Mr. Clean wrote in post #10948841
Nick, as I've moved to primes, I've also moved to shooting more in C mode. Much like schmoelzel and his magical (not kidding) 85 1.2 shots I think it improves the keeper rate. Also, since the DOF is so very thin, I'm purposefully using an AF point on the face to focus on, or something along the same plane with contrast. I'll use any focus point I need to. My last paid shoot the max ISO I used looks like it was 5000 with every lens (24-70, 70-200, Sigma 24/50/150) but MOST of the shots were with the Sigma's between f1.8 and 5.6 and I'm happy with how everything performed.
AF assist beam won't work in C mode, so in low light situations that might be a problem. I also only shoot in C mode when needed, otherwise I stick with S. The most important thing is contrast and that's what I am trying to find out. How much contrast does the AF system need? Obviously what you saw on the maple cabinet wasn't enough contrast. That's surprising to me b/c the transition line is pretty clear...actually more clear in person.
Mr. Clean wrote in post #10948841
If it helps at all, and maybe Permie can post her settings as I don't have the camera with me right now, I'm essentially using the D700 as she set it up.
Focus/recompose is not the answer here. I don't think the D700 is that complicated. I have both AF-S and AF-C set to focus priority. IMO, the rest is pretty irrelevant at weddings. Correct me if I am wrong.
Mr. Clean wrote in post #10948841
In closing though, especially after a Mark III debacle (to be fair, I've had one that works grea), I've come to adjust my expectations of a cameras AF system and in that adjustment, I would not expect a camera to accurately focus 99% of the time on either a white wall or a maple cabinet with little to no contrast.
Yes, obviously a white wall isn't representative of real world shooting and of course I wouldn't expect any camera to be able to focus on it, hence I didn't shoot a white wall. But mono-tone subject with some texture/shadow is very real world. For instance, someone's face, a mono-tone dress with patterns, etc. What about a plain white wedding gown? What about an orange dress with ruffles. Good luck focusing on those things. Also, good luck focusing on those things when they are moving!
I'm just a little surprised that's all. 
