I saw them too, and I have to agree with the others. They are definitely of sub-par quality. Why they would provide OP with unedited photos that are horribly underexposed and with WB that is waaaay off is beyond me.I would at least make an effort to correct the photos first before handing over proofs.
OP, did they actually shoot your wedding or did they subcontract? I checked out their website and I have to agree with you that what is represented in their portfolio section and what I am seeing from your wedding photos are vastly different in quality, including exposure and composition.
There are definitely some decent shots in there, but nothing really stand out. There are photos in there that are definitely salvageable via PP.
$3800? I wouldn't be happy either.
Disappointed to see this happen...but it always does to someone. Just sorry it was your turn.