens flare myself (getting old too) I would choose #1. I'm a big fan of 'scenic' shots being more natural, so the less 'editing' the beter IMHO.

yeah, thanks for the comments.. i agree for that

[infeeneetee]

last time i have set my monitor calibration (Adobe Gamma).. and just now i found that it is better for not using the monitor calibration (is that true?).. so my another question is, how can i remove the monitor calibration that i have set it up and get back to normal?