7-in-1 Review: ThinkTank Pro Speed Belt + Modular set (81 images)

[xenomorphic]

I was looking for a better way to carry my gear while shooting, and had a hard time deciding:
a) whether a belt system was something I should try, and
b) what I'd need for a belt system to work for me.

I just bought the ThinkTank Pro Speed Belt and a full Modular set, which includes:


Speed Changer
Lightning Fast
Large Lens Drop-in
Lens Changer 35
Lens Changer 50
Lens Changer 75 Pop-down


Seeing as I spent some time making my decision, I'm hoping this review might help others to decide.

A note about the review: This review covers a number of ThinkTank products that share many features and similar levels of quality. Where possible, I have tried to summarize common elements in one place without repeating the same thing for each product. There are a lot of images - mainly because it's the sort of thing I would appreciate if I was interested in the product and hadn't had a chance to go and check it out first - I hope the moderators will allow this indulgence. The non-studio quality backdrop sucks, but at least there are images...

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090530_4478.jpg




Why a belt system?

I have used and do use a fair amount of various photography gear bags and backpacks. These all fit the bill when it comes to transportation - some more comfortably than others. When it comes to which bags/backpacks are best for working out of while you are actually shooting, there are greater variations. A bags suitability depends greatly on the amount of gear you want to carry on a shoot or walkabout, as well as your shooting style and favoured lenses. Anyone can shoot comfortably carrying a single camera and attached lens in a bag - this is not the issue here. The question is how well a bag or backpack works for you while you are shooting and changing multiple lenses, attaching filters, switching bodies, etc. The answer most of the time is that finding a balance between ease and safety of transportation on the one hand, and the portability, flexibility and practicality neccessary for ease of shooting on the other hand always involves trade-offs of some kind:

Backpacks allow you to transport a lot, are comfortable to carry, but may be heavy and do require that you take them off fully or partly to access your gear. (ThinkTank, Kata and LowePro all make backpacks you can partially swing off your back to access part of the inside without putting the backpack down on the ground, but as a rule you still have to hold the backpacks in place while you're digging inside, and usually can't get at everything at once - so it is still cumbersome to a degree)

Shoulder-bags allow you to transport a lot - less comfortably, or less - more comfortably, and provide a fairly good balance between transportation and shooting. You still have to make an effort to keep the bag on your shoulder while you are shooting though, which reduces your freedom of movement somewhat, and can become very tiring if you're carrying a lot of gear. I find a fully loaded bag is often more tempting to set down than to carry - not necessarily a desirable of viable option in different settings.

Belt-systems allow you complete freedom of movement (short of rolling around on the ground), and at the same time keep all your gear on your person and extremely easily accessible when you need it. Belt-systems look more conspicuous and scream "Photographer" more than backpacks and shoulder-bags generally do, and so are perhaps less suitable for safe transportation.

As ThinkTank say on their site; your needs while you are shooting are different from your needs while in transit. Belt-systems, provide maximum attention to facility and ease of use while shooting, and as several users on POTN have stated, using a backpack or bag for transportation, and switching to a belt-system for shooting makes a lot of sense if your have the option of leaving your backpack somewhere safe.




The Belt-System

Initial rationale
Moving to a belt system seemed fairly radical to someone as obsessed with "normal" bags as I am. But as I tend to hopelessly over-pack, my bags always seem to weigh a bit more than is comfortable over time. Also, a bag that is really crammed full quickly becomes harder to work out of. So if a belt system would let me carry as many lenses as I needed, give me easy access to all those lenses while "in the field" - and preferably make it easier to change lenses - without weight becoming a great problem - then I'd definitely be interested.

Which belt?
With a rare couple of hours to kill I spent a long time at the local camera store trying out various combinations of belts and bags. ThinkTank's belt-system allows you to mix and match any number and type of bags and containers - called modular components - and securely fasten them onto a belt. All modular components feature the ability to either slide freely along the belt or be locked in place at a desired position. Locking is achieved by threading a plastic "tongue" through one of the hoops that run as a continuous band along the centre of the entire outside edge of the belts. ThinkTank's range of components features 17 different models in the Modular range, and 5 in the Skin range. Models from both ranges may be used and interchanged freely on the same belt. All the belts feature fastenings that seem extremely secure and rugged.

My first choice was between the Skin Belt, Pro Speed Belt, or the Steroid Speed Belt, listed in increasing order of "paddedness".

The Skin Belt is a light, unpadded belt that goes with the modular Skin-components, which are also unpadded. I wanted padding for my lenses, and considering the weight I'd probably be carrying, a padded belt seemed an obvious choice.

The Pro Speed Belt is a nicely padded, rounded belt about 5 cm wide and 1.5 cm thick, with an extremely solid snap-on buckle. It is very comfortable, light and strong. Modular components are fixed around the belt using a very sturdy and secure fastening mechanism (see images later in the review). The Pro Speed Belt is also compatible with a number of ThinkTanks backpacks - in that it can be fed through a slot at the base of the backpack, making it an integrated system.

The Steroid Speed Belt is somewhat different from the other two belts. It features about 10 cm wide padding for added support and comfort, and a separate, layered band running outside the padding for the modular components to fasten onto. These separate bands are fixed to the padding at 3 points - roughly corresponding to the left hipbone, right hipbone and centre back when the belt is worn. Modular components may be fastened to either band or across the front of the buckle, but may not be rotated past any of the fastening points. The fastening points feature extra connectors for the Pixel Racing Harness - an optional set of shoulderstraps to pass some of the weight onto your shoulders if you should feel the need for this.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090530_4474.jpg

I decided on the Pro Speed Belt because it is padded, comfortable and, most importantly, it allows free rotation of the modular components along its entire length, which the Steroid Speed Belt does not.

Which modular components to fix to the belt?
As previousy noted, ThinkTank offers a total of 22 modular components, 17 in the Modular range, 5 in the Skin range. The main difference between the two is that the Skin range is designed to be extremely light and compact, with no padding, while the Modular range features padding, often in the shape of an inset which can be removed.

All components can be used freely and combined, so which ones you choose is really up to what you need to carry. The problem, of course, is knowing which components are ideal for which piece of equipment. Faced with this decision, I gratefully turned to the Modular set, a prepackaged set of 6 components chosen by ThinkTank, which represents a good basic setup with the most widely used component/lens combinations. Buying the 6 components as parts of a set is also less expensive than buying each component individually, representing a saving of 20% according to ThinkTank.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090530_4476.jpg
The Modular Set box

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090530_4480.jpg
Opening The Modular Set box

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090530_4481.jpg
Package contains components and product information folder

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090530_4482.jpg
Product information is fairly light, but then again, the belt system is as good as self-explanatory in its elegant simplicity - the most important information here (if you need it) is the instructions on how to fit your components to your belt and make them either locked or gliding.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090530_4483.jpg
What?! Only 4 components? Two of the 6 components are hidden within other components.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090530_4486.jpg
All 6 components, clockwise from top left: Speed Changer, Lens Changer 35, Lens Changer 75 Pop-down, Large Lens Drop-in (Jeez - how did that silica gel packet get in the photo?!), Lens Changer 50, Lightning Fast

[xenomorphic]

Speed Changer

Internal dimensions: 7" long x 3.25" wide x 6" high (18 x 8 x 15 cm)

First up is the Speed changer, a small bag for carrying either a 1-series body, or a combination of smaller items such as a couple of small lenses, filters, memory-cards, rocketblower, etc. The Speed Changer features 2 main zippered compartments with inner subdivisions, and one additional zippered compartment that is directly accessible from the outside of the bag. The bag also features twin elasticated fishnet pockets on the outside.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090530_4487.jpg
Front view. Two sizes of zipper - main compartment features larger variety. All excellent quality and slide very easily.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090530_4488.jpg
Back view. Notice the velcro belt fastening flap affixed to the back and sides of the bag.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090530_4490.jpg
Left view

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090530_4491.jpg
Right view

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090530_4492.jpg
Fastening flap for belt open. The lower part of the flap with protruding "sidewings" features massive velcro which connects around the belt and back onto the base of the bag. The velcro sidewings wrap around and fasten to the sides of the bag, making it pretty close to impossible to rip the bag off the belt. Simple and quick to use, very strong and sturdy.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090530_4493.jpg
Fastening mechanism, inside view. Large velcro connection areas, and the white plastic "tongue" that is used to lock the bag in position on the belt (by threading it through one of the hoops on the belt).

