Canon Digital Photography Forums  

Go Back   Canon Digital Photography Forums > 'Equipment Talk' section > Canon EF and EF-S Lenses
Register Rules FAQ Members List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read



Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #1
fWord
Goldmember
 
fWord's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Posts: 2,635
Default 28-300mmL 'Perfect Partner' - A Tiny Test

To begin with, I have to admit that I'm not qualified to test lenses. I don't shoot charts or brick walls. But the results I got from this lens surprised and excited me, and I thought to share them with you. These are just preliminary observations and updates may be added as I get the chance to try the lens in varied situations in real life.

The photo tests were controlled as best as I could. Turns out that this super-zoom isn't a bad performer after all. I got this lens second-hand just yesterday night, and it's in mint condition, as far as I can tell. Initially I wanted to jump straight for the 24-105mm f/4L during the revamp of my lens setup. But when this one popped up, I couldn't resist the urge to try it. The 28-300mmL is quite rare on the local market, and seemingly quite unloved.

It closely resembles the 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6L functionally, in the sense that both of them are push-pull zooms. The 28-300mm is even weightier, perhaps feels a little better built and operates just as smoothly. But because the angle of view changes so much throughout the zoom, getting the 'right' framing does take a degree of control.

Here are some 100% crops taken indoors, using a 1D, remote release, mirror lockup, and a naked lens (ie. no filter) with IS off. In some pictures, moire may be visible and this is courtesy of the 1D's sensor. Photos shot in RAW. Converted with DPP. Neutral picture style, sharpness +2. In all cases, only the center focusing point was used, and this was centered over the 'T' in the word 'Centrum'.

28mm @ wide open aperture



28mm @ f/8



50mm @ wide open aperture



50mm @ f/8



105mm @ wide open aperture



105mm@ f/8



300mm samples coming up next...
__________________
LightWorks Portfolio
Night Photography Tutorial: Basics & Minutiae
Gear List (Past & Present)
The Art of Composition IS the Art of Photography.

Last edited by fWord : 15th of December 2006 (Fri) at 07:48.
fWord is offline   Reply With Quote
This ad block will go away when you log in as member
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #2
fWord
Goldmember
 
fWord's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Posts: 2,635
Default Re: 28-300mmL 'Perfect Partner' - A Tiny Test

300mm @ wide open aperture



300mm @ f/8



Subjectively, and to my untrained eye, stopping down to f/8 yields improved sharpness but this is more pronounced at the wider end, especially at 28mm. Throughout the range, stopping down does however, improve contrast.

I'd take this lens out for a duck shot and real world photos as soon as my schedule allows. But for now, this lens is excellent on a 1.3X crop camera such as the 1D and may just be its 'Perfect Partner'. The few issues are its weight and its color. It creates one of the heaviest P&S cameras in the world...absolutely muscle and gut-busting. The size when extended also doesn't make for stealthy shooting on the street.
__________________
LightWorks Portfolio
Night Photography Tutorial: Basics & Minutiae
Gear List (Past & Present)
The Art of Composition IS the Art of Photography.
fWord is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #3
MDJAK
...the definition of a noob
 
MDJAK's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: New York
Posts: 24,280
Default Re: 28-300mmL 'Perfect Partner' - A Tiny Test

Good test and review. This lens has always intrigued me, and if I had every lens I wanted already, that'd also be one I'd opt for, for flexibility alone.

mark
MDJAK is offline   Reply With Quote
This ad block will go away when you log in as member
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #4
fWord
Goldmember
 
fWord's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Posts: 2,635
Default Re: 28-300mmL 'Perfect Partner' - A Tiny Test

Quote:
Originally Posted by MDJAK View Post
Good test and review. This lens has always intrigued me, and if I had every lens I wanted already, that'd also be one I'd opt for, for flexibility alone.

mark
It's an unusual and interesting lens. In fact I went for it largely because I wanted to try it out for myself instead of relying entirely on what I was reading.

