Does this look too edited/HDR?

I was playing around with this picture in lightroom. I personally love the look of an HDR style picture, and sometimes get carried away with clarity, saturation, and the like. Did this picture turn out looking too "edited"? Or does it still look alright?

not liking the vig on this

I cant say much as I havent edited a thing in my life. but the left side looks way to dark in comparison to the right. it just has an unnatural look to it

Not bad, but its overexposed way too much, what you tried to do on the left side is add in dark where the light is blown out and it can be seen on most of the rocks where the light is hitting! Doesn't look great! Try it again!!

not tto bad. Some wierd blue color in top right.

Nice pic and great subject matter. IMO the right side of the image is good but the left is not good at all. The main things are the grey rock surface to the screen left of the passenger side front wheel and the weird loooking texture on the tree trunk, I'm afraid they don't work for me at all.

StayFrosty wrote in post #15044159
Nice pic and great subject matter. IMO the right side of the image is good but the left is not good at all. The main things are the grey rock surface to the screen left of the passenger side front wheel and the weird loooking texture on the tree trunk, I'm afraid they don't work for me at all.

Exactly what I was going to say.