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090530_4495.jpg
Size comparisons: Speed Changer, Pee Wee Pixel Pocket Rocket and standard CD-cover

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090530_4489.jpg
The Pee Wee in one of the front netting pockets - every Modular component features these netting pockets, stretched right across the front of the component and divided into two compartments by a seam in the middle. Useful for lens-cap or other small items

[xenomorphic]

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090530_4496.jpg
Pee Wee in the frontmost, flat, zippered pocket. Pocket extends entire height and width of the bag.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4497.jpg
Second zippered compartment open, revealing expandable sides and single divider, with innermost division featuring several slots for pens and a smaller, flat pocket. Also featured is a safety strap for attaching important items such as keys or your Pee Wee with all your memory cards to prevent it from falling out.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4499.jpg
Second zippered compartment loaded with Pee Wee, BIC ballpoint pen and CD - which fits nicely in the frontmost division - just to give you an idea of how big it is.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4501.jpg
Main compartment opened, showing padded inset and side pocket with rain-cover

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4503.jpg
Padded inset is fastened to velcro sides while in the bag, but is removable in one piece.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4504.jpg
Rain-cover is completely removable by undoing the velcro from around the red hoop. All ThinkTank bags have removable rain-covers fastened this way. Rain-cover is first-rate quality with taped seams and sewn to match the shape of the bag precisely.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4506.jpg
Padded inset contains 3 dividers with velcro fastenings. These can be removed or repositioned as you wish. All removed, the padding will house a 1-series body. A nice detail is the twin CF-card pocket on the outside of the padding.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4508.jpg
Another alternative is to remove the padding inset, but still use the padded dividers to separate stuff in your bag. Neat and flexible.

[xenomorphic]

Lightning Fast

Internal dimensions: 3.5" long x 2.5" wide x 8" high (9 x 6.5 x 19.5 cm)

The Lightning Fast is built to carry a Speedlite and extra batteries. Same excellent manufacturing quality as the Speed Changer and other components.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4510.jpg
Front view. The Lightning Fast has two main compartments, one for Speedlite and one for batteries (zipper on lower half, front)

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4518.jpg
Back view - note the belt-system connection flap in place and fastened down on the sides.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4511.jpg
Side view. Industrial strength zippers. Added string and clip grip on the zipper handle makes it extremely easy to operate.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4513.jpg
Belt connection flap open, revealing exactly the same system as for the Speed Changer, with white plastic tongue for locking its position on the belt.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4515.jpg
Spare batteries for the flash-unit fit nicely in this pocket. You might be able to cram an extra set in there, but its clearly meant to allow 4 batteries.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4516.jpg
Main compartment open, revealing padded lining unit and rain-cover fastening (at left, in an inner pocket in the main compartment)

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4517.jpg
Padding and rain-cover removed. Padding fits the 580EXII snugly but with a little room to spare. I use the excellent David Honl flash accessories, all of which are fastened to the flash head using the David Honl Speedstrap - a velcro band with rubberized backing - strapped around the uppermost edge of the flashhead. The padding fits the flash without having to remove this strap from the flash first.

Rain-cover fits nicely over the lightning fast in event of rain and is easy to put on and remove.

[xenomorphic]

Large Lens Drop-in

Internal dimensions: 5" top diameter x 7" high (12.7 x 17.8 cm)

This is the component I was most intrigued by, simply because I was curious as to whether a specialized container for lens-changes was justifiable given that you might just want to buy an extra Lens Changer for the job. The drop-in, however, features a faster opening and closing mechanism than the Lens Changers, and is also roomy enough to allow far very fast and easy placement and retrieval of lenses - even the 16-35 f2.8 L II with its very broad hood. Also, having a dedicated space like this ensures that you actually have somewhere to put that lens you are changing. It provides you with "the extra hand" you need to change lenses - particularly with the larger, unwieldy ones.

Think tank offers a smaller version of this component, simply called the "Lens Drop-in" - I don't really see the need for such a component, however - the Large version will serve smaller lenses equally well given its depth, and should prove to be the more versatile of the two.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4549.jpg
The Large Lens Drop-in is fairly deep, wide and has padded, yet looser side-walls than the Lens Changers, presumably to allow for easier placement and withdrawal of lenses. The rim of the opening seems to be strengthened by an inner loop that keeps the edges from collapsing in on the lens/opening.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4550.jpg
The rear of the component features the same fastening mechanism as the Speed Changer and other components

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4551.jpg
The cover or closing mechanism takes form of a large diaphragm or aperture and is made from an extremely soft and elastic yet strong material. When the drawstring is pulled, the aperture closes, when it is released, the aperture more or less falls open at the touch of a finger - very easily and quickly.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4554.jpg
Size comparison - The Large Lens Drop-in compared to the 85 1.2 L II with hood attached. The Drop-in functions almost like a champagne-cooler - you can easily drop a longer lens like the 100-400 or one of the 70-200's into it and it will stay nicely in place, resting against the rim of the bag.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4555.jpg
Unlike the other components, the Drop-in has a pocket for its rain-cover on the outside and underside of the bag. The pocket closes with velcro and easy to use.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4557.jpg
Drop-in with 85 1.2 L II with hood mounted inside, and raincover ready to put on.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4559.jpg
Drop-in with rain-cover and 85 1.2L II with hood inside.

[xenomorphic]

Lens Changer 35, Lens Changer 50 and Lens Changer 75 Pop-down

35: Internal dimensions: 4" top diameter x 9" high (10 x 23 cm)
50: Internal dimensions: 4.5" top diameter x 7" high (11.5 x 18 cm)
75: Internal dimensions: 4.5" top diameter x 10.75"-14.5" high (11.5 x 27-37 cm)

The Lens Changers are the real bread-and-butter of the belt-system, providing safe storage and easy access to your lenses at a very comfortable waist height. The bags come in several sizes, also a few more than the 35, 50 and 75 included in the Modular Kit. The packaging states that the 35, 50 and 75 are perfect for the 24-70, 16-35, and 70-200 lenses, respectively. This is indeed true, but any lens that fits within the size of the example lens will be a good match.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4520.jpg
The Lens Changer 50, Lens Changer 35 and Lens Changer 75 with base collapsed, respectively.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4521.jpg
The Lens Changers from behind - Speed Belt locking attachment mechanism, similar to the Speed Changer, Notice how the width of each individual belt fastener varies to correspond to the width of the actual component - this gives extra stability for wider components.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4523.jpg
The Lens Changer 50 with the 16-35 2,8 L II, the 35 with the 24-70 2,8 L, and the 75 with the 100-400 4.5-5.6 L.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4522.jpg
With hoods attached and reversed

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4524.jpg
Lenses with hoods reversed i their respective bags. Pleny of space. Easy to get the lenses in and out of the bags.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4525.jpg
The bags feature a cover-flap attached to the side of the inner compartment. When folded out, it protects the lens and interiour from dust coming through the bungee-cord opening mechanism.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4526.jpg
Cover-flaps in place and bungee tightened. Bungee-cords are easy to operate and slide freely by pressing down on the self-locking bungee stops.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4527.jpg
A belt system is meant to facilitate rapid access and quick shooting, so the possibility of storing lenses with their hoods would make sense. Are the bags up for the challenge?