When you get to that stage in lens nirvana, do try out this lens too! I don't think it'll be a hit with everybody, but as you say, the flexibility is something to be reckoned with. On the 1D the range would be incredible. I don't shoot too wide anymore, so the lens still goes wide enough for me.
__________________
LightWorks Portfolio
Night Photography Tutorial: Basics & Minutiae
Gear List (Past & Present)
The Art of Composition IS the Art of Photography.
fWord is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #5
sjafari
Member
 
sjafari's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Minneapolis, MN
Posts: 507
Default Re: 28-300mmL 'Perfect Partner' - A Tiny Test

thanks for the review. This is a lens that i have also wanted to try out for a long time. I am reminded of how much i liked shooting with the old tamron 28-200 and 28-300, super flexible, but relatively poor image quality. I would expect a lot more out of L series glass, and hope to get my hands on one sometime soon to play with.
__________________
-Shehab-
http://www.fotojafari.net

5Dii, 16-35/2.8ii, 24-70/2.8, 135/2

sjafari is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #6
AdamJL
Goldmember
 
AdamJL's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: 'Straya
Posts: 4,317
Default Re: 28-300mmL 'Perfect Partner' - A Tiny Test

Ditto - I'm another who has always been interested in this lens. It doesn't get much love to be honest, but looks like a good performer.
If it wasn't so heavy, it would be a perfect travelling companion.
Stopping down looks like it really gives an impact, even at the telephoto end (I know you think it's not as noticeable compared to 28mm, but it's still quite noticeable.)
I'm seriously intrigued by this lens.... I just don't know what I'd use it for...
__________________
Gear
coming soon
AdamJL is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #7
fWord
Goldmember
 
fWord's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Posts: 2,635
Default Re: 28-300mmL 'Perfect Partner' - A Tiny Test

Quote:
Originally Posted by sjafari View Post
thanks for the review. This is a lens that i have also wanted to try out for a long time. I am reminded of how much i liked shooting with the old tamron 28-200 and 28-300, super flexible, but relatively poor image quality. I would expect a lot more out of L series glass, and hope to get my hands on one sometime soon to play with.
Most welcome. Super zooms can make SLR photography a little more fun because it takes lens changes out of the equation. To be frank, I didn't expect great quality out of this lens as well, but the results really surprised me. At 28mm and stopped down (which I will always do for landscape photography) the quality is more than acceptable.

The 50mm and 105mm samples seemed to 'pop' out at me. Very nice. At 300mm things seem to take a little dive with a bit of softness creeping in. That said, it's still well-defined.
__________________
LightWorks Portfolio
Night Photography Tutorial: Basics & Minutiae
Gear List (Past & Present)
The Art of Composition IS the Art of Photography.
fWord is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #8
fWord
Goldmember
 
fWord's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Posts: 2,635
Default Re: 28-300mmL 'Perfect Partner' - A Tiny Test

Quote:
Originally Posted by AdamJL View Post
Ditto - I'm another who has always been interested in this lens. It doesn't get much love to be honest, but looks like a good performer.
If it wasn't so heavy, it would be a perfect travelling companion.
Stopping down looks like it really gives an impact, even at the telephoto end (I know you think it's not as noticeable compared to 28mm, but it's still quite noticeable.)
I'm seriously intrigued by this lens.... I just don't know what I'd use it for...
That's right. It's an unloved piece of glass, but from these preliminary tests it appears that the lens is indeed very good, especially considering the 11X zoom, 3-stop IS on top...it's a very complicated device.

Buying it first-hand isn't probably such a good idea because the price is just exhorbitant. Working pros can afford it, but people like us who are just curious to have a play with it will need to get it from the 2nd-hand market, and I think I found a bargain here at a local forum.

I think you'll know what to do with the lens when you finally buy it. It's so versatile that it'll do almost everything for you. In the lens world there is something for everyone, and I think this lens would be excellent for landscapes...this usually doesn't demand a fast lens to start off with, and the lens will usually be tripod-mounted. Even if handheld (which I tend to do), I like to stop down a lens for DOF, so the IS would really come in handy.

