Canon Digital Photography Forums  

Go Back   Canon Digital Photography Forums > 'Equipment Talk' section > Canon EOS Digital Cameras
Register Rules FAQ Members List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read



Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 16th of May 2008 (Fri)   #1
10-Dee-Q
Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 204
Default what is "auto lighting optimizer and highlight tone priority"?

Okay so i have my 450D for about a month for now, and i took a lot of photos and has been very very satisfied with it .
but i do have some question cause i feel the supplied manual didn't explain this to well for newbie like me.

#1> What is "Auto Lightig Optimizer" ?

#2> What is "highlight Tone Priority" ?

and can you please tell me when i should turn them on or off ?

And one more , i knew that we used to cover the vf when taking picture in bulb mode so thus the metering will be more accurate, but how about when taking pics with the liveview ?
do we still need to cover the vf ?
cause from what i see the vf is not available when shooting in live view mode .

thx
__________________
Canon 500D | , 50 f/1.8 MK I, 18-55 IS, 55-250 IS |
10-Dee-Q is offline   Reply With Quote
This ad block will go away when you log in as member
Old 16th of May 2008 (Fri)   #2
basroil
Cream of the Crop
 
basroil's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: STL/Clayton, MO| NJ
Posts: 8,015
Default Re: what is "auto lighting optimizer and hihglight tone priority"?

1) i will guess it's just a special code that normalizes light levels after exposure, only useful in JPG.
2) a fake iso setting that underexposes an image then uses software to bring the highlights down and shadows the same.

both will kill your already pathetic buffer. if you shoot raw, no need for either.

for last question, no, since exposure during live view is handled by "the sensor" itself rather than the exposure metering sensor.
__________________
I don't hate macs or OSX, I hate people and statements that portray them as better than anything else. Macs are A solution, not THE solution. Get a good desktop i7 with Windows 7 and come tell me that sucks for photo or video editing.
Gear List
basroil is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 16th of May 2008 (Fri)   #3
10-Dee-Q
Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 204
Default Re: what is "auto lighting optimizer and hihglight tone priority"?

Quote:
Originally Posted by basroil View Post
1) i will guess it's just a special code that normalizes light levels after exposure, only useful in JPG.
2) a fake iso setting that underexposes an image then uses software to bring the highlights down and shadows the same.

both will kill your already pathetic buffer. if you shoot raw, no need for either.

for last question, no, since exposure during live view is handled by "the sensor" itself rather than the exposure metering sensor.

okay so maojrity of people here turn it off ?
__________________
Canon 500D | , 50 f/1.8 MK I, 18-55 IS, 55-250 IS |
10-Dee-Q is offline   Reply With Quote
This ad block will go away when you log in as member
Old 16th of May 2008 (Fri)   #4
tzalman
Fatal attraction.
 
tzalman's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Gesher Haziv, Israel
Posts: 12,470
Default Re: what is "auto lighting optimizer and hihglight tone priority"?

Quote:
Originally Posted by basroil View Post
2) a fake iso setting that underexposes an image then uses software to bring the highlights down and shadows the same.

both will kill your already pathetic buffer. if you shoot raw, no need for either.
Just for the sake of accuracy, it actually works the opposite: the highlights remain the same (with less exposure) and the shadows are boosted.

Since I shoot only RAW, I never use HTP, but for jpg shooters I think it might be quite useful if you are willing to except the reduction in continuous shot capacity (not everyone uses the camera like a machine gun) and are aware to the possibility of noise in the shadows if you are using a high ISO. Of course you can reduce exposure to prevent blowing out highlights and then adjust the shadows later in post-proccessing, but you risk posterization in the shadows (because jpgs are 8 bit) while HTP has the advantage of being done in 14 bit.

I am not familiar with "Auto Lighting Optimizer" (new with the 450D) but I suspect it might have the same 14 bit vs. 8 bit advantage.
__________________
Elie / אלי
"If you presume to love something, you must love the process of it much more than you love the finished product." John Irving, 5/2012. "In theory there is no difference between practice and theory, but in practice there is." Yogi Berra
Site

Last edited by tzalman : 16th of May 2008 (Fri) at 04:27.
tzalman is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 16th of May 2008 (Fri)   #5
apersson850
Cream of the Crop
 
apersson850's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Traryd, Sweden
Posts: 10,442
Default Re: what is "auto lighting optimizer and highlight tone priority"?

First, highlight tone priority does not reduce the capacity for continuous shooting. You are mixing it up with the noise reduction for high ISO setting.

Then, wheteher you like to say that it reduces exposure of highlights and keeps the shadows the same, or the other way around, is mainly a semantic thing. The effect is at least that the dynamic range in the recorded image is reduced, compared to the subject you are shooting, which means it's possible to have the shadows and highlights at the same time, without blowing the highlights. As nothing is for free, the penalty is that the shadows have to be closer to the highlight, so you'll get slightly more noise in the shadows, due to the amplification.