[xenomorphic]

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4528.jpg
Bags with lenses inside, hoods on. A bit tight for the Lens Changer 35 (middle) perhaps, but the 50 and 75 have room to spare with these lenses. Note that the pop-down feature of the 75 pop-down has been used.

The Pop-Down feature
The Lens Changer 75 has a seriously clever feature allowing you to extend the bag and increase its depth by about 3-4 inches as need arises. This will allow storing pretty long tele-zoom lenses like the 70-200 and 100-400 in the bag, lens cap attached. The way this is done is pretty ingenious, using a single zipper to unfold or collapse the length of the tube. The 100-400 is my largest lens and so the best candidate for demonstration:

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4532.jpg
The Lens Changer 75 and the 100-400, as small as they get. No problem fitting the 100-400 into the LC75 at this stage.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4533.jpg
Hood un-reversed on the 100-400, LC75 extended using the pop-down feature. Still plenty of room to fit the lens and hood inside.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4534.jpg
The 100-400 fully extended to 400mm, with hood. With this setup, the lens will protrude above the edge of the LC75. Still, this may not be the likeliest of scenarios.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4535.jpg
Close-up of the Pop-Down zipper, fully opened.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4537.jpg
Close-up of the Pop-Down zipper, closing.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4538.jpg
Close-up of the Pop-Down zipper. Completing the length of the zipper around the edge will fully retract the base of the bag, leaving it a shorter bag.

Rain covers
http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4530.jpg
Like all ThinkTank bag-products, the Lens Changers feature rain-covers. On the Lens Changers, the rain-covers are stored inside at the bottom of the bag when not in use, and are secured from being separated from the bag by a blue strap with velcro fastening loop at the end.

[xenomorphic]

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4531.jpg
All rain-covers are fastened to a dedicated hoop under the bungee-shutter cover-flap. As shown here, all modular components feature a double netting front-pocket sewn onto the outside of the bag, for lens-caps and similar items. Here shown with a Pee Wee Pixel Pocket Rocket (not included).

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4540.jpg
Rain-covers fit snugly over the Lens Changers

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4541.jpg
The inside or backside of the Lens Changers show hoe the rain-covers come all the way around the body of the bags, leaving just the area which is fastened to the Pro Speed Belt.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4544.jpg
The Lens Changer 75 Pop-Down has a special rain-cover that allows it to fit snugly either on a collapsed or expanded LC 75. Tightening the inner bungee-cord around the base and tucking away the remaining extension gives a snug fit on a collapsed LC 75.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4545.jpg
Loosening the inner bungee and tightening the outer one makes for a snug fit on the extended LC 75.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4546.jpg
Rain-cover fitted on the extended Lens Changer 75 Pop-Down




The really interesting part: Putting it all together

Perhaps the hardest thing to make any conclusions about when considering a belt system is simply how it's going to feel to wear it. You don't really know until you've tried. Related to this are also questions of how it's going to be to work out of, and what order the components should be placed on the belt in order to maximize gear accessibility and comfort. Having a bunch of components to move around on a belt offers a lot more variables and makes it harder to picture yourself using it than when considering, say, the use of a single bag. The ThinkTank site doesn't really give you a good idea about this, so in an effort to make this easier for those of you considering a belt-system, I have dedicated a large section of this review to showing the belt worn in an almost embarrassing number of poses. It's a shame I didn't have a more appealing model, but then, if you're a fairly average sized photography nut, this is more or less what you're going to look like. In fact, no matter what size you are, I suspect this belt will ensure you look like either a photography nut or a professional - depending on the viewer.

So, In what order does one place the components on the belt?

First, there is a slight caveat here when it comes to the belt-size: As stated on the ThinkTank site, before buying it really is important to measure your waist outside the typical clothing you wear while shooting. This is because the belts vary quite a lot in length and the sizes don't overlap much even when you take adjustability into account. I had absolutely no chance trying to fit a medium sized belt on in the store, and neither did the shop assistant - who is a fair bit slimmer than me. Size large works just great (I'm roughly 39,5 inches / 101 cm when measured on the outside of my jeans with belt). Extra Large is way too big for me, and the difference in length between the belt sizes almost certainly means that you gain or lose the space to attach one modular component for each step up or down the size scale. The size large belt comfortably fits the Modular component in the Modular set, with room for about 2 extra components if you were to fill the belt completely. A size small belt would probably be crammed by the components in the Modular set.

Your preference when it comes to how you want to order your components will probably be different from mine, but here is my chosen order and reasoning behind it:

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4560.jpg
From left side front, around the back to right side front (as seen when worn) I fitted the Large Lens Drop-In, Lens Changer 35, Lightning Fast, Lens Changer 75 Pop-Down, Lens Changer 50 and the Speed Changer. This means that when the belt is worn, the Speed Changer can be slid over the belt-buckle and positioned centre front, with the Large Lens Drop-in slightly to the left. The Large Lens Drop-In will be used for every lens-change, and so is given a very accessible position. The Speed Changer contains small items and multiple, small pockets which would be hard to reach if placed too far away from the front. Also, the Speed Changer and Large Lens Drop-in are likely to be the shallowest components, and therefore least likely to get in your way of your thighs when kneeling or crouching down. Following on this logic, the deepest or least frequently used components are positioned at the centre of the belt, which translates to a position at the small of your back: The Lens Changer 75 Pop-Down (deepest) and the Lightning Fast (the flash is probably the least frequently interchanged).

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4561.jpg
The belt loaded with gear (clockwise from lower left): Speed Changer with Pee Wee Pixel Pocket Rocket, Rocket Blower, microfibre cloth, 4-5 various filters, extra batteries, Expodisc, and other stuff, Lens Changer 50 with 16-35 2.8L II, Lens Changer 75 Pop-Down with 100-400 f4.5-5.6L, Lightning Fast with 580 EX II, Lens Changer 35 with 24-70 f2.8L and Empty Large Lens Drop-In.

[xenomorphic]

I deliberately chose not to lock any of the modules in place. The following images demonstrate how this allows you to move everything around as needed:

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4563.jpg
2 components at the front (Speed Changer + Large Lens Drop-in)...

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4566.jpg
...and 4 components at the back

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4569.jpg
Lens Changer 50 moved to front (3 at front, 3 at back)

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4570.jpg
4 components at front (Lens Changer 50, Speed Changer, Large Lens Drop-In, Lens Changer 35)...

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4571.jpg
...and 2 at the back (Lightning Fast and Lens Changer 75 Pop-Down). This setup proved to give an ideal distribution of weight, balancing weight on 3 sides of the body.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4573.jpg
Retrieving a lens - the working height of the bags in relation to your arms when the belt is worn is excellent.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4575.jpg
Getting at items in the Speed Changer

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4579.jpg
Getting the 100-400 from of the LC 75 Pop-Down: Reach back...

[xenomorphic]

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4580.jpg
...and easily slide the bag forwards.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4581.jpg
Undo the bungee and grab the lens

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4582.jpg
The lens easily pulls out...

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4583.jpg
...and can either be fixed onto the camera, or placed into the Large Lens Drop-In so it is even more accessible for a quick lens-change than when in the Lens Changer.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4584.jpg

Crouching with the Pro Speed Belt
FInally, the last thing I was concerned about when buying the belt-system was how it was going to be when crouching down with the fully loaded belt on. This, I am pleased to say, poses no problems whatsoever the way the components are fitted on my belt. The components are still accessible, and you don't end up getting a length of lens rammed into you gut or chest either. Another good thing is your gear hangs clear of the ground at your back while crouching down.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4606.jpg
Shooting with one knee on the ground. Large Lens Drop-in still keeps the "dropped-in" 100-400 safe, and the belt lies comfortably over raised leg

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4607.jpg
Side view: One knee on the ground.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4608.jpg
Other side view: One knee on the ground. Both previous pictures show the belt in a 2-front, 4-back arrangement, but crouching down works equally well with the 4 units at the front and 2 at back.

