Need your opinion - Tobacco gradient

[Drowned]

I've always been interested in this effect... I think It gives the picture a nice effect. What do you think? Does it look better with the colored gradient or without it? BTW, I did the effect with photoshop... :p

====================================

Neutral:
http://www.velocidad-maxima.com/photos/albums/Rust/vent1-1024.jpg

Tobacco:
http://www.velocidad-maxima.com/photos/albums/Rust/vent2-1024.jpg

Here's a test with a blueish gradient too...
http://www.velocidad-maxima.com/photos/albums/Rust/vent3-1024.jpg

[ImperialRed]

I like both of the gradient shots...but I prefer the blue one!

[Michaelmjc]

I like the tabacco one, neat picture.