Index  •   • New Posts  •   • RTAT  •   • "Best Of"  •   • Gallery  •   • Gear  •   • Reviews
New Posts  •   • RTAT  •   • "Best Of"  •   • Gallery  •   • Gear  •   • Reviews
Register to forums    Log in

 
FORUMS General Gear Talk Flash and Studio Lighting
Thread started 12 Apr 2009 (Sunday) 16:35
PREV/NEXT

6,560 FLASH POPS LATER: The Results of "AA" Rechargeable Battery Tests

 
SYS
THREAD ­ STARTER
Cream of the Crop
SYS's Avatar
8,121 posts

Joined Jul 2004

Gilligan's Island
MORE INFO

int2str wrote in post #7716603external link
Great test!

Was the flash set to manual? If so, what power output?

Because I used the old flash from film photography years that is not compatible with my DSLR camera, I popped the flash by pressing on the pilot button when the flash's capacitor was at full, signified by the red light. See on the first page regarding the comparative difference between the 300EZ and 580EX. By the "Guide Number" 300EZ has weaker output than the 580EX, but I don't have the info as to how much exactly.

Apr 12, 2009 17:43


"Life is short, art is long..."
-Goethe
My Gear & DIYs

LOG IN TO REPLY
sponsored links
(this ad will go away when you log in as registered member)
SYS
THREAD ­ STARTER
Cream of the Crop
SYS's Avatar
8,121 posts

Joined Jul 2004

Gilligan's Island
MORE INFO

unrlmth wrote in post #7716612external link
What did you use to charge them? A higher charge rate will cause them to have a little more "pop" when fully charged and a slower charge rate will cause them to last a little longer?

Also do you have any data on the mah that each of the batteries hold?

See above post #2 for the charger I used and the mAh info...

As for charging rate, I don't like to charge NiHM batteries at any lower than 200mA and any higher than 500mA, and all tested batteries were charged in this manner.

Apr 12, 2009 17:49


"Life is short, art is long..."
-Goethe
My Gear & DIYs

LOG IN TO REPLY
monty28428
Cream of the Crop
monty28428's Avatar
9,764 posts

Joined Jul 2007

Carolina Beach
MORE INFO

Graphs, Pictures, Tables!! (LOL - just kidding)

Very nice set of tests.

Apr 12, 2009 18:05



LOG IN TO REPLY
SYS
THREAD ­ STARTER
Cream of the Crop
SYS's Avatar
8,121 posts

Joined Jul 2004

Gilligan's Island
MORE INFO

monty28428 wrote in post #7716714external link
Graphs, Pictures, Tables!! (LOL - just kidding)

Very nice set of tests.

Thanks, Monty. We actually do have graphs and charts (photos provided already ;) ), but these are very simple kinds that my son created for his Sci Fair. His graphs and charts do not display those detail information to be useful here... :)

Apr 12, 2009 19:02


"Life is short, art is long..."
-Goethe
My Gear & DIYs

LOG IN TO REPLY
tetrode
I am a walking repository of thoroughly useless information
tetrode's Avatar
3,770 posts

Joined Jan 2006

New York
MORE INFO

SYS wrote in post #7716640external link
...I popped the flash by pressing on the pilot button when the flash's capacitor was at full...

So, do you have a thumb like Popeye now?

Thanks for taking the time to report your findings. Very informative and helpful.

Dave F.

Apr 12, 2009 19:10



LOG IN TO REPLY
sponsored links
(this ad will go away when you log in as registered member)
SYS
THREAD ­ STARTER
Cream of the Crop
SYS's Avatar
8,121 posts

Joined Jul 2004

Gilligan's Island
MORE INFO

tetrode wrote in post #7716995external link
So, do you have a thumb like Popeye now?

Thanks for taking the time to report your findings. Very informative and helpful.

Dave F.

