Canon Digital Photography Forums  

Go Back   Canon Digital Photography Forums > 'Equipment Talk' section > Small Flash and Studio Lighting
Register Rules FAQ Members List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read



Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #1
TMR Design
Cream of the Crop
 
TMR Design's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Huntington Station, NY
Posts: 23,881
Default Question about using Barn Doors on strobes

I've been looking at light modifiers like snoots and grids and have seen barn doors being used and suggested in some cases.

I guess this is really a 2 part question.

A) Does using barn doors give you a hard edge or a shadow with a straight edge (depending on how close to the background or subject) because of the straight line/edge of the door?

B) How does one figure out what is needed or best? Snoots? Grids? Barn Doors? If you've never used these modifiers, are there general rules or scenarios that you would want one over the other?
__________________
Please call me Robert or Rob, not TMR
Gear List & Feedback | The Lighting Academy

"Art is the elimination of the unnecessary." - Pablo Picasso
TMR Design is offline  
This ad block will go away when you log in as member
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #2
TMR Design
Cream of the Crop
 
TMR Design's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Huntington Station, NY
Posts: 23,881
Default Re: Question about using Barn Doors on strobes

No takers?
__________________
Please call me Robert or Rob, not TMR
Gear List & Feedback | The Lighting Academy

"Art is the elimination of the unnecessary." - Pablo Picasso
TMR Design is offline  
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #3
StealthLude
Goldmember
 
StealthLude's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Posts: 3,680
Default Re: Question about using Barn Doors on strobes

Ill bump it since Im also looking for some information on this =)

Im sure a snoot gives a round light, but Im curious to how barn doors would look/work. I wanted to buy barn doors for use with my background or hair light (with a grid) instead of a snoot since it would give me control of the size. But im still not sure as to how it performs.
__________________
[[Gear List]]

Skype: Stealthlude
StealthLude is offline  
This ad block will go away when you log in as member
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #4
Wilt
Cream of the Crop
 
Wilt's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: California
Posts: 33,299
Default Re: Question about using Barn Doors on strobes

Will have to experiment this weekend. I haven't used barndoors since forever for anything but a gobo to shade the lens from light (and then I didn't care about the hardness or softness of the transition!) If memory serves me, the edge is actually somewhat soft because the apparent light source size is the full reflector, not merely the bulb. Do the experiment yourself...you only have to hold a book or magazine in front of your light as if one edge was clipped to the metal reflector!


Snoots and grids accomplish different things, even though both have a circular pattern of light cast on the subject/background...the grid tends to collimate the light a bit with the grid pattern removing a bit of the omnidirection component of light rays, the snoot does that to a much lesser degree.
__________________
Canon dSLR system, Olympus OM 35mm system, Bronica ETRSi 645 system, Horseman LS 4x5 system, Metz flashes, Dynalite studio lighting, and too many accessories to mention
Keep POTN alive and well with member support http://photography-on-the.net/forum/donate.php

Last edited by Wilt : 15th of December 2006 (Fri) at 17:34.
Wilt is offline  
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #5
kickmaster
Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: San Diego. CA
Posts: 304
Default Re: Question about using Barn Doors on strobes

I just used barndoors this past weekend to control the backdrop lighting while I shot. I'm happy to report that there were no hard lines in the background, and no spill onto my subjects.
kickmaster is offline  
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #6
TMR Design
Cream of the Crop
 
TMR Design's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Huntington Station, NY
Posts: 23,881
Default Re: Question about using Barn Doors on strobes

Quote:
Originally Posted by kickmaster View Post
I just used barndoors this past weekend to control the backdrop lighting while I shot. I'm happy to report that there were no hard lines in the background, and no spill onto my subjects.
Did you select them over other modifiers for any particular reason? is it that you could not have done what you were shooting with a snoot or grid? Did it give you more precise control over where light went and did not go?
__________________
Please call me Robert or Rob, not TMR
Gear List & Feedback | The Lighting Academy

"Art is the elimination of the unnecessary." - Pablo Picasso
TMR Design is offline  
Old 15th of December 2006 (Fri)   #7
kickmaster
Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: San Diego. CA
Posts: 304
Default Re: Question about using Barn Doors on strobes

