Maggie_B wrote in post #15294836
Hey there, no raining or parading here

I am guilty of finding inspiration in fashion magazine covers where it is so common to cut the top of the head that my crop tool just automatically goes there

Good point though, for a framed portrait I may be inclined to include it.
Mag
Cropping a shot is an artistic freedom, and it is up to the photographer to decide how a given shot is presented.
I get a lot of comments to my pictures like " nice.... except for the cropped fingers, hand, knee, sholder..... Bla. Bla.".
No - you crop as you like, and there is NO ROULES on how a perfect crop should be. In the old days, where everything ended up on photographic paper, some old portrait painters had their ideas, but .... forget it. We are in the next century, and the medium is not silver coated paper or paint.
To all of you "do not crop this and that" fanatics, I must say: if you comment on any given cropping, then the shot is perfect. Cropping is the most insignificant parameter to a picture, given that everything else is ok. So cropping remarks is to me the same as thumbs up.