which one?

Any one have any thoughts?

HTTP response: 404 | MIME changed to 'text/html' | Byte size: ZERO

HTTP response: 404 | MIME changed to 'text/html' | Byte size: ZERO

While I like the top one, I think the bottom one would really pop in a metallic print. Both are nice photos.

Cheers Thorrulz.

Anyone else have any thoughts?

Liking the first one.

I'm going for the color version...

But, it depends on the purpose of why we're choosing.

I would definitely say the colored one. Try cropping the image from bottom just a little bit, you might get fantastic results. I really like the image, the contrast of grass and the sky is fantastic.

I think cropping the bottom as mentioned above is a good idea, but I'd also stretch the top right side to straighten the building lines somewhat.

FIRST! It's really good composition wise and the structure in b&w is a clear winner. I would even make it even harsher, maybe [But not sure].

osh_sekta wrote in post #14623956
FIRST! It's really good composition wise and the structure in b&w is a clear winner. I would even make it even harsher, maybe [But not sure].

Yeap, I'd agree a little more contrast would make the black and white killer.

But I actually prefer the colour

Agree with most comments, a little more tweaking with the b/w shot, but the coloured one stands out for me.

Locton wrote in post #14624033
Agree with most comments, a little more tweaking with the b/w shot, but the coloured one stands out for me.

Yep, that contrast between the blue sky and the warm glow of the sun is just too effective. The black and white image is great, but it's worse.

I like the first.
The b&w makes a more powerful pop than the colored.

Cheers guys - in the end the colour one just didn't work for me so I settled on this version.