Birds & vignetting

[PBeeee]

Trying some vignetting in LR for these bird shots. Did I overdo it?

[AmandaMarie]

I think it's great.

[zwright]

i like it but i think for the vignette to look really good you should bring the image up a 1/4 stop and make the vigentte a little harder, like not as feathered i could post an edit of your image with what i am thinking of doing if that would be ok with you?

[robertn]

Needs more than 1/4 stop upped in exposure, but are too underexposed for me.
Second photo could use heavier vignetting.

[ShutteringFocus]

1st photo too heavy in my opinion. It looks like some of it is cutting in on the bird.

[PBeeee]

1st photo too heavy in my opinion. It looks like some of it is cutting in on the bird.

I think you're right about that.

As far as underexposed I think you're just seeing how LR tends to downsize for the web.

I have not played much with vignetting, it always seems too obvious to me but I kind of liked the effect I got on the first shot, the anhinga spreading his wings. The halo of light around the bird. But I do think it is on him too much.

Lots of birds shots to play with for a bit. Thanks for the comments.

[Kpablo]

I don't think you over did it, it looks nice.

[Flo]

Needs more than 1/4 stop upped in exposure, but are too underexposed for me.
Second photo could use heavier vignetting.

Agree.:)