No, I did't have any other modifiers at the time. It did give me far more control (especially with regard to spill). I've used grids with predicable results too.
kickmaster is offline  
Old 31st of December 2006 (Sun)   #8
LightingMan
Master of Light
 
LightingMan's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Fort Worth, Texas
Posts: 210
Smile Re: Question about using Barn Doors on strobes

Dear Robert:
Before I expand on these lighting devices, let me explain that shadow edge is controlled by the size of your light source. Barn doors donít give you a hard shadow edge because they are barn doors. They do it because they are part of a small light source. The only thing that matters in this regard is the size of the light source from the point of view of the subject so next time you are curious about this, just sit on the posing stool where your subject would be and look at your various light sources. It is their size from this point of view that controls the hardness or softness of of the shadow edge.

Control devices like snoots, barn doors and grids each have a characteristic way of controlling the light exiting a studio flash unit. Photographers getting into the business have a great tendency to be constantly looking at all the new toys available to them that will undoubtedly make their photographs better. This I know because I was once one of them.

First the ever popular and misunderstood snoot. This is in many cases the first lighting gadget that photographers buy once they have their studio strobes. It seems to be designed to assist in the business of lighting the hair. Well, the snoot is not a particularly controllable lighting device and that seats it in the ďOf little or no valueĒ section. A snoot is basically a metal tube on a flat piece of metal that mounts to your studio flash unit. The tube is usually only about 3 or so inches across so right off the bat, it is reducing the amount of light coming from your flash unit. The tube is typically 6 to 10 inches long. So what does it do if anything at all? It takes a smaller amount of light (because of the reduced size of the aperture in the metal plate) and lets that light exit the front of the tube. Thatís it. It confines the light to a somewhat narrower area than the flash unit by itself but only to a degree so there is little benefit from using it. It does not provide any significant control other than a slight amount of pattern narrowing. After 26 years in the business, I demonstrate how valuable the snoot is to me at my seminars by bringing it out sitting in a clay pot filled with potting soil with a nice ivy plant growing it. I have seen snoots where a small piece of honeycomb material was mounted in the mouth to collimate the light a little. There was an improvement but it still was very poor as a controllable lighting device.

A grid spot attachment is a device that has an inch or so of honeycomb metal mounted into a frame that attaches to the front of your studio flash unit. The purpose for the honeycomb material is to collimate the light into a narrow beam. There are different sizes of honey comb material where the individual holes vary from about an a tenth of an inch up to a quarter of an inch. The narrower the hole the narrower the beam exiting the flash unit. At a distance of 10 feet, a grid with small holes in the honeycomb might project a pattern of light no bigger than 10 inches or so. A grid with larger holes in the honeycomb, will be a bit larger. So what is the benefit of having a grid spot attachment like this? Several.

A grid spot can be used to isolate a subjectís face leaving the rest of their body essentially in shadow. I have used this effect many times over the years in everything from high school senior work to boudoir photography. The light source is a small one with hard shadow edges so care must be used to create a proper lighting pattern such as loop, or Rembrandt. For fashion work, it is easy to create a lighting pattern like Francisco Scavullo did for many years on the cover of Cosmopolitan magazine. The light is fired dead on into the models face at eye level and is then moved just slighting to the side creating a very subtle shadow on one side of the nose. This technique combined with a soft focus filter can be quite striking and is relatively simple to do.

A grid spot can also be useful in highlighting a small area in a photograph without affecting anything else nearby. I have used grid spots countless times in boudoir photography to add a beautiful glow to a womanís feet in high heels. I have also used grid spots as a bust line augmentation light where the grid is firing from slightly behind the model, over her shoulder gently grazing across the cleavage area creating highlights with shadows thereby enhancing the size of the bust line. I actually had a customer once ask me if I could come to her home and adjust the lights so she looked that big at home. It was pretty funny at the time.

Grid spots are also useful when you wish to add a small splash of color to the background in a very specific place. Simply added a color gel and point the light where you want it. It is important to use a grid that has a flat metal frame around the front so gels can be easily clipped on.

I have used grid spots to fire a long beam of colored light diagonally across a muslin background for specific effect. I have also used them to direct a small amount of light onto a very specific area of an object when doing commercial product photography.

