NEWBIE TO DIGITAL

[JTF]

Good day all from the frozen north, Canada. I have finally decided to purchase my first digital camera for birding. Up to this point I have only used binos to view birds and would now like to photograph them. After reading much on the net (DP Review etc.) the best choice would be a digital slr, however I have seen some models for much less with optical zoom which may be a better point for me to start budget wise & for the fact that most of the functions on the higher end cameras I would probabley never use. One model I noticed was the Canon PowerShot S1 IS that as a 10x optical zoom (better than a zoom) from what I have seen when comparing both in various reviews. Some users report a "purple fringing" when using the zoom at longer points, that wouldn't be good after spending a few bucks on this model. Are there any users on this forumn that use this camera, if so any feedback would be great. Also does the software that comes with the camera allow you to transfer images from the camera to a pc using OS Win98. Thanks for any help and have a great week.

[cmM]

I dont think I could recommend a P&S camera for birding. Slow focus, shutter lag, etc... will become pretty big obstacles. I'd say get a DSLR, and some long lenses. Maybe start off with a used 10D and something like a 300 f/4 or maybe a 100-400.

[Geeeyejo]

I have both the S1 and the 10D. Really depends what you are looking to spend and how big you want to print the photos. The S1 can take some nice tele shots outdoors focusing is good, but there is a lag between shots. It does have image stabilization that works well - useful for full tele shots, especially at lower shutter speeds. I have experienced no fringing. The S1 will run you just over $300 US. A Factory Demo 10D plus the least expensive zoom (70-300) will run $1000 ($800 for the cam, $200 for the lens). You will also need a smaller "indoor" lens for the DSLR - the 50mm 1.8 is great for the money at about $80. A good Image Stabilized zoom for a DSLR will run You several hundred dollars more - you will also need a decent CF card for both - about $60. There really is no comparison between the cameras - the 10D is amazing, focuses fast and well in low light. I use both - carrying the S1 out nearly everywhere (much lighter/more portable than a DSLR) and have taken some very nice shots with it. I use the 10D exclusively indoors and when I am feeling more "serious"

[JTF]

Thanks for the help, yes maybe a used DSLR to start.

[cactusclay]

Shutter lag is definately frustrating.