[xenomorphic]

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4609.jpg
Side view: Hunkering down with 2 units at front.

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/JamesBjerkholt_20090531_4610.jpg
Front view: Hunkering down with 2 units at front. No problems.

Quality, durability and usefulness
I own several other ThinkTank products, ranging from the Airport International roller to the Pee Wee Pixel Rocket memory-card wallet. The build quality of all these products is simply outstanding. They are extremely well manufactured, solid, rugged, and well thought-out. All products feature excellent materials and attention to detail that is seriously gratifying. Build quality in my opinion does not get any better than this, and the Pro Speed Belt and Modular components are no exception to this. Really excellent quality gear.




The moment of truth: Using it in the field

Having bought the products, opened the box, taken a load of pictures, fitted the belt, fitted the components onto the belt, loaded the components with gear and taken more photos wearing the belt, two really important questions remain:

Any piece of carrying-gear can feel great at first, yet turn into a nightmare once it has been on your back for an hour or two. With this in mind, how comfortable is the loaded Pro Speed belt and Modulars in the long run?

You don't really know how you're going to find working out of a carrying solution until you've tried. Does it pass the grade for a dedicated system for facilitating easy shooting?

http://www.infinitesoup.com/externalimages/modular/2009-05-31-0131.jpg
© 2009 F.Paasche

To find out, I took a day trip to the Spring Rudskogen Street-Car Racing event with a friend and stayed for a good 5 hours in pretty hot (for Norway) conditions, shooting, walking and crouching all the while. I was carrying all the gear listed in this review, as well as a 5D body with 70-200 f4 IS attached on a POTN camera-strap. I was extremely pleased with the experience.

The ThinkTank Pro Speed Belt and Modular kit provided seriously and by far the most comfortable and practical, accessible and useful on-location shooting solution I have ever had the great fortune and pleasure of using.

We walked literally for miles around the course, pit-stop and show areas, and I was totally comfortable the whole time. After returning to the car, it didn't feel like I'd been out shooting at all, as there was a complete lack of the usual back, neck and shoulder fatigue. Furthermore, the utter convenience provided by the system afforded me to actually consider and change lenses for various situations that I would probably otherwise have ignored because of the relative inconvenience of my other carrying systems. Quite simply, it is a dream to work out of - I absolutely love this gear!

My single favourite piece of kit has to be the Large Lens Drop-in for the sheer convenience it provides for changing lenses (particularly the large variety). In fact, I intend to bring this along whenever I'm out on a walkabout for its brilliant usefulness - it's going to be better to change lenses out of than any current bag that I own, and you can just fasten it to your regular belt without the need for a dedicated Speed Belt. (If your're using more than one Modular component, though, I'd definitely recommend getting a Speedbelt for their excellent secure fastening, support and comfort.)


Security
Events are a great occasion for using a belt system because the setting usually provides a wide variety of shooting opportunities which may benefit from using different lenses/focal lengths, and the belt system really does provide an excellent solution for changing lenses on the fly. Should one be concerned about security in crowds however?

Others will have more experience than me and I hope they will chime in here, but personally I'd assess the risk of someone lifting a lens from one of your bags without your noticing before it's too late to be pretty slim. You'll instantly feel a shift of weight once a lens is lifted, and getting the Lens Changers opened at top or slashing their base without your noticing should take some doing.

When it comes to avoiding outright mugging/robbery, of course, the belt-systems all have an obvious draw-back in that they are hardly discrete in the first place - they really do scream "Photographer here! Look at all these expensive little pouches!" So assessing the potential risk of becoming an obvious victim where you are going to be shooting is probably a very sensible precaution.




In conclusion: Should you try a belt-system?

Going for a belt-system was a bit of a leap of faith for me - the decision was definitely made easier by firsthand experience of many of ThinkTank's other, excellently built and designed products. For me, it was definitely the right decision, and something I hope to enjoy using for years to come.

The belt-system really works as advertised. It provides you with a dedicated, on-your-feet shooting, lens-change and carrying solution which is supremely comfortable, secure, practical and rugged, leaves your arms and upper body completely free to work your camera and angles, and lets you change lenses "in the comfort of your own personal space" - wherever you are. In this respect it is simply awesome. All this specialized goodness comes at the expense of not having optimal characteristics for travel: It is not very discrete, and it is not the most practical thing to lug around on a commuter train or other forms of public transport. (In fairness, carrying the fully loaded belt slung around your arm/shoulder instead of wearing it for transit doesn't pose much difficulty, but having 6 bags on a belt is bound to be more unwieldy than having it all in a single bag.) An ideal usage pattern suggested by others here at POTN is combining a backpack and belt-system, such as the Street Walker / Pro from ThinkTank. You may then either thread the backpack onto the belt to work as an integrated system, or use a separate backpack to travel, and transfer your gear to the belt-system for shooting. In the latter scenario, some POTN members have recommended using the Skin-system instead of the Modular system because these unpadded bags are very light and thin, and can easily be packed flat in the backpack with the gear when in transit.

Whether you find a belt-system useful to you or not will depend on your shooting style and the situation/location, but events, weddings, sports, urban (in safe areas) and scenic hiking (in combination with a backpack) should all be good candidates. No matter the situation, your back and shoulders will probably thank you. I was -and still am - blown away by the comfort and ease of use provided by this system. Thank you, ThinkTank.

James

[chinoamigo]

awesome review! thanks for taking the time to write one up!

[jhom]

Thanks for your time and effort providing an excellent review of a great system for shooters. After using the Lowepro S&F belt system for awhile, the TT system has been a much more comfortable and user friendly system. The key for me is the design of the system is geared for ready access of my gear. It is not bulky like the Lowepro system.

[82NoMe]

Great review. Thanks for the exceptional effort.

[EveryMilesAMemory]

James, first and foremost, thank you for taking the time and effort to do such an amazing review. I've been on the fence on whether to get this exact set-up or not for some time now.

We travel fulltime and I have never found a shop that carries the system to try out and I'm too scared (Cheap) to order one without ever having seen it fitted or with lenses put it in like all the various poses you posted.

I'll have to say that I think your review just swayed my vote for sure.

If I ever make a product, I'm going to send you one to review. Hats off to probably the best, most in-depth review I've ever read in my life!!

[P51Mstg]

Heck of a review.......

I've been using this system for over a year now....... Only things I can add are.....

Sorry, but I don't have enough (a$$?) hips to hold the belt up when its full and find the Pixel Racing Harness (suspenders) to be very use full in holding it up. Otherwise in 2 steps its around my ankles.

I put pouches on it as I need them, so they change about everytime I use it. The SPEED CHANGER BAG stays on the right and is FULL of stuff, very useful item there.....

Last RAIN COVERS are useless, I leave them at home. Try and put them on everything, especially when its raining.... Totally worthless...... Carry a poncho, raincoat, or a large garbage bag. Personally if it rains, I take everything off and dump the entire harness and camera into a big heavy lawn sized garbage bag, seal it up and carry it all to the car.... Works fine.

Actually I have an idea for what they need for a raincover, which would be awesome, so if you guys are listening, let me know.

Fine review and lots of work there, thanks.....

Mark H

[Familiaphoto]

Great review...one of the most complete I have read in a while.

[Hyun]

FANTASTIC review. Thank you so very much for the detailed photos and commentary. This will come in very handy, as I'm just building up my Think Tank setup.

Thanks again!

[atu]

Very detailed review! Thanks!bw!

