HTC Asks If You Can Tell Which Image Was Shot With a Smartphone

7/10, but I didnt try that hard. Mostly just skimmed through. How's That workin out for you, HTC?

joeblack2022 wrote in post #14446274
Nope, I got 1/10 so I guess I'm not qualified to take photos with a smartphone...

...ha ha! I actually got 0 out of ten! Noone can get worse than that!

I retook the test a minute later and picked the opposite image to what I picked first time, and I still only got 8 out of ten!

I define the word dunce!!!

9 out of 10.

6/10 here. Wish the pictures could have been bigger.

i got 4/10 . but with that said, the comparisons were not fair. i was expecting the images to be the same scene or subject but comparing a landscape to a salt shaker is just not right. and the size of the images are too small

^^^ This ^^^

I got 5 of 10 but quickly lost interest in trying.

I don't have the phone they are advertising, but I do have an HTC 5 meg picture phone. It STINKS at pictures. Always very soft in focus and saturation.

Buy a phone for phone calls and buy a camera for picture taking.

They didn't even do an apples to oranges comparison, much less apples to apple Hmmm...let's put a macro next to a panorama and call that a useful comparison...<facepalm>

Or Apple's to Android's
Seriously, the 4 & 4s have amazing cameras!

8/10. Some were incredibly obvious, some not so much at such small size

Got 7 out of 7 and then quit. For me it was the dof that gave it away or blown highlights on a couple. For average snap shots, a camera phone does just fine. I was one of the big critics of phones with cameras... But now I am glad the two have merged. For snap shot type stuff most are more than capable of doing the job.

I got them all right, but it lied to me and said I got 8/10.

nekrosoft13 wrote in post #14422144
Not a good comparison at web size images

I got 7 out of 10

9/10 for me... guess I can pretty easily tell which ones were taken by their phone

Colorblinded wrote in post #14422724
They're all terrible!

That's the real problem I have with it. None of those photos are good enough for the average hobby-ist tog to be happy enough to publish anywhere.

Also, very few of the images utilise or show off the many significant advantages that a SLR camera has.

But... Did you expect anything more from an advertising campaign for a smart phone?

9/10 looking at them on my iPad. Pretty easy to spot, despite the pictures all being pretty bad as others have mentioned.