Thanks. Fortunately for my thumb, I had a month's period to spread out the repetitive abuse. My son's thumb was employed, as well... :)

Apr 12, 2009 20:30


"Life is short, art is long..."
-Goethe
My Gear & DIYs

LOG IN TO REPLY
phamster
Cream of the Crop
phamster's Avatar
6,315 posts

Joined Apr 2008

Purdue - Go Boilers
MORE INFO

very scientific approach..

lots of data.. and lots of hours..

so what holds true is higher mAh the better the performance..

good work

phamster

Apr 12, 2009 20:42

"Lighting will make or break your photo"
Flickrexternal link
Facebookexternal link
Interview with Mike Panicexternal link

LOG IN TO REPLY
SYS
THREAD ­ STARTER
Cream of the Crop
SYS's Avatar
8,121 posts

Joined Jul 2004

Gilligan's Island
MORE INFO

phamster wrote in post #7717461external link
very scientific approach..

lots of data.. and lots of hours..

so what holds true is higher mAh the better the performance..

good work

phamster

Yes, against my initial skepticism, "higher the 'mAh' the stronger the performance" came through consistently. Even Energizer Rechargeable that I despised performed better than eneloops that I so admired.

eneloops were pleasantly consistent in their "low self-discharge" showing....

I also learned that not all "low self-discharging" claiming batteries are same. I was expecting MAHA Powerex "Imedion," for instance, to be about the same as eneloop, but I'd trust eneloop as the most reliable in this category...

MAHA Powerex 2700mAh, on the other hand, came through really impressively, such that I've now changed my strategy in how I use my rechargeable batteries, that is, I'd use Powerex as the main horse and rely on eneloops more as back up or in situations where I need to use in intermittent situations and applications.

The alkaline was surprising how poorly it performed... I was expecting them to be a bit stronger...

Apr 12, 2009 21:16


"Life is short, art is long..."
-Goethe
My Gear & DIYs

LOG IN TO REPLY
phamster
Cream of the Crop
phamster's Avatar
6,315 posts

Joined Apr 2008

Purdue - Go Boilers
MORE INFO

SYS wrote in post #7717695external link
Yes, against my initial skepticism, "higher the 'mAh' the stronger the performance" came through consistently. Even Energizer Rechargeable that I despised performed better than eneloops that I so admired.

eneloops were pleasantly consistent in their "low self-discharge" showing....

I also learned that not all "low self-discharging" claiming batteries are same. I was expecting MAHA Powerex "Imedion," for instance, to be about the same as eneloop, but I'd trust eneloop as the most reliable in this category...

MAHA Powerex 2700mAh, on the other hand, came through really impressively, such that I've now changed my strategy in how I use my rechargeable batteries, that is, I'd use Powerex as the main horse and rely on eneloops more as back up or in situations where I need to use in intermittent situations and applications.

The alkaline was surprising how poorly it performed... I was expecting them to be a bit stronger...

i work in quality at Subaru.. i am responsible for lots of the over all quality @ subaru for Specs, Regulations, New Model Development and Training for upcoming models in the Subaru line are also my responsibility at Subaru.

so reading your Methodology and applying a well thought out approach to comparing your objects was great.

it is all about making a plan, collecting your data and collating your results to a usable output for others and yourself to read.. (you did awesome)

now for me.. my useage of batteries are pretty much the same as yours..

i have one of those MAHA 8 bay 69 dollar unit.. and lots of 2700 MaH batteries.. so before a wedding job, i always charge up 4 sets of 4 2700'S and also carry 16 back up alkalines in my back pack.. but never have used the alkalines yet..

and i make sure i charge all my batteries up the day before the big job.

thanks for doing this cool research.. i am sure it is going to be made a STICKY !!!

phamster

Apr 12, 2009 21:27

"Lighting will make or break your photo"
Flickrexternal link
Facebookexternal link
Interview with Mike Panicexternal link

LOG IN TO REPLY
SYS
THREAD ­ STARTER
Cream of the Crop
SYS's Avatar
8,121 posts

Joined Jul 2004

Gilligan's Island
MORE INFO

Thanks, phamster, for your kind words. :D

Apr 12, 2009 21:38


"Life is short, art is long..."
-Goethe
My Gear & DIYs

LOG IN TO REPLY
jcw122
Goldmember
jcw122's Avatar
1,940 posts

Joined Jul 2006

West Chester, PA
MORE INFO

Yeah FORGET YOU ENELOOP YOUR OVER PRICED! Wooooo!

