I think that to say that the first shot is too wide for an engagement shoot is like saying the ring shot doesn't have enough person in it. Not every shot has to do all things. The client gets ALL the (selected) photos in the end. And in my judgment, they'll be glad to have all of them.
Agree, with above.
About the 1) I do like this picture. The couple don't get lost in the scene, and it shows what a beautiful location is. We do see other pictures with couple hugging and interacting with each other in the set anyway.