The auto lighting optimizer was first introduced in the 40D. But there you can't turn it on or off. Instead, it works in the pre-programmed modes only, but there always. It's supposed to help you getting details everywhere in the image, by compressing the dynamic range in the subject. Boost shadows and reduce highlights.

I haven't seen the technical details explained, but as far as I've understood, highlight priority reduces exposure of highlights, but lighting optimizer attacks both the highlights and deep shadows.
It seems reasonable to expect a better result when doing this whilst working with 14 bits, not 8.
__________________
Anders

Last edited by apersson850 : 6th of August 2010 (Fri) at 16:57.
apersson850 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 16th of May 2008 (Fri)   #6
Doug Pardee
Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Southern California, USA
Posts: 838
Default Re: what is "auto lighting optimizer and highlight tone priority"?

Quote:
Originally Posted by 10-Dee-Q View Post
What is "Auto Lightig Optimizer" ?
It's similar to having the camera do an "auto levels" adjustment on the image. This helps give the "ready to print" results that people have come to expect from digicams.

Quote:
What is "highlight Tone Priority" ?
HTP exposes the image at one ISO level below the indicated ISO level, thus increasing the amount of highlight headroom in Raw by one stop. The in-camera JPEG conversion then corrects for this, using a curve that gently compresses the extra highlights. Canon Raw converters presumably can do the same kind of correction—most third-party Raw converters don't and merely show the Raw file as being one stop underexposed.

Quote:
can you please tell me when i should turn them on or off ?
They're options because some people like them one way and some like them another. If you're shooting Raw, you probably will want to leave them both off. If you're shooting JPEG, then it depends on what settings give you the results that you like.

Quote:
i knew that we used to cover the vf when taking picture in bulb mode so thus the metering will be more accurate, but how about when taking pics with the liveview ?
do we still need to cover the vf ?
No, you don't need to. The reason that you cover the viewfinder in Bulb mode is to prevent stray light coming in the viewfinder opening from fooling the metering sensors in the viewfinder. Those metering sensors are not used in Live View mode, and the mirrors are up and blocking any light coming in the viewfinder from reaching the main sensor.
Doug Pardee is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 15th of September 2009 (Tue)   #7
apersson850
Cream of the Crop
 
apersson850's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Traryd, Sweden
Posts: 10,442
Default Re: what is "auto lighting optimizer and highlight tone priority"?

One thing to remember is that if you are using Auto Lighting Optimizer, it doesn't combine with exposure compensation.
The software will see the result of the picture, after exposure compensation, as too dark or too light, and fix accordingly after the exposure, but before you can look at the jpeg image. So it will counteract what you set the camera to do.

Highligh tone priority I typically use in high-contrast situations, which usually happen in strong sunlight or the opposite, in darkness in city environments, where lamps are very bright compared to the rest of the scene.
__________________
Anders
apersson850 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 30th of September 2009 (Wed)   #8
Joaaso
Member
 
Joaaso's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Oslo, Norway
Posts: 548
Default Re: what is "auto lighting optimizer and highlight tone priority"?

HTP is useful for raw-shooters as well, for those here who believe it only applies to jpg.. did a test myself last night to confirm it.. and it really starts to get interesting if you combine it with the "expose to the right" technique -gives you alot more room to play with...
__________________
Flickr
5D Mk II | 450D
EF 24-105
L | Samyang 14/2.8 | TS-E 24/3.5L II | Sigma 35/1.4 | EF 85/1.8 | EF 135L | EF 200/2.8L II | 1,4x TC
Joaaso is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 30th of September 2009 (Wed)   #9
Daniel Browning
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Vancouver, WA
Posts: 1,199
Default Re: what is "auto lighting optimizer and highlight tone priority"?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Joaaso View Post
HTP is useful for raw-shooters as well, for those here who believe it only applies to jpg.. did a test myself last night to confirm it.. and it really starts to get interesting if you combine it with the "expose to the right" technique -gives you alot more room to play with...
You are mistaken. When in manual mode, HTP produces the *exact* same raw file as if you reduce the ISO by one stop. In AE mode (Av, Tv, P, etc.) , HTP produces the exact same raw file as if you reduce the ISO by one stop and decrease EC by one stop.
__________________
Daniel
Daniel Browning is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 30th of September 2009 (Wed)   #10
Daniel Browning
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Vancouver, WA
Posts: 1,199
Default Re: what is "auto lighting optimizer and highlight tone priority"?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Joaaso View Post
and the raw files i got then were not the exact same as the non-htp at all..
Keep in mind that many raw converters do not show you what the raw file is really like. For example, Adobe (ACR and lightroom) applies a hidden exposure compensation to hide the effect of HTP. In other words, you have to set -1 EC in Adobe to see what the raw file would have been like before it applied the secret adjustment. If you want to see what the raw file is really like, try Rawnalyze.
__________________
Daniel
Daniel Browning is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 30th of September 2009 (Wed)   #11
Joaaso
Member
 
