S2 and filters

madmmac · 6th of June 2007 (Wed)

Sorry if this has been explained before, but I did try looking. I just picked up the camera and know of the 52 and 58mm tube extensions for the camera but was wondering how filters and vignetting worked.

I have more than a few 77mm Nikon filters and would need to purchase step up rings for the S2....but would the 52 or 58mm be better to handle them as far as vignetting and such? Any and all information is appreciated.

Thanks, madmmac.....1st Post!!!

GoHokiesGo · 7th of June 2007 (Thu)

I have a 52mm adaptor on my S2, and I get a bit of vignetting when shooting at the wide end. I'm not sure about the 58mm, but you do get a bit of it with the 52mm.

Cindi · 7th of June 2007 (Thu)

Hmmm....I've never noticed any vignetting with my 52mm set up. Maybe I should go and look over them better! LOL!! Did you order your setup from Lensmate Jason?
Anyone else with the 52mm setup from Lensmate notice some vignetting?

nwyman · 10th of June 2007 (Sun)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cindi

Hmmm....I've never noticed any vignetting with my 52mm set up. Maybe I should go and look over them better! LOL!! Did you order your setup from Lensmate Jason?
Anyone else with the 52mm setup from Lensmate notice some vignetting?

I have both 52 and 58 - both from Lensmate and no vignetting for me.

I've just taken the trusty S2 to Disney in Orlando for a week's vacation. After shunning it for a year while I was learning the ropes on the Rebel XT, it was good to have it back in hand again.

springplum · 10th of June 2007 (Sun)

I have the 58 setup and have had no vignetting, but I would be worried that the 77mm filters would cause shadows when you use the flash.

GoHokiesGo · 10th of June 2007 (Sun)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cindi

Hmmm....I've never noticed any vignetting with my 52mm set up. Maybe I should go and look over them better! LOL!! Did you order your setup from Lensmate Jason?
Anyone else with the 52mm setup from Lensmate notice some vignetting?

My adaptor is from fotodiox, but I think they are all the same dimensionally.

But now that I think of it, whenever I have the adaptor on my S2 I also have the lens hood on it. I'm sure that extra little bit of length from the hood could be the cause. I will have to try shooting without the hood on to see if I get any vignetting.

madmmac · 11th of June 2007 (Mon)

Quote:

Originally Posted by springplum

I have the 58 setup and have had no vignetting, but I would be worried that the 77mm filters would cause shadows when you use the flash.

Good point. What is the size of the standard hood?

Thanks, madmmac

springplum · 13th of June 2007 (Wed)

Quote:

Originally Posted by madmmac

Good point. What is the size of the standard hood?

Thanks, madmmac

Thread size or big ol' round end size?

6th of June 2007 (Wed)	#1
madmmac Junior Member Join Date: Jun 2007 Posts: 22	S2 and filters Sorry if this has been explained before, but I did try looking. I just picked up the camera and know of the 52 and 58mm tube extensions for the camera but was wondering how filters and vignetting worked. I have more than a few 77mm Nikon filters and would need to purchase step up rings for the S2....but would the 52 or 58mm be better to handle them as far as vignetting and such? Any and all information is appreciated. Thanks, madmmac.....1st Post!!!

7th of June 2007 (Thu)	#2
GoHokiesGo Member Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Virginia - DC Metro Posts: 469 IMAGE EDITING OK	Re: S2 and filters I have a 52mm adaptor on my S2, and I get a bit of vignetting when shooting at the wide end. I'm not sure about the 58mm, but you do get a bit of it with the 52mm. __________________ ~*Jason* Canon 60D -¤- Canon XTi Sigma 10-20mm f/4-5.6 EX -¤- Canon 24-105 f/4L IS -¤- Canon 70-200 f/4L Sigma 30mm f/1.4 EX -¤- Sigma 24-60 f/2.8 EX -¤- Metz 48 AF-1 Flash SmugMug Link

7th of June 2007 (Thu)	#3
Cindi Member Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Cedar Springs, MI Posts: 366 IMAGE EDITING OK	Re: S2 and filters Hmmm....I've never noticed any vignetting with my 52mm set up. Maybe I should go and look over them better! LOL!! Did you order your setup from Lensmate Jason? Anyone else with the 52mm setup from Lensmate notice some vignetting? __________________ ~ Cindi ~ Rebel XTi/kit lens/nifty fifty Powershot S2 IS

10th of June 2007 (Sun)	#5
springplum Member Join Date: May 2007 Location: Texas Posts: 48 IMAGE EDITING OK	Re: S2 and filters I have the 58 setup and have had no vignetting, but I would be worried that the 77mm filters would cause shadows when you use the flash.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Gelatin filters vs Screw-in filters	kn_guy87	Canon EF and EF-S Lenses	3	3rd of February 2006 (Fri) 10:04
Polarising filters - filters aint filters?	Drk Orange	Accessories & Storage	9	25th of April 2005 (Mon) 17:25
are multi-coated filters worth double the price of non MC filters?	johnathanesper	Accessories & Storage	7	9th of February 2005 (Wed) 19:33
Canon Filters vs Hoya filters?	dennykyser	Accessories & Storage	3	21st of February 2004 (Sat) 22:49
Photoshop filters VS lens filters	Conk	General Photography Talk	4	6th of September 2002 (Fri) 18:37