Legs

which one do you prefer?

Color.

The shoes and the wine are just too appealing to throw away those colors.

My only nitpick is the graduation from light to shadow on the bottom half of her leg, the way it's slightly twisted makes that gradient uneven and a tiny bit distracting, and the little bulge peeking over the edge of the heel. But that's only if I'm actively looking for a thing to critique.

nathancarter wrote in post #15459115
Color.

The shoes and the wine are just too appealing to throw away those colors.

My only nitpick is the graduation from light to shadow on the bottom half of her leg, the way it's slightly twisted makes that gradient uneven and a tiny bit distracting, and the little bulge peeking over the edge of the heel. But that's only if I'm actively looking for a thing to critique.

+1 ditto

Color 100% like the way the colors blend together.

Color!
I love B&W for shots like this but you NAILED the colors on this!

definitely the color. to me it is more appealing.

thanks for the input everyone. i had my wife wear red shoes since i intended to shoot this for black and white and new t would how up better. the wine is diluted apple juice.

i see how the colors came out and i am just torn myself.

Nicely done. Color for sure.

Nice capture. Prefer the color!

A woman can never go wrong with red shoes.

Both are great shots but the color shot is my favorite IMHO!

this is interesting i posted this on another site and the consensus there was B/W here its unanimous to the color. Granted they are a more composition orientated crowd.

Color!

Color clearly wins, but since the legs are OOF shouldn't the picture be re-named??

Beautiful shot! - color