[profec291]

Excellent review, I have the same setup with the addition of the Pixel Racing Harness.

[Double Negative]

I just LOVE Think Tank Photo stuff; the quality of materials and workmanship as well as overall design are second to none. I've been eyeing this modular kit as they have them at the local shop. Looks like a great solution for high mobility and configurability.

Thanks for the fantastic review.

[Headshotzx]

Probably the best (definitely one of the better) review of storage gear I've ever read. Thanks a lot! It really helps me because I too am considering the exact same purchase as what was reviewed for my event shooting.

My only issue is the price. SG$250+ (US$175) for a the belt and pouches can buy me lots of other things..

[xenomorphic]

Thanks everyone for responding so kindly to the review. I felt for a moment I'd perhaps gone a bit over the top with the details and/or number of photos, but it seems like all of you are finding it useful - and that's really nice to hear. POTN is a great community that has taught me a hell of a lot, and it's worth every minute trying to give something back for all the value I've had from being a part of it.

Mark H - interesting point about the probable hassle of having to put on 6 separate rain-covers, and also your thoughts on your "lack of anatomy" :lol: I have not tried the rain covers in the field yet, but I have tried putting them on "dry" without problems - and the rain-covers for my other ThinkTank stuff works well. But I see your point if you're caught out in a sudden downpour.

Nothing is perfect, but ThinkTank comes pretty close in my book.

James

[Balliolman]

Superb effort, James, and very informative! Thank you for your efforts. I use the Rotation 360 and have found it very versatile. Like you I think Think Tank products are top notch in build quality and usefulness. :)

[SteveNC]

You spent a lot of time on this and it shows. This is a very high quality review. Thank you very much from all of us.

[CronoDL]

Best photo gear review ever! I've been looking at that system and this helps a lot.

Also, flawless grammar for such a long review! :)

[NicolasRubio]

Good :D

I placed an order on Adorama 2 hours ago for a Pro Speed Belt, a Trim Changer and a Large Lens Drop In... I'll have to wait for the Whip It Out and Chimp Cage to be in stock!

Thanks for the review!

[SteveNC]

I can chime in here as well. I really like my modular system (I have all components except the Lightning Fast and the Speed Changer). One thing I do wish I had, though, is a larger bag to "work" out of. While the various pouches are nice, when you're working with two bodies I've found that I need a better place to stash the one I'm not shooting with. Having two bodies hanging from your person at all times is kind of unwieldy when you have so many pouches also around your waist, and it would be helpful to get one of the Digital Holsters or even the Change Up (http://www.thinktankphoto.com/ttp_product_ChngUp.php) (though the Change Up is designed for a body with no grip attached). One might consider getting one of the larger bags (Change Up (http://www.thinktankphoto.com/ttp_product_ChngUp.php) or even a Speed Racer (http://www.thinktankphoto.com/ttp_product_SpdRcr.php)) in place of the modular BELT, as these belt packs accept modular components on its built-in belt, but also provides a larger bag to work out of.

Change Up
http://www.thinktankphoto.com/images/prod-photo-CU-1.jpg

Speed Racer
http://www.thinktankphoto.com/images/prod-photo-SR2.jpg

[RDKirk]

Put suspenders on that belt and you will like it a lot more.

[Harreh]

James, first and foremost, thank you for taking the time and effort to do such an amazing review. I've been on the fence on whether to get this exact set-up or not for some time now.

We travel fulltime and I have never found a shop that carries the system to try out and I'm too scared (Cheap) to order one without ever having seen it fitted or with lenses put it in like all the various poses you posted.

I'll have to say that I think your review just swayed my vote for sure.

If I ever make a product, I'm going to send you one to review. Hats off to probably the best, most in-depth review I've ever read in my life!!

+1.

Kudos for the brilliant review!

[SteveNC]

Put suspenders on that belt and you will like it a lot more.

= Pixel Racing harness (http://www.thinktankphoto.com/ttp_product_PxlRcngHrnss.php)

http://www.thinktankphoto.com/images/prod-photo-PRH.jpg

http://www.thinktankphoto.com/images/SmpPrd/PxlRcngHrnss2.jpg

[Headshotzx]

= Pixel Racing harness (http://www.thinktankphoto.com/ttp_product_PxlRcngHrnss.php)

http://www.thinktankphoto.com/images/prod-photo-PRH.jpg

http://www.thinktankphoto.com/images/SmpPrd/PxlRcngHrnss2.jpg

Just a question, because I have neither... Does it work good / alright with an R strap or two? We're talking about the CoupleR if it's ever going to be used together.

[sOid]

That's an amazing review! I've got some of the Skin-set components, and I love it.

I've got the pro speed belt too.

But where did you place the buckle? On the front? If I do that, and place some pouches over that, it's very uncomfortable.

I've added some paracord and a carabiner to the front. So if the buckle somehow fails, my gear doesn't fall onto the ground.

[claybuster]

Great review!!! I use the steroid belt and pixel racing harness . And really like the racing harness. So if I'm at an event and eat about five hot dogs a couple of orders of french fries and down a few beers I can undo the belt buckle and have everything hang from my shoulders and get a little relief at my stomach from eating to much:D

[SteveNC]

That's an amazing review! I've got some of the Skin-set components, and I love it.

I've got the pro speed belt too.

But where did you place the buckle? On the front? If I do that, and place some pouches over that, it's very uncomfortable.

I've added some paracord and a carabiner to the front. So if the buckle somehow fails, my gear doesn't fall onto the ground.

The carabiner idea is something I need to try. Personally I place the buckle on the back and it has worked quite well.

[xenomorphic]

Just a question, because I have neither... Does it work good / alright with an R strap or two? We're talking about the CoupleR if it's ever going to be used together.

Judging from the videos over at BlackRapid, I'd say you are right to concerned about that - The R-straps seem to need free passage from hanging to shooting position, and the Modular bags would very likely interfere with this unless you only place Modulars at the front. Perhaps one of the belt-packs suggested by SteveNC would be a better match for the R-straps?

That's an amazing review! I've got some of the Skin-set components, and I love it.

I've got the pro speed belt too.

But where did you place the buckle? On the front? If I do that, and place some pouches over that, it's very uncomfortable.

I've added some paracord and a carabiner to the front. So if the buckle somehow fails, my gear doesn't fall onto the ground.

I placed the buckle at the front, and slid the Speed Changer across it. I didn't experience any discomfort at all, but I was wearing the Pro Speed Belt across the top of my shorts, so perhaps they offered some protection of some sort. I found the Speed belt very, very comfortable to wear.

James

[SteveNC]

Judging from the videos over at BlackRapid, I'd say you are right to concerned about that - The R-straps seem to need free passage from hanging to shooting position, and the Modular bags would very likely interfere with this unless you only place Modulars at the front. Perhaps one of the belt-packs suggested by SteveNC would be a better match for the R-straps?



I placed the buckle at the front, and slid the Speed Changer across it. I didn't experience any discomfort at all, but I was wearing the Pro Speed Belt across the top of my shorts, so perhaps they offered some protection of some sort. I found the Speed belt very, very comfortable to wear.

James

I definitely think if you've got all the components of the modular system attached to the belt you will have problems with the R-strap. I find it hard to manage even a regular strap with all the pouches, which is why I recommended the belt-pack so that you could temporarily stow one of your bodies in the pack, leaving only one body/strap to deal with. However, if you are only using a few of the components, you could position the components along the belt so as not to cause interference with the BlackRapid strap, and that would work fine.

RE: the front versus back buckle. I definitely think that placing it in front with a pouch to slide over the buckle would work well. I did this myself, but found that it interfered with quick removal of the entire belt (one would have to slide the pouch to the side to gain access to the buckle). It's not a big deal but I preferred having the buckle behind me so as to minimize the chance that I'd accidentally un-clip it, as well as to be able to take the buckle off without having to slide any pouches. The real advantage for me was that I wouldn't have to slide the pouch back over the buckle when I put the belt back on. To each his own, that's why this system is so nice!

