Can't decide on this shot - CC?

[form]

I am not sure about the shot itself. I like the light angle and the deep orange and red, but I don't really know if the shot is actually any good. Opinions?

http://www.resolutionplan.com/Joey/Apr04_09/IMG_3973-1_POTN.jpg

[zelseman]

I like some greain in most shots that i see, but i think this one has too much. i also feel that the colors are just a tad warm.

[form]

Considered, okay reduced the redness of the group. There is grain in each one because the exposure was boosted in PP quite a bit.

[Svetlana]

I love the mood of this photo! maybe convert to b/w?

[elisesanchez]

I agree. Post it in bw. Grain sometimes is easier to look at in bw. You wouldn't lose the fun pattern in the carpet or the romantic light from the window.

[ozonepirate]

Yep adjust the curves and put in black and white

[form]

I did end up converting it to black & white for the final, largely because of the grain.