PDA

View Full Version : which edit?

FamilyJules
28th of December 2009 (Mon), 20:56
A typical ring shot from a recent wedding... Which edit do you prefer?

1. color
http://jwilsonphotography.smugmug.com/Weddings/Janell-and-Rob-92609/IMG625/747564588_niqQV-L.jpg

2. Vintage inspired
http://jwilsonphotography.smugmug.com/Weddings/Janell-and-Rob-92609/IMG626/747564716_eLV7Z-L.jpg
mule
28th of December 2009 (Mon), 21:01
I love both, but I am more drawn to #1, love the concept of #2 but the first is my choice.
KayakPhotos
28th of December 2009 (Mon), 21:31
I like the look of #2 myself.
tnicol
28th of December 2009 (Mon), 23:11
No. 1 for me too.
mjadse
28th of December 2009 (Mon), 23:59
Number 1 for me. I like the sparkle and clean look much better.
raiyo
29th of December 2009 (Tue), 00:01
#1 looks better to me
Ichiban
29th of December 2009 (Tue), 03:20
#2 for me.
sctbiggs
29th of December 2009 (Tue), 06:33
1. I like the seventies processing... but, as for ring shots, i like diamonds to look just as they do.
HQP
29th of December 2009 (Tue), 09:28
#1 for me
Rockney
29th of December 2009 (Tue), 09:34
# 1 for me, nice and clean...
Bladerunner99
29th of December 2009 (Tue), 19:48
#1, much sharper look!
AircoolerKirk
29th of December 2009 (Tue), 21:32
Number one, and well done.
Creepy Crawler
30th of December 2009 (Wed), 08:29
I think #1 also but both very nice
FamilyJules
30th of December 2009 (Wed), 13:41
Thanks for the input and kind words! :D
bakerbranded
30th of December 2009 (Wed), 13:51
#2 love it! :)
sf1
30th of December 2009 (Wed), 19:16
#1, but edit out the red, I tend to be drawn towards it first.
LeftSide
3rd of January 2010 (Sun), 17:27
#1 for me!
petedam
4th of January 2010 (Mon), 12:59
#1 it is!
FamilyJules
4th of January 2010 (Mon), 15:04
Thank you so much for the input :) It's much appreciated
collierportraits
4th of January 2010 (Mon), 15:07
Which does the client like? (Second one for me. It seems pretty split...)
FamilyJules
4th of January 2010 (Mon), 15:44
Which does the client like? (Second one for me. It seems pretty split...)
Not sure.... I just gave her both so that she can choose :)
JoJo2fast
5th of January 2010 (Tue), 12:48
#2 for me