[Kuma]

Excellent review. Thanks for taking the time to do such a good job. :D

[FLiPMaRC]

:cool: Thank you for your time and work put into this.

[rfreschner]

Great review! I recently purchased the Steroid Speed Belt and Skin Set and had my first opportunity over this past weekend to get out and try it. I also have the Pixel Racing Harness, but found that I really didn't need it. Perhaps when I start carrying the 70-200 and 100-400 at the same time.

What a pleasant experience after using a backpack! And, the TT equipment is so well made to boot! Thanks for giving me some more ideas on how to configure and use the system!

[Mike R]

Great review. My only complaint with the system is the belt sizes, I need the XL for cold weather sooting and the L size when shooting in warm weather with less clothing on. And if the belt is not snug, I find that it tend to slide down when walking.

[medic583]

James... just wanted to say thank you for an excellent review. I've seen these used by a few, wondered how they worked... and now.. I know :)

Great job on the write up!

[sOid]

Great review. My only complaint with the system is the belt sizes, I need the XL for cold weather sooting and the L size when shooting in warm weather with less clothing on. And if the belt is not snug, I find that it tend to slide down when walking.

I agree with you on that. Although my belt IS snug, just pull it more taut.

[asysin2leads]

Absolutely fantastic review. I have read other reviews, but yours takes the cake. I have gone back and forth for months about getting the TT system. I will most likely get the suspender system so I can leave the belt unbuckled when I want. It's an old habit from my army and firefighting days. I never buckled the waist belt. Thanks again for the review.

[Headshotzx]

I purchased think tank photo's steroid speed belt instead of the pro speed belt, bought the LC25 and whip it out, as well as a lightning fast pouch. Put it through its paces for a shoot during a mega-church service, and it really served me well. Lens changes were fast, I didn't feel encumbered even with the 70-200, and it was really really comfortable. I did, however, turn the belt 180 degrees so the buckle is at the back, so that I could have easier access to the modular rail.

Thanks for the review again! It really helped (:

Cheers,
Zexun

[Ephemeral]

This has probably been one of the best reviews I've seen on POTN. Thanks!

[badgerW]

Great review. I currently have a TT Digital Holster 20 that I carry when I just want to take my 5D + 24-105 around. I have a couple of Crumpler shoulder bags that I currently use when I want to carry more gear, but it is definitely a problem to carry them for long periods due to the weight on one shoulder. If I get more into event photography I will definitely get the TT modular system based on your review. It looks awesome, and I can attach the Digital Holster that I already own!

Thanks for the very informational review!

[Jim G]

Fantastic review... I've had many questions about belt systems over time and this answers pretty much all of them. Excellent photos all 'round too.

[Scottes]

Excellent review. Thanks for the time and effort - and the help, because I've been thinking about getting a belt system.

[NYPhotog]

I have been using the TT belt system for a few years and slightly prefer it to the LP system. However, I use the Steroid Speed belt, instead of the Pro Sped belt, as I find it to be more comfortable when carrying several components on the belt.

[GaryR]

Thanks for the excellent review and photos. I'm considering the Think Tank Modular Set and your review will be a big help. I'm sure that others who looked for information like this before making the purchase wish that such information had been available previously.

[Bob F]

Great review, I have used my system for a couple months and had to add a harness to keep it around my waist. Can get heavy as you load up for the day. Thanks again for the information

[gjman]

The modular system seems like a great way to carry stuff while you are on site/field. But how do you transport the modular system itself ? You still need a bag or some sort.

[NicolasRubio]

Mine arrived today (Pro Speed Belt, Large Lens Drop-In and Trim Changer). I absolutely love the system! Whip It Out, Lighting Fast and Chimp Cage still have to arrive.

I should've got the Speed Changer instead of the Trim Changer to put the CPL on the outside pocket... but I'll figure something out!

[dreamchaser58]

EXCELLENT QUESTION........... How do you transport the system? I got simple dufflebag and put it all in there, makes it easy to keep from getting all tangled up and you can put the extra pouches in it.

Mark H

[Headshotzx]

EXCELLENT QUESTION........... How do you transport the system? I got simple dufflebag and put it all in there, makes it easy to keep from getting all tangled up and you can put the extra pouches in it.

Mark H

I store:
70-200 without hood in whip it out
17-40L + 17-55's hood reversed in LC25
580EXII in lightning fast with padding OR 580EXII + CP-E3 without padding
70-200 hood around a lowepro water bottle bag
+ a gripped camera (400D in my case) + R strap
+ sweater
in a Think Tank Photo Streetwalker Harddrive with my steroid speed belt connected the bag dedicated belt area (buckles lengthened to allow me to wear the belt without it being too tight)

Works pretty well.

If I go for an photoshoot where I know I can't put down my bags, I just wear the belt with everything on it, plus one camera and lens (with R strap) on my shoulder.

[jacobsen1]

The modular system seems like a great way to carry stuff while you are on site/field. But how do you transport the modular system itself ? You still need a bag or some sort.

Yeah, do you just put the belt in the car loaded, or do you load it up out of another bag on site?

Also, for all you belt guys, have you tried vests? I'm looking at both right now and I'm having a hard time deciding. I actually OWN this belt (the nicer TT belt) and the lens bag/case they make for the 70-200 2.8 as well as a lowepro lens bag. My issue is it just feels weird having all my kit on my waist. Not uncomfortable, just weird... It also draws a lot of attention.

Right now I'm using the boda, and I like it's concept/idea, but it wears down your shoulder after a while. I have it's belt strap, but again, it just feels weird?

ugh, nothing's ever easy with carrying gear, that's for sure. :lol:

thanks for any insight on belts-vs-vests though, and also how you guys carry your kit before you use it.

[AxxisPhoto]

Fanstastic review and thanks for all the hard work that went into it! This review is really making me think about using a belt instead of a bag. Thanks.

[rfreschner]

Also, for all you belt guys, have you tried vests?

Yes, I've used a vest and never liked it. It looks better than walking around looking like you have a life preserver around your waist, but I like the comfort and convenience of the belt system much better.

[rfreschner]

Yeah, do you just put the belt in the car loaded, or do you load it up out of another bag on site?

Missed this. I put the belt in the car loaded most times.

[jacobsen1]

Yes, I've used a vest and never liked it. It looks better than walking around looking like you have a life preserver around your waist, but I like the comfort and convenience of the belt system much better.

yeah, I'm kinda thinking this:
http://www.bhphotovideo.com/images/images345x345/153225.jpg
http://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/153225-REG/Lowepro_LP19515_BOE_Vest_Harness.html

might work better for me? I know it's the same thing at TT's suspenders, but it looks more like a vest which I like? I don't like just the belt, I doubt I'd like just the vest, the lowe pro (with my TT belt) seems like it might be the perfect hybrid?

[gjman]

If I am reading the specs correctly the difference between the modular and the skin systems is that the skin are not padded.

Skin
This non-padded, lightweight, modular system allows you to organize your gear on all Think Tank belts, and work quietly with the Silencer Flap! Our 5 piece system is designed for a SLR user with 2 to 4 lenses and a flash.

Modular Set
Padded, easily accessible, Modular set allows you to organize your gear on all Think Tank belts.

So it appears to be possible to store, transport and deploy the modular cases on site. A duffel bag may not offer much protection if you want to store and transport this gear (plus I like to pack in my undies and toothbrush too....see my other thread)

What would be ideal is some sort of protective OUTER case (like a Pelican 1510-shell...or a stripped down TTP Airport Addict V2.0 shell only) and you just drop in your gear in the padded modular case and the belt and others stuff like a laptop and undies...and toothbrush. You reach your destination, take out ONLY want you need.