I don't do sports/ fast action stuff, so I won't miss a lot by using this lens. Wildlife is about the fastest I will go to, and at the zoo, those things don't move very much at all.
__________________
LightWorks Portfolio
Night Photography Tutorial: Basics & Minutiae
Gear List (Past & Present)
The Art of Composition IS the Art of Photography.
fWord is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #9
AdamJL
Goldmember
 
AdamJL's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: 'Straya
Posts: 4,317
Default Re: 28-300mmL 'Perfect Partner' - A Tiny Test

But it's hard to justify the purpose of this lens when I have a 24-105 and a 70-300 on the way... if I use the 28-300 I'll know I'm not getting my money's worth from the two other lenses.
Saying that, if I see it decently priced on the second hand market, I might take a peak. I've seen it brand new and it's way out of my current budget. But I've never really seen a second hand Cano lens go cheap. They have great resale value.
__________________
Gear
coming soon
AdamJL is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #10
fWord
Goldmember
 
fWord's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Posts: 2,635
Default Re: 28-300mmL 'Perfect Partner' - A Tiny Test

Quote:
Originally Posted by AdamJL View Post
But it's hard to justify the purpose of this lens when I have a 24-105 and a 70-300 on the way... if I use the 28-300 I'll know I'm not getting my money's worth from the two other lenses.
Saying that, if I see it decently priced on the second hand market, I might take a peak. I've seen it brand new and it's way out of my current budget. But I've never really seen a second hand Cano lens go cheap. They have great resale value.
That's good thinking. I suppose if that were the case, then it may not be necessary to have an all-purpose 28-300mm. I'm assuming you're going for the 70-300mm IS? The 24-105mm and 70-300mm IS would have made a lovely setup and I was considering it as well...this was after I decided that I'll blow my budget after all and not get the Sigma 70-300mm.

Funny thing here was that I realized the 28-300mm zoom was even cheaper than those two lenses combined. Plus, it's weather-sealed, has great build-feel and can potentially free me from ever needing to change lenses again.

Canon lenses usually don't lose much of their value, but you may chance upon someone who's either giving up the hobby or is desperate/ impatient to get the cash back. And when you do, you can probably nab a reasonable deal. If you approach online sources then you open many more avenues for hunting. But personally, I wouldn't trust anybody online with such a big sum of money.
__________________
LightWorks Portfolio
Night Photography Tutorial: Basics & Minutiae
Gear List (Past & Present)
The Art of Composition IS the Art of Photography.
fWord is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #11
AdamJL
Goldmember
 
AdamJL's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: 'Straya
Posts: 4,317
Default Re: 28-300mmL 'Perfect Partner' - A Tiny Test

Quote:
Originally Posted by fWord View Post
That's good thinking. I suppose if that were the case, then it may not be necessary to have an all-purpose 28-300mm. I'm assuming you're going for the 70-300mm IS? The 24-105mm and 70-300mm IS would have made a lovely setup and I was considering it as well...this was after I decided that I'll blow my budget after all and not get the Sigma 70-300mm.
Yes, I purchased the 70-300 IS. Very excited about receiving it.
And to be honest, I only found out about the 28-300 after I'd bought my 24-105. Whether or not I would have gone down the same path had I know about the 28-300 previously, I'm quite unsure about. I'm that interested in this lens.
My current 28-300 has seen better days to be honest, and although I've used it plenty of times overseas as my travel lens, the optical quality is what prompted me to invest in the 24-105.

Quote:
Originally Posted by fWord View Post
Funny thing here was that I realized the 28-300mm zoom was even cheaper than those two lenses combined. Plus, it's weather-sealed, has great build-feel and can potentially free me from ever needing to change lenses again.
yes, weather sealing is ultra important, especially for a traveller like myself. The 24-105 is dust/moisture sealed at the back only I believe. And that doesn't really help as I'm using a 350D anyway, so dust likes to get in.

Quote:
Originally Posted by fWord View Post
Canon lenses usually don't lose much of their value, but you may chance upon someone who's either giving up the hobby or is desperate/ impatient to get the cash back. And when you do, you can probably nab a reasonable deal. If you approach online sources then you open many more avenues for hunting. But personally, I wouldn't trust anybody online with such a big sum of money.
If you see another one going cheap on your forums, let me know, I'll have a peak! I should be in Singapore next year, so I'm always happy to pick up in person.
__________________
Gear
coming soon
AdamJL is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #12
fWord
Goldmember
 
fWord's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Posts: 2,635
Default Re: 28-300mmL 'Perfect Partner' - A Tiny Test

Quote:
Originally Posted by AdamJL View Post
If you see another one going cheap on your forums, let me know, I'll have a peak! I should be in Singapore next year, so I'm always happy to pick up in person.
Wow, so you're pretty keen on this lens eh? It's always nice to try new things of course. The 24-105mm seems to be a stellar lens and I was almost sold on it based on what I read. After using the consumer 28-105mm lens for a vacation I found out how useful that range was, so the 24-105mm is going to be even better especially considering the IS.

