Rate the Photo Above You

This is lovely! I love the way the flowers on her shirt pick up the color of the leaves in the background. I'd like to see a crop with her more to the left of the frame, less centered, and I'm a little distracted by the skin of her ankle, but I'd be happy with this shot if I were her. 8/10

Photo from LauraBean's gallery.
Image hosted by forum (934794)

Nice Photo
the wall in the bottom left corner ruined it for me, otherwise I would've enjoyed the lovely color contrast you managed to produce!
6/10

Love the lighting and the filter I give it a 8.5/10

Jstud wrote in post #18719802
Love the lighting and the filter I give it a 8.5/10

Really like how u used the pink lines of the wall the frame in ur mcdel.. overall it's a good image only nitpick I have is the wall fights for visual attention... separating her off the wall and shooting shallow or using a gridded light on her and knocking down the rest... but it's still a good shot 7.5/10

jack880 wrote in post #18266260
Thanks a lot!

I know we're not supposed to rate the person who's just rated us, but firstly I love your image, and secondly this thread dies for months at a time so I wanted to keep it going.

9/10 - a very clever idea and really well executed. Very original.

IMAGE LINK: https://flic.kr/p/Rjyu​FU The Wild Garden by Jack Henriques, on Flickr

Love this... love the colors. The only thing I wish is the blue wasn’t cut off at the end. 9.75/10

IMAGE LINK: https://averymckenna.s​mugmug.com …nels/i-HDgD9rj/A&lb=1&s=A

Mainland Kennels

8/10 I really like this one. The only things that occurred to be were (a) might have cropped a bit differently (down from the top so less space would be given to the trees in the background), (b) would have been nice if the puppies' eyes could have been slightly more open (they look like they are about to fall asleep), & (c) perhaps a little bit more contrast. However, I find the image as a whole extremely appealing!

OK, here is one:

Photo from ozziepuppy's gallery.
Image hosted by forum (943857)

9/10

Would have been a 10 if the model had arranged her antennae in the vertical position

Lovely shot, stunning background (not sure how you did that in this one), beautiful butterfly and very yellow flower. What more does a macro-man need? Really nice.

I'll give you a butterfly back in return, though mine is not nearly so beautiful, sigh

Macroramphosis wrote in post #18749618
9/10

Would have been a 10 if the model had arranged her antennae in the vertical position

Lovely shot, stunning background (not sure how you did that in this one), beautiful butterfly and very yellow flower. What more does a macro-man need? Really nice.

I'll give you a butterfly back in return, though mine is not nearly so beautiful, sigh

Hosted photo: posted by Macroramphosis in
./showthread.php?p=187​49618&i=i59686871
forum: Critique Corner

Wow, thank you! Love the comment on the antennae! It was just one of those "accidental shots." I had just gotten the SL2 to take on a trip and decided to walk down the road and take random photos. I didn't even know butterflies were still around in October. It was also kind of breezy outside. I was very surprised and honestly can't take much credit at all, but I'm glad you liked it. I like yours also, but I know from the Rules of the game that I can't take another turn yet so will leave the rating etc. to someone else to keep the game going. . .

Edit PS: I see that your model has her antennae upright! Much more professional of her, lol!

Bailey lighthouse Sunset. Situated at Dublin bay Ireland

https://www.flickr.com …694/in/datepost​ed-public/

Apologies I couldn't figure out the right way to post image

Macroramphosis wrote in post #18749618
9/10

Would have been a 10 if the model had arranged her antennae in the vertical position

Lovely shot, stunning background (not sure how you did that in this one), beautiful butterfly and very yellow flower. What more does a macro-man need? Really nice.

I'll give you a butterfly back in return, though mine is not nearly so beautiful, sigh

Hosted photo: posted by Macroramphosis in
./showthread.php?p=187​49618&i=i59686871
forum: Critique Corner

Beautiful image. 8/10
I would like a slightly tighter crop. Beautiful colours.

LeoB1964 wrote in post #18749805
Beautiful image.

Hi Leo and welcome to POTN. What is expected in this thread is to rate the photo above yours on a 1-10 scale such as 9/10, 7.5/10, etc. You can also add critique stating reasons for your rating. If you will, please edit your post above to reflect this.

I'm not going to post a pic so I won't rate yours, but I like it. Beautiful scene!

Thank you for the welcome and pointing me in right direction. Will edit my post above now

LeoB1964 wrote in post #18749838

IMAGE LINK: https://www.flickr.com …694/in/datepost​ed-public/
40/52 Baily sunset by Leo Bissett on Flickr

7/10. Love the scenery, the leading line of the shore to the light house is also very nice.
However, your horizon is of several degrees to the right, it is lacking a bit of sharpness.

IMAGE LINK: https://flic.kr/p/23TY​Sfr