The only problem with my grand plan: cost.

The TTP system for storage, transport will include a holster.

Sterioid Speed Belt $47.50
Modular Set $169.00
Pixel Racing Harness $35.00
Digital Holster 40 $69.00

Total $320.50

Plus a Pelican 1510-$162 (assuming all this fits in there with room to spare for toothbrush/undies and laptop)

[adam*]

Absolutely awesome review. I'm still deciding between this and the UD60 but that's down to it not looking like a camera bag and laptop access. Only problem then is accessibility / useability on the fly for PJ shooting. Thanks anyway!

[rfreschner]

I'm still deciding between this and the UD60

Get em both (I did), it's only money!! ;)

[adam*]

Not a chance I can afford both! It's a right pain trying to find the perfect PJ camera bag. Space for a laptop is essential these days.

[jacobsen1]

Get em both (I did), it's only money!! ;)

god damn you're not helpiiiiiing!!!! :lol:

[zagiace]

its been said many times already, thanks for the stellar review. I wish their site was as thorough.

[rfreschner]

god damn you're not helpiiiiiing!!!! :lol:

Whaddda ya mean!! I'm helping Think Tank, aren't I?? ;)

I got the Skin Set in anticipation of someday purchasing the Airport Security so I can just stuff them into it in their cases and just attach to the belt once I get to my destination. I can't wait to hear what my wife will say about that one! :p

[rfreschner]

It's a right pain trying to find the perfect PJ camera bag.

You can't find it because it doesn't exist!

[NicolasRubio]

Not a chance I can afford both! It's a right pain trying to find the perfect PJ camera bag. Space for a laptop is essential these days.

Such bag does not exist, perfection is an asymptote.

The day ThinkTankPhoto solves the buclke issue and make pouches able to slide even over the buckles, this system will be even nearer to perfection!

[NYPhotog]

Also, for all you belt guys, have you tried vests? I'm looking at both right now and I'm having a hard time deciding.


I have both the TT belt system and a couple of vests. I use the Steroid Speed Belt with the Pixel Racing Harness when I wear the TT belt. Sometimes, however, I like to wear a vest. The best vests, IMO, are from The Vested Interest http://www.vestedinterest.com/ I have a slightly customized Khumbu model, in which I can actually carry as much or more than I can on the belt. Sometimes a vest is easier to travel with, as I can load it up and just walk onto the plane, wearing my gear. That also allows me to take a carry-on bag as well.

[Headshotzx]

Btw, I heard from a local store (sole distributor) that there is apparently going to be an update to the pixel racing harness. Any one can confirm this? No local stocks till september 2009.

[jhom]

If I am reading the specs correctly the difference between the modular and the skin systems is that the skin are not padded.



So it appears to be possible to store, transport and deploy the modular cases on site. A duffel bag may not offer much protection if you want to store and transport this gear (plus I like to pack in my undies and toothbrush too....see my other thread)

What would be ideal is some sort of protective OUTER case (like a Pelican 1510-shell...or a stripped down TTP Airport Addict V2.0 shell only) and you just drop in your gear in the padded modular case and the belt and others stuff like a laptop and undies...and toothbrush. You reach your destination, take out ONLY want you need.

The only problem with my grand plan: cost.

The TTP system for storage, transport will include a holster.

Sterioid Speed Belt $47.50
Modular Set $169.00
Pixel Racing Harness $35.00
Digital Holster 40 $69.00

Total $320.50

Plus a Pelican 1510-$162 (assuming all this fits in there with room to spare for toothbrush/undies and laptop)

My solution has been a TT Airport Security + TT modular or TTAS with any of the other TT bags. I just returned from a trip to AZ with my TTAS and a TT ChangeUp. Flexibility, convenience and good protection. Priceless.

[gjman]

My solution has been a TT Airport Security + TT modular ........ Flexibility, convenience and good protection. Priceless.

If its possible can we see pics of the Modular System INSIDE the TT Airport Security with the gear that you carry.

[NYPhotog]

Btw, I heard from a local store (sole distributor) that there is apparently going to be an update to the pixel racing harness. Any one can confirm this? No local stocks till september 2009.

I spoke directly to TT and was told that the Pixel Racing Harness is NOT going to be updated.

[Sauk]

So what was the final price for this investment?

[GaryR]

FWIW. I just bought the modular set. Tried it out and it works great. I transport my gear in Glass Taxis then load whatever I need onto the belt. Very pleased with this system.

[xenomorphic]

The modular system seems like a great way to carry stuff while you are on site/field. But how do you transport the modular system itself ? You still need a bag or some sort.

I have had three scenarios for carrying the modular system before shooting, two of them similar to what others have suggested:
If necessary to commute or otherwise move through areas were a belt would be too conspicuous: Belt system inside a bag, or Urban Disguise with gear in and belt system in separate bag.
If packing a lot of gear for a days shooting and going by car: Gear in bag, only pack necessary gear into belt system on location.
Finally - the most pleasing of all - pack what you need into the belt system, snap the belt closed and then hitch it onto your shoulder as if you were going to wear it diagonally across your chest - only don't put your head through the hoop, just wear it like a shoulder bag on one side. The weight of the components with lenses makes the belt "lean into" your shoulder/torso, and I find it surprisingly comfortable to carry like this when not shooting. Sure, I look like a nut ;) but this is how I transport it most of the time.

Also, for all you belt guys, have you tried vests? I'm looking at both right now and I'm having a hard time deciding. I actually OWN this belt (the nicer TT belt) and the lens bag/case they make for the 70-200 2.8 as well as a lowepro lens bag. My issue is it just feels weird having all my kit on my waist. Not uncomfortable, just weird... It also draws a lot of attention.

I have used the POTN Safari Vest. While it is a great vest, I find it best for smaller items and maybe a single extra lens because it drags down on my shoulders and constrains movement too much when really loaded up when compared to the belt system. However - and this is a BIG plus for vests which I am grateful to someone here on POTN for pointing out a while back - vests are the ultimate way to beat hand-luggage weight-restrictions on flights: Pack one full of lenses, batteries, and all manner of heavy stuff, and either wear it or sling it across your arm as a jacket, and it sure doesn't count as hand luggage. Totally sweet :)

Absolutely awesome review. I'm still deciding between this and the UD60 but that's down to it not looking like a camera bag and laptop access. Only problem then is accessibility / useability on the fly for PJ shooting. Thanks anyway!

Thanks - glad you liked it. :) I'd say they are two very different carrying solutions that excel at fairly different things - UD60 for transportation and discretion, belt-system for brilliant, hands-and-shoulders-free shooting and comfort on location. UD60 is good to shoot out of, but the belt system is that much better at this one thing. Check out the UD60 review in my sig if you haven't already.

Get em both (I did), it's only money!! ;)

Oh, to have your cake and eat it too - it's the best solution for sure! :)

So what was the final price for this investment?

About NOK 2250,- (Norwegian Kroner), that is about Euro 255,- or USD 360,-
The price varies a lot depending on where you are in the world - and the US seems like the best place to be by far in this respect, were the same kit retails for around $200 (www.adorama.com)

James

[cubestwin]

Think Tank should pay you a commission because you just sold another order for them from this thread of yours! Great Review!!!

[fungry]

Think Tank should pay you a commission because you just sold another order for them from this thread of yours! Great Review!!!
Haha! It is such a great review.
I'm still waiting for them to be officially sold in Australia grrrr.

[johnaengus]

Yes, they should pay you. I just ordered a system. Manufacturer sites are so bad as far as pictures and descriptions and the nearest camera store that carries anything is at least 500 miles away from here. Thanks for the review!!!!