Joaaso's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Oslo, Norway
Posts: 548
Default Re: what is "auto lighting optimizer and highlight tone priority"?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Daniel Browning View Post
you have to set -1 EC in Adobe to see what the raw file would have been like before it applied the secret adjustment.
that I did do, and noise-levels became pretty much the same, but still there was alot less blown out highlights than the non-htp shot, so I can't see how they could be the exact same..
__________________
Flickr
5D Mk II | 450D
EF 24-105
L | Samyang 14/2.8 | TS-E 24/3.5L II | Sigma 35/1.4 | EF 85/1.8 | EF 135L | EF 200/2.8L II | 1,4x TC
Joaaso is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 30th of September 2009 (Wed)   #12
Daniel Browning
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Vancouver, WA
Posts: 1,199
Default Re: what is "auto lighting optimizer and highlight tone priority"?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Joaaso View Post
that I did do, and noise-levels became pretty much the same, but still there was alot less blown out highlights than the non-htp shot, so I can't see how they could be the exact same..
That could also be caused by Adobe's hidden highlight guessing ("recovery") algorithm. Most people think that the highlight guesser only applies when you use the "highlight recovery" slider, but Adobe also enables it when the exposure slider is used. (The exact rules and behavior is unknown to me.)
__________________
Daniel
Daniel Browning is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 30th of September 2009 (Wed)   #13
Joaaso
Member
 
Joaaso's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Oslo, Norway
Posts: 548
Default Re: what is "auto lighting optimizer and highlight tone priority"?

well i'm talking about blown highlights that are unrecoverable -my non-htp shot had some of it, the htp-shot didnt, when all other settings were the same.. even with 2 stop higher ISO, htp left me with less blown highlights in this particular scene.. and when that overexposure was counteradjusted in PP, the end result was alot less noisy than the non-htp shot..
__________________
Flickr
5D Mk II | 450D
EF 24-105
L | Samyang 14/2.8 | TS-E 24/3.5L II | Sigma 35/1.4 | EF 85/1.8 | EF 135L | EF 200/2.8L II | 1,4x TC

Last edited by Joaaso : 30th of September 2009 (Wed) at 04:57.
Joaaso is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 30th of September 2009 (Wed)   #14
Daniel Browning
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Vancouver, WA
Posts: 1,199
Default Re: what is "auto lighting optimizer and highlight tone priority"?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Joaaso View Post
well i'm talking about blown highlights that are unrecoverable -my non-htp shot had some of it, the htp-shot didnt,
OK, that rules out the highlight guessing software.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Joaaso View Post
...when all other settings were the same.. even with 2 stop higher ISO, htp left me with less blown highlights in this particular scene..
Are you certain that f-number, shutter speed, and scene luminance (i.e. brightness of the subject you are photographing) were exactly the same? If a cloud passed in front of the sun or something, it it could cause one to have less blown highlights than the other.

If you post the raw files (such as after you redo the test) I'd like to take a look at them.
__________________
Daniel
Daniel Browning is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 30th of September 2009 (Wed)   #15
Joaaso
Member
 
Joaaso's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Oslo, Norway
Posts: 548
Default Re: what is "auto lighting optimizer and highlight tone priority"?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Daniel Browning View Post
OK, that rules out the highlight guessing software. Are you certain that f-number, shutter speed, and scene luminance (i.e. brightness of the subject you are photographing) were exactly the same? If a cloud passed in front of the sun or something, it it could cause one to have less blown highlights than the other.

If you post the raw files (such as after you redo the test) I'd like to take a look at them.
yeah i was in manual, and this was inside my apartment at night, so no change in light... i'll test some more, look at it in rawnalyze and post it later today..
__________________
Flickr
5D Mk II | 450D
EF 24-105
L | Samyang 14/2.8 | TS-E 24/3.5L II | Sigma 35/1.4 | EF 85/1.8 | EF 135L | EF 200/2.8L II | 1,4x TC

Last edited by Joaaso : 30th of September 2009 (Wed) at 06:25.
Joaaso is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Highlight Tone Priority doema Canon EOS Digital Cameras 17 11th of March 2009 (Wed) 13:20
Lovin' Highlight Tone Priority TeeTee Canon EOS Digital Cameras 5 26th of March 2008 (Wed) 02:28
Highlight tone priority vs. Burst gasrocks Canon EOS Digital Cameras 16 3rd of November 2007 (Sat) 08:29
Highlight Tone Priority - 40D Grimm75 Canon EOS Digital Cameras 0 29th of September 2007 (Sat) 23:11
Lightroom and Highlight Tone Priority jwwill0 RAW, Post Processing and Printing 0 5th of July 2007 (Thu) 18:58


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 20:55.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.12
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
This forum is not affiliated with Canon in any way and is run as a free user helpsite by Pekka Saarinen, Helsinki Finland. You will need to register in order to be able to post messages. Cookies are required for registering and posting. HTML in messages is not allowed, plain website addresses are automatically made active by the board.