cpam.pix wrote:
Interesting how we can have such different points of view. With the boy away from Mom and Dad...especially with them out of focus...it gave me the feeling that the boy is exercising his independence by having some distance. Mom and Dad are being watchful and concerned parents...not sure if they are proud of this new independence or if they are slowly losing their roles as protector and caregiver.
I agree with this. I really like when the parents are OOF in the back. It is used in wedding photography too, having the parents in the back looking at their daughter all grown up. 
Samantha.Lovett wrote:
I agree that if number 2 had the parents standing together it would have a different feel, but I also agree with cpam.pix in that it gives a different kind of feeling. The parents and I probably have different feelings towards the photo than both of you because the little boy was actually chasing bubbles at the time (I think you can see some if you look closely) so we were all laughing and having a good time. However, as a stand alone picture, I understand and appreciate your thoughts.
Right
They have the memory of being there when the picture was taken so it has special meaning for them. I like it too, even though I wasn't there. I think the picture is successful because it makes the customer happy and reminds them of a fun day at the park with their son. I just thought that the difference of them standing side by side would be an extra little detail to make the picture one step better. You might try experimenting with several variations of placing people for a photo like that and see which one is most popular with the customers.
Over-all I think you made the customer happy and gave them some precious moments to save. 
Samantha.Lovett wrote:
Do you think that if I left the picture in colour it would give less of that distant feeling? Maybe with the colour it could portray a happier kind of atmosphere.
Possibly. It's worth a shot!
Oh and one suggestion to deal with all those Raw pics: I was thinking of archiving all my past Raws with CDs or DVDs so that they would be off my computer and out of sight/out of mind but available if I ever wanted to look back at previous work... that way I'm not completely cutting the cord and saying goodbye forever.