Grips...

To grip or not to grip.
That is the question

LowriderS10 wrote in post #14532579
Most people I know have NEVER used the AA magazine. And they certainly don't carry it around with them. It's a neat feature, but of all the grips I've had (4 so far), I've never once used the AA tray...

I thought the idea of the AA magazine was a huge plus. But I honestly don't remember if I've ever used them. I think I remember a few people saying they were happy to have them when needed as a backup but I also seem to remember the over all battery life wasn't what was expected.

Jon.

AAphotog wrote in post #14532617
Are you mad? I asked a question(out of curiosity) and you seem a bit mad about it. How are we to learn if we don't seek the knowledge to do so? I dont get the point of people who post rant responses with NO valuable information in them

Not mad at all. I just think these types of threads are always so asinine. They don't help anyone and always turn into a "well I use one and they rule!" vs "I threw mine away, they suck!" types of scenarios.

Not to mention that there's about 1400 threads on here already that have completely run their course on this exact subject. I think there's about one a week.

Todd Lambert wrote in post #14532651
Not mad at all. I just think these types of threads are always so asinine. They don't help anyone and always turn into a "well I use one and they rule!" vs "I threw mine away, they suck!" types of scenarios.

Not to mention that there's about 1400 threads on here already that have completely run their course on this exact subject. I think there's about one a week.

Then why not scroll past th thread? Instead, you insist on replying. For what? Not to mention the fact that you came back for a SECOND reply

I posted an opinion just as you and many others have here. Why is mine not allowed?

My opinion was not for or against, just another thought point, which is "why do you care"? That's a lot more insightful in my mind, than "yeah, grips are great" or "Grips are for posers".

But, I guess my anti-grip thread banter is unwanted and past my allowed quota, so yes, I guess I'll move onto one of the other dozen or so grip threads posted this week. Thanks!

Todd Lambert wrote in post #14532698
I posted an opinion just as you and many others have here. Why is mine not allowed?

My opinion was not for or against, just another thought point, which is "why do you care"? That's a lot more insightful in my mind, than "yeah, grips are great" or "Grips are for posers".

But, I guess my anti-grip thread banter is unwanted and past my allowed quota, so yes, I guess I'll move onto one of the other dozen or so grip threads posted this week. Thanks!

Well I was the original poster of this thread and you came in and ragged on it. Yes, your anti grip thread banter IS unwanted here. If you don't like them... Don't read them. Simple as that. You're welcome. Now please do as stated and move on

Ah bite me. I made a simple point that was as valid as any of the other insight you got in this thread. My main remarks were more about another poster in this thread an not directed at you. I simply made an added statement about my opinion of these types of threads. I wasn't mad and it was merely an opposing point. I'm sorry you got butt-hurt about it, but really, you need to lighten up. This is a discussion forum which means discussions from various viewpoints and even some (shocker) that might not agree with the OP's opinion (or lack thereof).

You solicited input, I gave it (and will continue to give it as I see fit).

I think there's a bit of poseur in some grip users. It makes them feel more 1 series like. That is the only way I can explain:

Gear list:

5DII gripped, 7D gripped, 24-70 f/4L 28-135 gripped...

It's still a XXXXXXD body and whether it has a grip or not is really immaterial to the photograph it takes. Yet those that have a grip seem to have a need to advertise this fact. Oh and the little red L's are quite cute too.

I use a grip simply for the better feel/balance of the camera and the portrait mode shutter button. I used 1D bodies for years, and am just used to the grip. I don't like the camera handling without it. I don't care about the extra battery life, as I typically only have one battery in there at a time. I think for most people it's a preference thing. I would suggest trying one out for a while if you can. I hate how the camera feels without a grip, but I'm sure there are plenty of people out there with exactly the opposite opinion.

Todd Lambert wrote in post #14532740
Ah bite me. I made a simple point that was as valid as any of the other insight you got in this thread. My main remarks were more about another poster in this thread an not directed at you. I simply made an added statement about my opinion of these types of threads. I wasn't mad and it was merely an opposing point. I'm sorry you got butt-hurt about it, but really, you need to lighten up. This is a discussion forum which means discussions from various viewpoints and even some (shocker) that might not agree with the OP's opinion (or lack thereof).

You solicited input, I gave it (and will continue to give it as I see fit).

Wow... back again? You don't like the threads(how many times have you been in this one?), then stated that you'll go to one of the others created this week(there are a dozen of them. sarcastic I thought, but actually thought you'd be leaving this one.) yet you're back AGAIN?!?! Ok, feel free to talk as much as you please. Maybe you'll feel better about yourself. You win!


