PDA

View Full Version : Two versions of same cat picture


JeffreyO
19th of April 2010 (Mon), 15:07
Can't decide which I like better. See processing details. This is Eddie Fierce.

Eddie is fierce when he plays. Sometimes he even hisses at his toys. You can see he's mad here because the top of his eyes are kind of flat. If he had eyebrows they'd be pointing down. His chin being down helps too.

I finally got to shoot him when he's playing with his beloved mouse. But I had my flash on manual instead of automatic and this was underexposed by about 2-3 stops. I was mad. But shooting RAW rescued the photo.

Since it looked a little noisy even though I did some reduction, I'd thought I'd make the photo look even rougher.

So in Gimp I duplicated the background layer twice. The middle layer is black and white. The top layer is Soft Light mode. By mixing the opacity of the layers you get sort of a desaturated look that I've read is called the "Hollywood look". Of course this is usually used on people. I boosted the black and did some burning around the edges. The process makes his eyes look darker and they match the mouse.

Canon XSi, Canon EF 100mm f/2.8 macro, Canon 430 EX II bounced off ceiling behind and slightly to the right.

2nd picture:
With this one I saturated colors, moved his eyelids down to make him look even madder, oversharpened his eyes and then made them darker and did some dodging and burning. I like how his eyes turned out here. Both at Flickr.

thekid17
19th of April 2010 (Mon), 15:28
i like the first one better

aebrown
19th of April 2010 (Mon), 15:29
first one. the second one is overdone and the eyes don't look believable IMO

GoWolfpack
20th of April 2010 (Tue), 09:07
The eyes from the second one with the coloring of the first.

The eyes are mesmerizing in the second, but the yellow tinge takes away from the rest of it.

Whippeticious
23rd of April 2010 (Fri), 03:43
Yep first for me too. Maybe you could have another go at somewhere in between the 2.

JeffreyO
23rd of April 2010 (Fri), 03:51
I guess maybe the second one was too gimmicky. The first one is the one I did first and really was the idea I was first looking for. Then I did the second one and think it looks really cool but it may be my digital immaturity showing.

I think the second eyes with the first one might not 'match'. They may be too much for the way the rest of the picture is somewhat desaturated (even though it would make them stand out).

I took the second one off of Flickr. I like to just put my best stuff on there and not have a lot of versions of things with a couple of exceptions.

Puppage
23rd of April 2010 (Fri), 14:28
Did you ask HIM which one he liked best?

JeffreyO
23rd of April 2010 (Fri), 15:25
Since he barely knows his own name and can't recognize himself in a mirror I'm not sure he'd have an opinion. Good idea though.