I have found many uses for grids over the years but as with all accessories, they are only as useful as you make them. They wonít do the work themselves.

Lastly, we have the barn doors. These are simple frames that attach to a studio flash unit and have hinged metal doors. Sometimes two doors and sometimes 4 doors. One would ask what the benefits are for one over the other. With a 2 door unit, you can close the doors down to zero opening but the opening will always be a long slit. This is not a bad thing but under certain circumstances it is more convenient to have 4 doors so you can close down in both axis at the same time keeping your light source symmetrical. The bottom line is that if you have a 4 door unit, you also have a 2 door. Just donít use the other two.

The benefits from using barn doors are not as well known as with other studio toys. Today we have such a huge emphasis on technology doing everything for us that many simple devices like the barn doors are sadly all but forgotten. Barn doors provide control unlike any other device. With nothing more than a quick flip of the hand, you can change the amount of light exiting your flash unit from 100% to 0 % or any increment in-between those extremes. The beauty of this is that the changes made affect both modeling light and strobe tube equally so you can stay in a ďwhat you see is what you getĒ mode. This is critical for me because I want to know what I have before I press the shutter release button to make an exposure. I do not want to have to look at the back of my camera to see how my lighting is. I watch photographers everywhere spending more time looking at the back of their digital cameras than looking through it at the subject. I want to know that what I see is what I will get and the only way to know is to have a balanced set of lights and to use methods of controlling their output so any changes made are equal for both modeling bulb and strobe tube.

Someone will say, just turn down the output of the flash unit while it is in the tracking mode. Sadly, many, many flash units are not linear with the amount of change provided in their controls. This means that reducing the amount of strobe output, reduces the amount of modeling bulb output by a disproportionate and usually lesser quantity. For many flash units, the tracking feature is only a rough approximation. I recently tested the just released Novatron M600 mono light and plotted a graph of itís strobe output as compared to its modeling bulb output and was pleasantly startled at itís nearly ruler flat tracking over a 5 stop range. Itís the first I have encounter that was this accurate.

Ok, back to the barn doors. When I am adding a bit of accent light to a portrait subjectís hair, I have to have control over the smallest changes in light output. For this reason, I use a set of barn doors on my hair light. So frequently, hair light is overdone and blown away. I teach my students to begin small and gently build up the hair light until itís just enough to provide a beautiful separation and still show detail in every hair. This kind of precision is easy with barn doors because of the control you have. I open my barn doors on my hair light just a crack. Perhaps a half inch or so depending on hair color while my flash unit is pointing behind and away from the subject. Then I gently rotate the flash unit toward the subject until just a kiss of light is gently touching the side of the subjectís head providing me with perfect hair light. This works perfectly for one or two people as I can train my hair light to reach both people and give one more light than the other if need be due to differences in hair color. For larger groups, itís no more difficult than turning the flash unit upward and firing it toward the ceiling where a large reflective panel is mounted above the shooting area. I can now provide a beautiful kiss of hair light on a family of 8 or 10 and control the amount of hair light precisely by simply opening or closing the barn doors. Simple.

Like the grid spot, one can also use barn doors to fire light into small areas of a photograph for various effects. Lighting a modelís shoes or the calves of her legs or adding a deep blue accent light to the edge of her black leather jacket are all easily done using barn doors combined with color gels.

Barn doors are excellent when you wish to fire a bit of light onto a specific area of your background as you can easily control how large the area is and how much light reaches that area by opening or closing the doors.

For me the most significant thing that barn doors allow me to do is to control the amount of main light that I am using. Most of the time, my main light is a simple 7 foot tall diffusion panel. I use this because it provides control like no other lighting device. I get to decide what size of light I am using and can change from huge to extremely small in a matter of 2 seconds by doing nothing more than changing the distance of the flash unit to the panel thereby making the lit area on the panel larger or smaller. Combine this with the use of a set of barn doors and you have unlimited control over both size and quantity of light. By adjusting the size of the barn door opening and the distance to the panel, I have total control over the size of the light and the quantity of the light. I can close the doors way down to only a 4 inch square and move them very close to the panel for a very hard edge defined quality of light. I can also move my flash unit back and enlarge the area on the panel being lit providing a softer quality of light. I can also open the doors up all the way and move the flash unit in close and create a small light source at a higher brightness level. The control possibilities are huge and the best part of this is that since the changes in light output are mechanical because of the barn doors, I will always get what I see.