[EveryMilesAMemory]

I just ordered the ThinkTank Modular System after drooling over it for so long. I know I'll never be able to review it as good as you have, but once I get it and use it for a few days/weeks, I'll post up a review of what I think

[zildjansg]

just come across with this i wonder how much does the modular set cost?thanks

[hfgarris]

just come across with this i wonder how much does the modular set cost?thanks

http://www.thinktankphoto.com/products/modular-set-component.aspx

$169

[mghong]

James , 1 thumb up for you on this great reviews , but personally when travel i don't really like to put my gear outside .. because i scare of people will pick it "out" from me...:)

Just to ask , are you a reviewer for some product ?

[asysin2leads]

James , 1 thumb up for you on this great reviews , but personally when travel i don't really like to put my gear outside .. because i scare of people will pick it "out" from me...:)

Just to ask , are you a reviewer for some product ?

I have never thought about this. The pouches are zippered shut and secured very well to the belt. I put the 70-200 2.8 in the Whip It Out (http://www.thinktankphoto.com/products/whip-it-out-lens-case.aspx) that I have. It's in there rather securely. I would have no worries about someone trying to snag my gear.

[jaeapla]

Excellent review -- I, too, love the ThinkTank products!

[Runt808]

Awesome review. Thanks for taking the time and for putting in the effort.

For those who may have compared the two, which would be the better belt? The Pro or the Steroid.

I don't think I would be carrying too many pouches on the belt, it is more to complement my Coton Carrier. I am what some may call a "fluffy" guy :oops: so was wondering if my gut would interfere with the wider profile of the Steroid belt. :D

[NicolasRubio]

Awesome review. Thanks for taking the time and for putting in the effort.

For those who may have compared the two, which would be the better belt? The Pro or the Steroid.

I don't think I would be carrying too many pouches on the belt, it is more to complement my Coton Carrier. I am what some may call a "fluffy" guy :oops: so was wondering if my gut would interfere with the wider profile of the Steroid belt. :D

IMHO, the Pro Speed Belt is too wide to be used with the CC.

I have both belts and I think they compliment each other.

[Runt808]

IMHO, the Pro Speed Belt is too wide to be used with the CC.

I have both belts and I think they compliment each other.

Thanks for the response Nicolas. Did you mean to say the Pro Speed Belt or did you mean to say the Steroid Speed Belt?

[NicolasRubio]

Thanks for the response Nicolas. Did you mean to say the Pro Speed Belt or did you mean to say the Steroid Speed Belt?

I use the Steroid Speed Belt with my CC.

[Headshotzx]

I use the Steroid Speed Belt with my CC.

As do I:

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2715/4342916499_c7a4e63cf4_o.jpg

http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3480/3881709498_7dd27f3fe9.jpg

[Vascilli]

I really wish CPS didn't close up shop here, I wouldn't look much different than your first shot.

[Headshotzx]

I really wish CPS didn't close up shop here, I wouldn't look much different than your first shot.

Haha, I'm no CPS user nor am i affiliated to any CPS user. Canon loaned me the 1D4 + 200 f/2L IS for a review / chance to test via a company that I write for... that was 2 months back, and I still haven't submitted my review. I'm sooo trustworthy :/

Back on topic, I find that the skin belt would be a good idea for when I'm shooting sports with a monopod. It can hold my water bottle, and once the game's done, I can pop the monopod back into the monopod bag to shoot wide shots of the players.

[gcukurova]

THINK TANK has a great built quality but I think the belt system is another way of getting your money.....

*Makes you look like a suicide bomber :)
*what's wrong with putting your stuff in a bag?

Some say, well, all you need is around your waist, yes, but how comfortable could that be?
Walk like a buoy :-))

[rfreschner]

Some say, well, all you need is around your waist, yes, but how comfortable could that be?

I've used mine on several occasions hiking for hours through the woods and it's much more comfortable than having all the weight in my backpack. Getting into a New York city taxi with it on was a different story altogether! :D

[jeanninemarie]

This is an amazing review. Thank you for taking the time to do it....with lots of photos to keep my attention long enough to know I'm making the right purchase.

[Savas K]

Thank you for the wonderful review. It's a labor of love.

[G-FOTO]

Hello James,

thanks a lot for this complete review!

You supported my decision to buy the modular system.
And now I know exactly what I need - thanks to your detailed pictures and explanations.

I will not buy the whole modular set. The Lens-Drop-in and the 75 pop-up will be enough.

Again - THANKS A LOT!!!

[MDJAK]

Great review, I have used my system for a couple months and had to add a harness to keep it around my waist. Can get heavy as you load up for the day. Thanks again for the information


First, fantastically detailed review with excellent pictures.

I agree with the above. I've had belt systems and maybe it's just me, but they do get heavy and tire my hips through the day.

[rfreschner]

but they do get heavy and tire my hips through the day.

What hips? You're too skinny - you've got no hips!

[jonneymendoza]

anyone tried this approach going to a plane? do they "weigh" ur belt?

[Canonised]

I was trawling the net for user reviews and just read the whole report. OUTSTANDING review. I wish all reviews were as detailed and comprehensive.

I must say I was looking at the Skin Set but the Modular Set seems attractive now!

Just wish to add, I am also considering the Belly Dancer harness to suspend the belt above my hip and to take some weight off the hip if I am required to wear the belt for long periods. It allows for the packs to be worn in front.

ALSO instead of the Pro Speed belt, I bought the Vanguard ICS Belt which can be used with or without the padding. Much like having the Pro Speed and Skin Belt as one. Still able to wear the Skin and Modular sets.

Thanks again!

[hfgarris]

I was trawling the net for user reviews and just read the whole report. OUTSTANDING review. I wish all reviews were as detailed and comprehensive.

I must say I was looking at the Skin Set but the Modular Set seems attractive now!

Just wish to add, I am also considering the Belly Dancer harness to suspend the belt above my hip and to take some weight off the hip if I am required to wear the belt for long periods. It allows for the packs to be worn in front.

ALSO instead of the Pro Speed belt, I bought the Vanguard ICS Belt which can be used with or without the padding. Much like having the Pro Speed and Skin Belt as one. Still able to wear the Skin and Modular sets.

Thanks again!

Depending on your profile (physical, not background ;) ), you may find a harness to be a necessity to prevent the belt from ending up around your ankles. :D :rolleyes:

The weight of all the gear really pulls down on the belt when you are walking, kneeling, squatting, and bending. I find I have to either wear a shoulder harness, or tighten the belt uncomfortably tight, especially if I am wearing winter clothes (too much gut ... not enough butt).:rolleyes: If you carry your gear only on one side, a simple shoulder strap may work to help support it.

Although I haven't really searched for one, I have thought that a "stretchy" shoulder strap/harness would be desirable to eliminate it pulling against the belt when you stretch your upper torso or lean to one side.

-howard

[Canonised]

Depending on your profile (physical, not background ;) ), you may find a harness to be a necessity to prevent the belt from ending up around your ankles. :D :rolleyes:

The weight of all the gear really pulls down on the belt when you are walking, kneeling, squatting, and bending. I find I have to either wear a shoulder harness, or tighten the belt uncomfortably tight, especially if I am wearing winter clothes (too much gut ... not enough butt).:rolleyes: If you carry your gear only on one side, a simple shoulder strap may work to help support it.

Although I haven't really searched for one, I have thought that a "stretchy" shoulder strap/harness would be desirable to eliminate it pulling against the belt when you stretch your upper torso or lean to one side.

-howard

Unfortunately and embarrassingly being 49 its hard to fight nature and my gut is wider than my hips so it seems I have no choice but to acquire some kind of belt/harness that works for me. Will try different configurations to see what works. But so far, I have not gone the full harness way - just yet. Thanks for the input!