Which do you prefer?

Hey guys ,

Top pic is the original , bottom pic I took a much nicer sky from another photo of mine and put it in with layer masks.....which one you think I should keep?

thanks!

HTTP response: NOT FOUND | MIME changed to 'image/gif' | Redirected to error image by FLICKR

HTTP response: NOT FOUND | MIME changed to 'image/gif' | Redirected to error image by FLICKR

#1 for me. post work in #2 is looking more obvious

vamsiavala wrote in post #13106030
#1 for me. post work in #2 is looking more obvious

Agree

antonislap wrote in post #13106040
Agree

pic 1 for me too... although pic 2 has nicer colour but its too obvious...

I like sky from 2 but I can see it is blended in even on iPhone screen!!

Original pic. Maybe you could tweak the colours a bit in post, not change the whole sky?

i like #1 the best but around the top of the buildings on the right chimneys/roof i think theres a halo? im not 100% sure if its just the odd light but perhaps this should be cloned out. personally once i spotted it, it was distracting me from the picture in its entirety.

#1 for me

Drixar wrote in post #13106743
i like #1 the best but around the top of the buildings on the right chimneys/roof i think theres a halo? im not 100% sure if its just the odd light but perhaps this should be cloned out. personally once i spotted it, it was distracting me from the picture in its entirety.

#1
Same.. the haloing looks really strong.

ummm

Halo on the right chimney?

im trying to see a halo but i dont.....maybe can you guys crop it and post exacly where?


Thanks for all your replys guys!! appreciate it!

#1 it is then....any comments are welcome for pic number 1!

right about here.

hmmmm thats a bit odd...

I was using the standard 18-55mm lens for the shot , if I zoom in I can see a lot of chromatic abrasion (I think that is whats it called) the shot was shot with a 1000D.


I have cloned the halo out a little bit....is it better? is there no way to REDUCE the chromatic abbrasion? (since I took this photo i have got a nice 10-20mm cannon lense so my quality with future shots should be better!!


Thanks for the replys!

It's still pretty prominent. I enlarged the shot to ~100%, and i don't really see any CA's. You generally don't get them in a night/sunset shot.. moreso against a bright/white sky with trees/leaves, etc.

yep thats where im seeing it...on the edges of the roof and tree leaves by the sky!


anyways , thanks for the replys!

what program are you using to edit with? if you use photoshop you should be able to get rid of the entire halo without much trouble and a little patience.

it is definatly a little better on the 2nd edit though but as Kel said (1Tanker) it is still pretty prominent