Barn doors are my favorite tool in the camera room as well as on location. They provide incredible control while giving me precisely what I see. Thatís a pretty big advantage when there is a lot of money riding on getting it right the first time.

I hope this has been helpful.
Best wishes,
__________________
Scott Smith - Master Photographic Craftsman, CPP, F-TPPA
CLICK to write to me: Scott@LightingMagic.com

"It's not what you own that makes you a great image maker... It's what you know." - Scott Smith
LightingMan is offline  
Old 31st of December 2006 (Sun)   #9
TMR Design
Cream of the Crop
 
TMR Design's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Huntington Station, NY
Posts: 23,881
Default Re: Question about using Barn Doors on strobes

Scott,

Thank you so much for the great detail and descriptions. This was a great help to me as I am trying to figure out which types of light modifiers are best for me and what I want to do. The hairlight is important and something I would like to have so that is in the plan. I'm trying to determine based on each description which device is actually the best for creating colored backgrounds, whether useing seamless paper or muslin. The Grids and Barn Doors sound like they cover all my needs and the snoot sounds like it does the least but in terms of getting a nice tight dot of light or colored light using a gel, I thought a snoot was about equal to having a 20į grid. Can I do all the things I want with Barn Doors and I don't really need a grid bor my background lighting?

Thanks again for your help.
__________________
Please call me Robert or Rob, not TMR
Gear List & Feedback | The Lighting Academy

"Art is the elimination of the unnecessary." - Pablo Picasso
TMR Design is offline  
Old 31st of December 2006 (Sun)   #10
LightingMan
Master of Light
 
LightingMan's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Fort Worth, Texas
Posts: 210
Default Re: Question about using Barn Doors on strobes

Hi Robert
There is nothing tight about the light coming from a snoot. It is also very clumsey to try and attach gels to. I simply see no practical use for it when other devices do so much more. A grid is not usually used to put a glow over a subject's shoulders for a closeup. The pattern would be too small. The flash unit kept perpendicular to the backgound at a foot or two will do this effectively. Use a gel holder to attach color gels and neutral density gels for very precise control over background glows without changing the size of the pattern by moving the light back and forth.
If you would like to see many examples of how these devices are used feel free to visit the gallery section of my web site.
Here is the address.
http://www.lightingmagic.com/scottgal.htm
Best wishes and take care,
__________________
Scott Smith - Master Photographic Craftsman, CPP, F-TPPA
CLICK to write to me: Scott@LightingMagic.com

"It's not what you own that makes you a great image maker... It's what you know." - Scott Smith

Last edited by LightingMan : 31st of December 2006 (Sun) at 13:34. Reason: Spelling and more info.
LightingMan is offline  
Old 31st of December 2006 (Sun)   #11
TMR Design
Cream of the Crop
 
TMR Design's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Huntington Station, NY
Posts: 23,881
Default Re: Question about using Barn Doors on strobes

Hi Scott,

I looked at your Gallery and much of what I see there are effects I want to achieve. I've played with moving my AB800 closer to the background to reduce the size of the spot of light but the area is so large and the light spreads no matter how close. That is what led me to start looking into grids and snoots so I could narrow that light.
__________________
Please call me Robert or Rob, not TMR
Gear List & Feedback | The Lighting Academy

"Art is the elimination of the unnecessary." - Pablo Picasso
TMR Design is offline  
Old 31st of December 2006 (Sun)   #12
LightingMan
Master of Light
 
LightingMan's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Fort Worth, Texas
Posts: 210
Default Re: Question about using Barn Doors on strobes

Hi
If you are using your flash unit with a standard 7 inch or so silver reflector on it, you will be able to achieve a nice round pattern when the light is used near the background. If you try this and still have trouble, please post a sample image showing what you were doing and we will get this resolved for you. You don't need grids or snoots to achieve this effect.
take care,
__________________
Scott Smith - Master Photographic Craftsman, CPP, F-TPPA
CLICK to write to me: Scott@LightingMagic.com