I noticed that you're using a 350D. In the end you'll probably still need to keep your widest lens because the 28-300mm doesn't exactly go wide enough on a 1.6X crop camera.

How did you find out that the 24-105mm was only sealed at the back? So far I assumed that it was weather-sealed on its extending portion as well, just like the 24-70mm f/2.8.

I'll keep a lookout for you at the local forums and will get back to you here if I see anything. So far I've only seen perhaps one or maybe two copies of this lens go for sale.
__________________
LightWorks Portfolio
Night Photography Tutorial: Basics & Minutiae
Gear List (Past & Present)
The Art of Composition IS the Art of Photography.
fWord is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #13
calicokat
calicokat is BANNED
 
calicokat's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Southern California
Posts: 14,720
Default Re: 28-300mmL 'Perfect Partner' - A Tiny Test

Thanks for the review, very interesting lens
__________________
"You are going to fall off a cliff trying to get a better shot someday"- My hopeful and loving wife


My Website

My Gear

Calicokat 1990-2007 RIP My Loving Kitty
calicokat is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #14
cjm
Goldmember
 
cjm's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Edmonton, Alberta
Posts: 4,740
Default Re: 28-300mmL 'Perfect Partner' - A Tiny Test

Buddy you bought it? Wow I cant wait to see the results you get outdoors. So how heavy is it? Like 70-200 f2.8 L weight like? Good hand holdable?
__________________
Christopher J Martin
Gear: 1D MKIII - 60D - G16 - 24mm f1.4 L
- 24-70mm F2.8 L - 70-200mm IS f2.8 L - 100-400 f4.5-5.6 IS L and more...
cjm is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #15
fWord
Goldmember
 
fWord's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Posts: 2,635
Default Re: 28-300mmL 'Perfect Partner' - A Tiny Test

calicokat: Most welcome. Hope to put up some real results soon. At this moment I am still waiting to see if my military camp is going to recall me for an exercise!

cjm: Yup. Pulled the trigger on this baby...being quite affordable (seems the seller was letting it go cheap) it was irresistable. It was screaming to be bought and tried.

The lens is heavier than either the 70-200mm f/2.8IS or the 100-400mm IS, but not by much. However once the camera is added on top the whole setup is quite a lump to carry around. I'm not strong at all but it is manageable if I hold it to my eye level for short periods at a time just to shoot a photo. IS really helps because the viewfinder really jumps around a lot at the 300mm end.

I'll need to work-out and strengthen myself for it. But for the majority of people out there, it shouldn't be too hard to handle. This really makes me glad that I didn't buy a Bigma, hoping to be able to handhold that!

Hope to get some real world pictures here if I manage a trip out this evening.
__________________
LightWorks Portfolio
Night Photography Tutorial: Basics & Minutiae
Gear List (Past & Present)
The Art of Composition IS the Art of Photography.
fWord is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Perfect light but not perfect photo NCBEACH Critique Corner 3 22nd of January 2007 (Mon) 23:32
Howdy Partner bdj3 People 1 28th of June 2006 (Wed) 21:39
My partner Sean-Mcr People 10 13th of May 2006 (Sat) 19:06
Perfect physique studio test DRock Small Flash and Studio Lighting 0 2nd of April 2006 (Sun) 11:00
Perfect test subject ! JonathanSQ Wildlife 1 25th of November 2005 (Fri) 16:51


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:09.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.12
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
This forum is not affiliated with Canon in any way and is run as a free user helpsite by Pekka Saarinen, Helsinki Finland. You will need to register in order to be able to post messages. Cookies are required for registering and posting. HTML in messages is not allowed, plain website addresses are automatically made active by the board.