Marketplace feedback bug (fixed)

Cormac wrote in post #18689290
That's all well and good. But I didn't realize this was an issue till recently. Missed out on feedback for a sale and a purchase. In the past few weeks.

You also can have an issue where someone maybe knowingly sells "less than advertised" condition gear, closes the thread and then won't/can't receive negative feedback.

carpenter wrote in post #18689522
You also can have an issue where someone maybe knowingly sells "less than advertised" condition gear, closes the thread and then won't/can't receive negative feedback.

That is possible to

Closed deal should not affect ability to give feedback. So if that is so then that is a bug and I'll get it fixed soon.

following

Cormac wrote in post #18688694
With this new feedback system why can you not give feedback after the thread is closed? I saw the option to give feedback before the thread was closed but wanted to wait to ensure proper item and timely shipment. Before giving feedback.

Or am I missing something?

Just to clarify, when you go to e.g. thread https://photography-on-the.net …/showthread.php​?t=1498960 you do not see a command "GIVE MARKETPLACE FEEDBACK TO potncharleswham" there?

Pekka wrote in post #18689639
Closed deal should not affect ability to give feedback. So if that is so then that is a bug and I'll get it fixed soon.

I suspect it's been this way since implementation?

Pekka wrote in post #18689651
Just to clarify, when you go to e.g. thread https://photography-on-the.net …/showthread.php​?t=1498960 you do not see a command "GIVE MARKETPLACE FEEDBACK TO potncharleswham" there?

Nope, this is what I see in pink.

HOSTED PHOTO
please log in to view hosted photos in full size.

Cormac wrote in post #18689658
I suspect it's been this way since implementation?

No, it has been so about three weeks when I corrected another bug in those permissions.
As mod I can give feedback there fine, so I missed that error.

This bug should now be fixed. Please report here if you encounter any more problems.

daleg wrote in post #18688867
Cannot understand why folks insist on fixing that which is simply not broken. The feedback system is another great example. I haven't a clue how this is supposed to work, or how it's deemed to be an improvement on a system that seed to work just fine.

It works like this: in the sale/buy thread click the GIVE MARKETPLACE FEEDBACK command. Submit the form (overall rating is the only required item). I do not honestly know how could that be made any simpler.

Old version:

One very long thread with one feedback per post. Search the thread if you want to find feedback. You have no stats, no logs, no messaging, no rating systems.

New version:

Comprehensive marketplace feedback system. Start giving feedback from the thread in question. Fully transparent to all members and member feedback stats and feedback can be viewed easily. Sort and filter. Member feedback stats always added to relevant places. 4 rating items (only 1 required), texts (not required), editable. Heads Up popups about every action to respective members.

Very clear stats output: https://photography-on-the.net …50&from=0&t=0&t​s=0&byto=0

Pekka wrote in post #18689673
This bug should now be fixed. Please report here if you encounter any more problems.

Tested the fix, looks good here.
It's 1:30 am here so if there is anything wrong with the fix, I'll handle in the morning.

As always, thanks for being so awesome Pekka!

It worked. I just left a good feedback for a member. Thank you for the good works Pekka

Yep. Appears to have been fixed! Thank you very much!!!