Are you guys saying that you can't choose your all-time favorite magical image?
First I said I couldn't choose one favorite image or one most beautiful image. Now that you throw "magical" into the mix, I'll say the same for magical. In fact, when judging images, I don't look for anything I'd call a magical quality. The concept is irrelevant.
When I was a child, certain sights seemed magical that don't now. Greeting cards with glitter glued to them impressed me; the way they reflected light when moved was really special. Now they're just cards with glitter glued on, still sparkly but not mysterious. What would it take to revive that perception of "magic"? I don't know. Maybe nothing would do it.