PS. if you read my post, I asked about WHY peopple like and get them. The response that I got, told me just that(except for yours). This topic wasn't full of "well I use one and they rule!" & "I threw mine away, they suck!" like you stated they always are

casaaviocar wrote in post #14532746
I think there's a bit of poseur in some grip users. It makes them feel more 1 series like. That is the only way I can explain:

Gear list:

5DII gripped, 7D gripped, 24-70 f/4L 28-135 gripped...

It's still a XXXXXXD body and whether it has a grip or not is really immaterial to the photograph it takes. Yet those that have a grip seem to have a need to advertise this fact. Oh and the little red L's are quite cute too.

I'm hearing you.

I'm the odd man out as well. I've had grips before but more often than not they stay in the cupboard at home. Unless you're doing a lot in portait orientation, they aren't worth the bother.
The often dragged out battery issue is a non event, most of the newish models & rack off 1000 photos per battery charge & if that aint enough a spare battery in your bag is pretty simple.

One of the reasons I went 1dmkiv to 5dmkiii is to have a lighter package, mainly for travelling & hiking.

AAphotog wrote in post #14532770
Wow... back again? You don't like the threads(how many times have you been in this one?), then stated that you'll go to one of the others created this week(there are a dozen of them. sarcastic I thought, but actually thought you'd be leaving this one.) yet you're back AGAIN?!?! Ok, feel free to talk as much as you please. Maybe you'll feel better about yourself. You win!


PS. if you read my post, I asked about WHY peopple like and get them. The response that I got, told me just that(except for yours). This topic wasn't full of "well I use one and they rule!" & "I threw mine away, they suck!" like you stated they always are

Hehehe, ah man.. you're a gem. You make a post about something, asking for input. You get input that you don't agree with and then you don't want to hear any more input. Uh, huh.

Again, if you feel like you have a need for a grip, then why bother asking others about theirs? If you're truly on the fence, then try one out and make up your own mind.

Asking about something as subjective as grips, is very closely akin to mac vs pc or chevy vs ford. What's the point?

But, to bring this trainwreck back on track, there are tons of very valid reasons (mostly already mentioned) about why someone would want a grip. Some like the added comfort, other like the weight, others like the balance, most like having another shutter button and AF selector, while others need the extra/backup power capacities that they offer.

I like and continue to buy the 5D line because it allows me to decide when or if I want to have a full-sized gripped body or travel lighter/small with the compact body instead. That's a very nice capability to have and one that many people enjoy.

Todd Lambert wrote in post #14532597
You're not tHe poster child for everyone though. There are many of us who do use the extra battery capacity and yes, I do carry the AA tray ith me and it's saved me several times.

I don't get the point of these threads which pop up all the time. What does it matter if you can't see a use for a tool in your workflow? There tons of different reasons why people want/need grips and they're made for a reason. If that reason isn't for you then it's not for you.

Todd, buddy! You went on a big rant about blocking me a while ago...what happened with that?

Either way, I never claimed to be the poster child...the OP asked for input and I shared with him my views as well as what I have seen...seems like a more appropriate response than much of what you've been posting

Back on topic...I've never used a grip with the AA tray. What is the point of it? Having never used one, I assume the AA tray takes place of the normal battery. Is it something that you use in an "oh crap" moment where you run a grab some AA batteries?

I ask because it just seems simpler to carry a few spare LP-E6 batteries than lug around a tray in case something goes wrong. I think the AA batteries will be heavier too (unless you carry them anyway for a flash, etc...)

LowriderS10 wrote in post #14532804
Todd, buddy! You went on a big rant about blocking me a while ago...what happened with that?

Either way, I never claimed to be the poster child...the OP asked for input and I shared with him my views as well as what I have seen...seems like a more appropriate response than much of what you've been posting

Nah, I only keep block lists for two weeks.

I agree, everyone posted the same comments that always get posted in these threads. Not sure why I even opened the thread honestly, but since I did and I'm now invested, might as well ride it out.

Gregg.Siam wrote in post #14532815
Back on topic...I've never used a grip with the AA tray. What is the point of it? Having never used one, I assume the AA tray takes place of the normal battery. Is it something that you use in an "oh crap" moment where you run a grab some AA batteries?

I ask because it just seems simpler to carry a few spare LP-E6 batteries than lug around a tray in case something goes wrong. I think the AA batteries will be heavier too (unless you carry them anyway for a flash, etc...)

There's been times when a battery went bad, or when you're down to your last two LP-E6s and you're hiking in the back country.. most photographers have a ton of Eneloops (I do) and so if for any reason, my LP-E6s fail me, get lost, etc.. at least I'm not dead in the water.

I do know that I've gone out on a photo expedition (drove 8 hours out into them middle of nowhere, took out my camera and found I had not batteries - left them at home). I had 2 dozen AAs and I was able to shoot my entire trip still. Good luck getting LP-E6s out on the road. You can however find AAs just about anywhere.