PDA

View Full Version : Canon TC 1.4x test results


Zwiz
16th of May 2005 (Mon), 14:39
Hi,

I got a new TC 1.4x last week. I use it on a 300mm f/4L IS with a Rebel 300D. Main purpose: birds shooting. My goal with the TC was not to get bigger pictures but more details one. With good light condition, this goal is achieved but with average to poor light condition, the lost a 1 f-stop make the AF less reliable. So what you gain in zoom, you "may" lose it in sharpness.

Those examples show what the TC can do in average light condition. Take note that this specific picture is an easy task for the AF.

All pictures are cropped to get pixel details. No other mods in PS except resizing.

First example; I resized down the TC picture to match the size on the non-TC picture

Without TC
http://img224.echo.cx/img224/8387/xxxbcorg1007ud.jpg

With TC (resize to match picture above)
http://img224.echo.cx/img224/9725/xxxbctc0718rk.jpg


Second example: I resize up the non-TC picture to match the size of the TC picture.

Without TC
http://img224.echo.cx/img224/6167/xxxbc0org1408oh.jpg

With TC
http://img224.echo.cx/img224/7787/xxxbc0tc1000ys.jpg

Another shot taken with the TC in good light condition
http://img224.echo.cx/img224/9959/xxxbc1tc1008aq.jpg

There is one other advantage with the TC. Your subject is bigger, you get less background so the camera do a better job adjusting levels and colors balancing according to the subject. Yes, you can always adjust back the colors but a bad exposition will be difficult to correct.

pierrot
16th of May 2005 (Mon), 15:32
From what I see, the pics taken with the TC seem sharper than the ones without? :shock:

Not only are there more detail, but they definitely look sharper. Are they really? No post-processing?

Zwiz
16th of May 2005 (Mon), 15:36
Hi Pierrot,

I think the details make the picture sharper. Those 2 attributes are linked.
There is no post-processing involved in those tests.

Medic1
16th of May 2005 (Mon), 16:06
Interesting.......I was thinking that my 70-200 f4L was quite noticably softer with the TC

CyberDyneSystems
16th of May 2005 (Mon), 16:11
TC's allways work better with Primes than zooms.. but these look really good :)