Todd Lambert wrote in post #12020613
I too have and use the slim on FF. I also have a non-slim 82mm CPL and it doesn't vignette or at least not that I've ever encountered.
I don't really see the point in getting the slim version honestly and if I had it to over again, I'd pass on the slim.
Butch Cassidy wrote in post #12020679
Todd, I wish that we had talked about the slim, I would not buy it again
GMCPhotographics wrote in post #12027694
Yes full frame. I used to use a Sigma 105mm polariser with a step adaptor. But the 82mm thread is fine for all filters, and oddly is fine for thin 77mm filters with a step adaptor.
Good information, gents,
Thanks a lot. Yep, i wrestled for quite a while trying to find out if I'd regret NOT getting the slim. I HAD intended to go FF in (for about 1yr now), so focused on buying appropriate lenses / filters, etc. Glad to know the 82 regular will do just fine if needed to purchase again. (I really don't like the cap required for the Slim versions at all).