i have a sigma 30, a tamron 17-50 non-vc, and the canon 24-105L. i mostly use the L and love the quality and reach. f/4 is the limitation as we all know, but with a flash, its not terrible. for low light, i purchased the siggy. now, i find that my tamron is seldom used, and am wondering if i should sell it. there is alot of overlap with the 24-105, and i only get 7mm on the wide end.
sure, the tamron is faster, but i have the sigma for that. im torn between keeping the tamron and selling it (either replacing it with something else, or just pocketing the $$)
PS. ive thought about selling the 24-105 and the tammy, and buying the canon 17-55 with IS, but i love the reach on the tele side.