Overpriced, highly advertised, over hyped electronics = BIG FAIL.

Sorry this thread got me REAL excited haha. Go electronics! And no I have no credibility as to how expensive Eneloop is, I just know they are highly advertised, and I thought I saw them going for much more than other stuff, so I concluded they were probably crap anyway! WOO!

Apr 12, 2009 21:39

"Ill show you."-John Hammond
Gear List
:D "YES! I AM INVINSIBLE!"-Boris

LOG IN TO REPLY
sponsored links
(this ad will go away when you log in as registered member)
SYS
THREAD ­ STARTER
Cream of the Crop
SYS's Avatar
8,121 posts

Joined Jul 2004

Gilligan's Island
MORE INFO

jcw122 wrote in post #7717850external link
Yeah FORGET YOU ENELOOP YOUR OVER PRICED! Wooooo!

A LOT cheaper than alkalines, though, and I'm willing to bet a lot cheaper than other rechargeable kinds with eneloop's 1,000 + chargeability in its lifetime...

eneloop is NOT overhyped. They performed exactly as they advertised...

Apr 12, 2009 21:47


"Life is short, art is long..."
-Goethe
My Gear & DIYs

LOG IN TO REPLY
unrlmth
Member
135 posts
Joined Feb 2009
MORE INFO

SYS wrote in post #7716663external link
See above post #2 for the charger I used and the mAh info...

As for charging rate, I don't like to charge NiHM batteries at any lower than 200mA and any higher than 500mA, and all tested batteries were charged in this manner.

I was meaning the actual amount the charger put in the batteries from a discharged state. Not the actual manufacture specs which can be off.

200mA and 500mA is a pretty low charge rate. I usually charge mine at around 1.5-2.5A depending on the batteries and how much of a hurry I am in.

Apr 12, 2009 21:48



LOG IN TO REPLY
blam
Goldmember
1,895 posts
Joined Sep 2006

Edmonton, AB, CAN
MORE INFO

I love my eneloops because I can always rely on them, but as your tests confirmed they definitely aren't the strongest. I find mine dont have very good life when in use compared to my old sanyo 2500mahs on full charge

great test! 2 thumbs up and thanks for sharing.

Apr 12, 2009 21:49

Canon 5D MKII
EF 16-35 F2.8L II | EF 70-200 F2.8L IS | EF 50mm F1.2L | EF 100mm F2.8 Macro
430EX II | 580EX II
http://www.onthelam.caexternal link

LOG IN TO REPLY
Ook
Senior Member
Ook's Avatar
648 posts

Joined Mar 2008

Toronto, Canada
MORE INFO

Thanks for doing the test, SYS, I really enjoyed reading it. Very well done!

Apr 12, 2009 21:51

John-Allan
40D | 11-16mm f/2.8 | 17-55mm f/2.8 IS | 100mm f/2.8 macro | 430ex | A650IS

LOG IN TO REPLY

127,234 views & 0 likes for this thread
6,560 FLASH POPS LATER: The Results of "AA" Rechargeable Battery Tests
FORUMS General Gear Talk Flash and Studio Lighting

NOT A MEMBER YET? CLICK HERE TO REGISTER TO THE FORUMS
Registered members get all the features: search, more forums, private messaging, thread follow, notifications, own gallery, own reviews...




SEND FEEDBACK TO STAFF    •   JUMP TO FORUM    •   FORUM RULES    •   Index    •   New Posts    •   RTAT    •   "Best Of"    •   Gallery    •   Gear    •   Reviews    •   Polls

COOKIES DISCLAIMER: By using this site you agree that some cookies will be stored on your browser. For unlogged users we store one session id cookie. For registered members we store (in addition to login session cookie) only cookies that are essential for required functionality. We do not store any personal tracking data in cookies or other browsers' data storage methods.

POWERED BY AMASS 1.1version 1.1
made in Finland
by Pekka Saarinen
for photography-on-the.net
Spent 0.00334 for 6 database queries.
PAGE COMPLETED IN 0.02s
Latest registered member is MattyC
948 guests, 709 members online
Simultaneous users record so far is 3341, that happened on Dec 11, 2014