PDA

View Full Version : to crop or not to crop

GeForceFX
2nd of April 2005 (Sat), 17:53
20D + EF-S 17-85

would you crop out the tree in the left or not?

http://users.telenet.be/ggoole1/cdp/IMG_3519.jpg

1/500 F13 ISO400 35mm



and an extra picture:

http://users.telenet.be/ggoole1/cdp/IMG_3526.jpg

1/250 F14 ISO400 26mm PS:cs b/w convert
ordnance1
2nd of April 2005 (Sat), 17:55
Yes
sparker1
2nd of April 2005 (Sat), 17:56
Yes.
GeForceFX
2nd of April 2005 (Sat), 18:04
ok, better? :lol:

http://users.telenet.be/ggoole1/cdp/IMG_3519b.jpg
sparker1
2nd of April 2005 (Sat), 18:24
Much better. I like it a lot. Many times, a tree serves as a good framing device. This one didn't help, IMO.
symes
2nd of April 2005 (Sat), 19:26
Yes much better without the tree...
flyfisher
2nd of April 2005 (Sat), 19:34
Yup better without tree.
MarkoPolo
3rd of April 2005 (Sun), 08:24
I vote yes, too. Pretty picture.
viczig
3rd of April 2005 (Sun), 08:41
Agree with the rest, the tree in the middle really pops out now. Nice picture.
DSMITH131
3rd of April 2005 (Sun), 13:11
Agree with the rest, the tree in the middle really pops out now. Nice picture.
Agree with the rest, the tree in the middle really pops out now. Nice picture.[/
Michaelmjc
3rd of April 2005 (Sun), 15:31
Definately not ! The tree adds dimension and depth to the picture it also serves as a natural frame. I liek it 100% better with it there.
neil_r
3rd of April 2005 (Sun), 15:35
Yes and Much :D


N
johnthebaptist
5th of April 2005 (Tue), 15:02
:confused: No comments on the second pic? I think it's awesome!
GeForceFX
5th of April 2005 (Tue), 15:09
ha :D

I thought it wasn't good because nobody said something about it :)
Mills
5th of April 2005 (Tue), 17:50
Yep. Much better. Nice one.
RbrtPtikLeoSeny
6th of April 2005 (Wed), 13:35
Love it without the tree. Well done. The second picture really intrigues me. I love it. Very different.
Vetteography
6th of April 2005 (Wed), 14:42
The second picture doesn't need a thing (And I didn't see a tree so.... ) ;)