Critique pleasse

Critique these photos please.
the composition, and the Post processing work
1.

#1, did you intend the tower thing behind the car to be part of the photo? It seems a bit carelessly placed what with being partly hidden by the car. If you'd moved to the left so as to have both the car and the structure isolated, it would have been a stronger composition IMO.

#2, the car is facing the wrong way. It should be facing "into" the frame, not out.

#both, the PP looks strange to me. You have odd bits that are brighter, like halos, but not just around edges. The reflections on the car seem "smudged" in places (especially in #2 on the driver's door and the front bumper). The car doesn't have enough space under its front wheel in both shots and not enough space on the right in #1. The location is not the most glamorous and looks a bit cluttered (background) with random poles and houses sticking out of the hills.

I agree with above... #1 has too much weight on the right and then empty void on the left. Step to the left and turn to get the water tank out of the center. #2 the car is ready to drive right out of the frame.
Pp doesn't look bad to me but I am on my phone so I can't see the detail...

Have to agree the pp looks a little odd, halo's/colours. I don't mind the water tank in the shot, but 1st shot there is a lot of clutter in the background. I would have moved to the right a little and shot from a much lower angle. 2nd shot front of the car is far to close to the r/h/s of thr frame. Again the background is to cluttered, shot from a lower angle loosing the buildings.

thanks guys.
your comments really helpd me

I agree with the above. Good start here. Don't forget that the little things are important, too.
In #2, you have the halo around the water tank, the wheel is turned the wrong way, & I'd have picked up the stick under the bumper.
OTOH, the highlights in #1 are very nice, which is what most people here get wrong, so you're on the right track. I'd have tried one with the parking lights on, too.
It doesn't look bad, but think about doing something with the License plate.

Looks like that car was in an accident - or is that messed up bumper a result of some pp editing?

I see the car as a record shot only. I suspect that without the car the landscape might be more interesting

2 is better. the small tower in 1 is really distracting. for 2, I think you can leave more space on the right side instead of left