"It's not what you own that makes you a great image maker... It's what you know." - Scott Smith

Last edited by LightingMan : 31st of December 2006 (Sun) at 14:27. Reason: spelling
LightingMan is offline  
Old 31st of December 2006 (Sun)   #13
stckciv
Member
 
stckciv's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: SLC Utah
Posts: 240
Default Re: Question about using Barn Doors on strobes

Thanks for the detailed posts lightingman! Always great information!!!
__________________
There are always two people in every picture, the photographer and the viewer. ~Ansel Adams
stckciv is offline  
Old 31st of December 2006 (Sun)   #14
TMR Design
Cream of the Crop
 
TMR Design's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Huntington Station, NY
Posts: 23,881
Default Re: Question about using Barn Doors on strobes

Quote:
Originally Posted by lightingman View Post
Hi
If you are using your flash unit with a standard 7 inch or so silver reflector on it, you will be able to achieve a nice round pattern when the light is used near the background. If you try this and still have trouble, please post a sample image showing what you were doing and we will get this resolved for you. You don't need grids or snoots to achieve this effect.
take care,
Scott,

I took some quicks shots to show you. The light is pointing straight ahead at the background and and is literally 6" from the background. I had to put the strobe that close to get a spot of light that size, which is about 24" in diameter from the modeling light and spreads to about 28" or 30" when the strobe fires. The left hand image is the spot of light from the modeling light and on the right is the strobe. If I pull the light further away or try to bring it in from an angle on the side the spread of light is so great that it begins to light a large part of the background. If I place the strobe on a floor stand that is 6" from the ground and point it up at the background to create an oval or sphere of light I can't do that either due to the spread of light.

This is why I thought I needed some sort of modifier to narrow the beam.
.
Attached Images
File Type: jpg light_01.jpg (6.3 KB, 5564 views)
File Type: jpg light_02.jpg (14.1 KB, 5521 views)
__________________
Please call me Robert or Rob, not TMR
Gear List & Feedback | The Lighting Academy

"Art is the elimination of the unnecessary." - Pablo Picasso
TMR Design is offline  
Old 31st of December 2006 (Sun)   #15
LightingMan
Master of Light
 
LightingMan's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Fort Worth, Texas
Posts: 210
Default Re: Question about using Barn Doors on strobes

HI Robert
First is a question. How many of these mono lights are you using in your portrait lighting setup? ...and are they all identical? Details please.
The concept you are missing here is the combination of taking aperture (which is based upon the amount of light reaching the subject) relative to the output of the background light. We deal with the main light first and all suplimental lighting is relative to the all important main light. This is not complex but we do have to know the full story about what you are doing here.

The major factor here is that we are looking ONLY at your background light. We need to address what it is doing when you have a portrait subject 6 feet in front of it with correct lighting on them and the correct taking aperture set on the lens. This is not a complicated issue to solve but we have to know all the contributing factors.
Let me know the entire story and we can get this resolved for you, no problem.
Take care
Scott
__________________
Scott Smith - Master Photographic Craftsman, CPP, F-TPPA
CLICK to write to me: Scott@LightingMagic.com

"It's not what you own that makes you a great image maker... It's what you know." - Scott Smith
LightingMan is offline  
Closed Thread


Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Barn doors or snoot? Roy Mathers Small Flash and Studio Lighting 9 21st of July 2007 (Sat) 12:14
Barn Doors for 400FX?? Nekkid Small Flash and Studio Lighting 2 26th of October 2006 (Thu) 14:32
Barn Doors suggestions? incendy Small Flash and Studio Lighting 0 27th of September 2006 (Wed) 14:48
Barn doors for EX series flashes? tim Small Flash and Studio Lighting 4 10th of August 2005 (Wed) 07:49


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:07.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.12
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
This forum is not affiliated with Canon in any way and is run as a free user helpsite by Pekka Saarinen, Helsinki Finland. You will need to register in order to be able to post messages. Cookies are required for registering and posting. HTML in messages is not allowed, plain website addresses are automatically made active by the board.